Hog Hunting - Close Combat!

Hog hunting with dogs and a knife?


  • Total voters
    191
Status
Not open for further replies.

K3

Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2006
Messages
1,508
Location
Looking through the scope at a coyote
Now that Art has put the Muy Thai thread out of its misery :D, I'm interested to see who has hunted/killed hogs up close and personal.

Knives and dogs being the preferred method. If you haven't, would you want to? See poll.
 
Rob Pincus from the Valhalla shooting school did the dogs'n'knife thing, back in 1999 or thereabouts.

I really don't think I'd have tried that, even back when I was younger, dumber and healthier. :)
 
Rob Pincus from the Valhalla shooting school did the dogs'n'knife thing, back in 1999 or thereabouts.

I really don't think I'd have tried that, even back when I was younger, dumber and healthier.

I wasn't keen on it myself, and I'm in decent shape, but the guy I was hunting with convinced me to try it. The predator hunting was bad because of wind, and he thought I'd have more fun with hog hunting instead of calling when critters were laid up. He was right. I got 3 hogs, but the biggest was only 150#. Only. :D The catch dogs did a pretty good job.
 
Getting up close and personal with a big 250lb+ hog is not something for the faint of heart. I enjoyed it a lot back in the day, but have grown up and grown smarter since those days.
 
I have done a couple of times and it was very exciting and I would recomend it to anybody looking for a new and thrilling way to harvest and animal.
 
It is a stupid practice...

Period.

There are several people that have been maimed and one story wherein the guy lost one of his balls. As said above, it is a stupid thing to do. After it is over, you are not more macho. I liken this to hunting pornography. If I did that kind of stuff short of having to, my grandfather would look down from the great hereafter and be disappointed in me.

Just my $0.02.
 
Knew a guy that ran dogs. I went with him a few times and stuck a pig. He had a pet lion, used to feed 'em to the lion. I just went along with him. It's pretty physical stomping through rice field and I'm a lot less physical now days. I'd rather shoot 'em in the trap or at the most, from a stand. :D

Incidentally, this guy used a fillet knife, stuck 'em in the throat to cut the carotid.
 
Have you ever done it MBT2001...If not than all you have are stories to back up your line of thinking. I take some offense to you calling it stupid. At the end of the day I didn't feel more macho so you are right there. I also didn't go out and do it to feel macho. I did because it was something that I wanted to say that I had done when I look back and guess what now I can. The guys I go with have really good dogs there are always at least three people and you wouldn't believe how safe it actually is when you know you are doing. I am sure there are a lot of horror stories out there but I have yet to expierence one. Maybe that day will come but I try like hell to stay away from the buisness end of a hog. Besides that before you go rushing in there you make damn well sure that your catch dog has a mouth full of pig head and you grab the hog by the back legs. Once you have him by the back legs hes yours no matter what you want to do with it. We once brought home a 450lb russian home live with no injuries to even the dogs. So these stories you heard maybe from a group of STUPID guys but that doesn't make the whole practice stupid.
 
In a survival role I'd probably go for it with spear with knife as backup.
Hogs is mean! And I likes me testicals right where they are -thank you!:D

I'd hunt hogs with pistol at close range.

I wish I'd have taken my Blackbear with pistol. Could have, but the rifle was in my hand. I don't know if it'd make me feel more macho if I did. Taking Deer at close range with pistol hasn't.

Killin somethin with a knife might make more guys (or gals), feel more like a bad a$$ I guess. I don't think it's a smart move, to put yourself in harms way to make a kill. I hunt for meat, and occasionally get rewarded with a trophy. That's enough for me.

-Steve
 
3pairs12, same here, did it because I'd never done it and I got invited and, well, if you never do it, you won't be able to say you did. I raced Daytona on motorcycles for the same reason. That's pretty dangerous if you don't know what you're doing, too. :D Of course, you don't get a license in that case. Not just anyone gets an AMA pro license.

Oh, I ain't gonna say hog hunting with a knife and dogs ain't dangerous. The hog CAN get loose of the dogs. It happens. I know a guy that has a scar from his navel to his left nipple from just such an incident. The guy I went with had a suture kit on him for the dogs. He's had dogs torn up pretty good before. Hog guys take care of the dogs, cost a lot in time and money.

BUT, hunting 'em this way, while not as safe as sitting in your tripod stand and sniping 'em from 50 yards, isn't all THAT dangerous. I mean, it's not a suicidal sport. I've never heard of anyone killed by a hog. The hog generally, if he gets loose, will take a few swipes at whatever's near by and high tail it outta Dodge. They aren't about to try fighting to the death with a pack of dogs and humans. I can believe the story about the guy being one nutted, for instance. Hey, it happens. If I got cut up, I'd heal. That motorcycle racing thing I did for all those years and still dabble in has had me laid up more'n once, casts and stuff. I got over it. Ernest Hemmingway ran with the bulls, same sort of thing. I won't say it makes you feel more "macho", but some folks like adrenalin. Just put it that way. For all I've been able to do in my life, I ain't flying to Pamplona, Espana to get chased by a toro. I have my limits. :D
 
Last edited:
Yes. A WWI Colt 1911 reproduction in .45 ACP. Distance...far side of a pine tree. It wasn't one of my smarter moments. Face-to-face with a Russian boar isn't a smart situation.

It was much smarter when I carried my Encore pistol.
 
MC I wasn't saying it can't get dangerous because I know it can. It just helps when you are with good dogs and people who know what they are doing. It just irks me when somebody that hasn't done it can call something stupid only knowing third hand stories. As far as racing Daytona you sir definitely are braver than I maybe more "macho" too :)
 
If any of you embark on this adventure Id hope you are a big boy with some lean mass on your frame and some steel toe's on otherwise you'll be at the mercy of the beast..
 
If you are not interested in doing it, fine don't do it. I know people who race cars or motorcycles. Not really my cup of tea, but I don't go around calling the stupid. I know others who sky dive, haven't done it yet, but think it sounds fun. I killed a few with a knife, I also helped to live catch a few. Now there is a certain element of risk, but if you want to live your life "safely" then stay home, cover yourself with bubble wrap, and "ENJOY".
 
Ok, let's get this straight the "hunters" are dependant on the athleticism, strength and talent of the dogs to run the hogs, corner and catch them.

I have seen it done in an ethical manner (in Hawaii and Africa), I have seen it done the opposite. You may be doing it one way, but as a rule I am not that interested (outside of a survival situation) in doing it.

As to having offended you, I honestly do not care. I made no rude remarks, merely stated my opinion on what I view to be a negative practice, one that certainly doesn't enhance the PR image of hunters in a PC society.
 
view to be a negative practice, one that certainly doesn't enhance the PR image of hunters in a PC society.

I never worried to much about that. I've been chastised much worse as unethical by HUNTERS for using a feeder. You use a feeder? I took no offense to any comments, BTW.

In the end, all the PETA vegetarian types want to end ALL hunting. They sensationalize anything they can, it's their MO. I often wonder how they can pull a potato out of the ground and live with theirselves. I mean, a potato is no less a living creature than a human. Yet, you see movies about slaughter houses and chicken houses, not potato farms or potato chip manufacturers. Heck, I don't even know if the PETA morons even KNOW people hunt with knives. I know they were on a binge after bow hunters for a while. That didn't work for 'em, either. I think their cause is a losing cause. The general public isn't yet that stupid and people ain't ready to give up their hamburgers and leather jackets. Lets face it, naugahyde wears rapidly and tofu tastes like crap.
 
MTB2001 These wild hogs aren't even a game game animal so as far as ethical treatment I don't care. I am not to worried about that. Guess what the live hog was used for... training other dogs. Thought you may like to know that. I have also hunted them onpublic land with out the use of dogs archery only. You labeling a group of people as "hunters" relying on dogs is "ignorant". In my opinion. Here in Texas the FERAL hog caused $1,000,000 dollars a week in damage to agriculture and/or livestock. So killing them by any means is pretty much legal. So as far as PR goes when PETA starts paying my bills maybe I'll care about the treatment of a non game animal a little more.
 
It is a stupid practice...

Period.

There are several people that have been maimed and one story wherein the guy lost one of his balls. As said above, it is a stupid thing to do. After it is over, you are not more macho. I liken this to hunting pornography. If I did that kind of stuff short of having to, my grandfather would look down from the great hereafter and be disappointed in me.

Just my $0.02.


Ok, let's get this straight the "hunters" are dependant on the athleticism, strength and talent of the dogs to run the hogs, corner and catch them.

I have seen it done in an ethical manner (in Hawaii and Africa), I have seen it done the opposite. You may be doing it one way, but as a rule I am not that interested (outside of a survival situation) in doing it.

As to having offended you, I honestly do not care. I made no rude remarks, merely stated my opinion on what I view to be a negative practice, one that certainly doesn't enhance the PR image of hunters in a PC society.

Might wanna go read your own words (stupid, macho, liken it to pornography etc). BTW you didn't offend me. I could not care any less about your opinion. Just think it sad that so many folks cannot live and let live. You do your thing your way, I will do mine my way, and until you or I infringe upon the rights of another person then it should not be anyone's business. Further more as for the PR image, again I am not worried about damaging the Image of people who hate hunting, guns, and hunters to begin with!
 
The dogs do the work. Get some catahoulas to flush them and a kill dog (such as a pit bull) to strangle it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top