Hornady .357 Magnum 135gr Critical Duty FTX in Clear Ballistics Gel.

Status
Not open for further replies.

5pins

Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2003
Messages
240
xRC3b97l.jpg

Test Gun: Smith and Wesson model 65.

Barrel length: 3 inches.

Ammunition: Hornady .357 Magnum 135gr Critical Duty FTX.

Test media: 10% Clear Ballistics Gel.

Distance: 10 feet.

Chronograph: PACT 1 XP with inferred sky screens.

Five shot velocity average: 1227fps.

Gel Temperature 70 degrees.

After trying out the Hornady CD 135gr 9mm non +P I have to admit I wasn’t very impressed and thought to myself that I probably not try any Critical Duty again. But all that was replaced when the FBI announced recently that it had pick the 135gr +P version in 9mm. If the FBI picked it how bad could it be? Maybe the non +P is just the one bad apple in the line (which is what I suspect) and maybe I should give the +P version a try. So I ordered some and will be trying it out soon. Until then, a coworker gave me some of the 135gr in .357 to try and I will have to say it performed much better.


I have started to start shooting five rounds over the chronograph for an average and shoot it at 7 yards for point of aim. In this case, I got a five shot average of 1227 and the group was hitting low by about one inch. In the picture, you will see the group at the bottom of number 6 but I was aiming at number 3.

AdwpT0Ml.jpg

The first round into the bear gel had a velocity of 1224fps and penetrated to 17.25 inches with an expansion of .52 inches. Round two also expanded to .52 inches but only penetrated to 16.5 inches with a velocity of 1215fps. Both bullets tumbled at some point and came to a rest base forward.

hsnc96xl.jpg

The first round in the heavy clothing covered gel hit at a velocity of 1214fps and penetrated to 19.5 inches with an expansion of .47 inches. Number two’s velocity was 1224fps and it expanded to with a penetrating of 18 inches. The first round came to rest base forward but the second one did not tumble and stayed front forward.
UO2Mh7Il.jpg

The recovered weight of all the bullets was 135grs with the plug.

VYdm7h2l.jpg
 
That's pretty decent velocity for a 3 inch barrel. Might have to try those in my M60 Pro, 3 inch. How was recoil?
 
I believe Hornady only advertises 1275fps from an 8" bbl so to get 1227 from a snub is awesome. Im not sure why they loaded them so soft?
 
Maybe you have covered this with another round... but have you ever pulled the plug out and tested the CD on gel? I carry the 135grn CD 9mm (non-+P) in my carry guns, and I've often thought about pulling the plug out... or just switching to XTP's.
 
Maybe you have covered this with another round... but have you ever pulled the plug out and tested the CD on gel? I carry the 135grn CD 9mm (non-+P) in my carry guns, and I've often thought about pulling the plug out... or just switching to XTP's.

Can I ask what the purpose of this would be? The plug serves a purpose, and I'm fairly certain the bullet was designed around having a polymer tip for the hydraulic properties it provides during impact.
 
After seeing how they performed yesterday I decided to give them the four layers of denim challenge. I have seen numerous bullets perform well in bare and heavy clothing only to fail the FLD test. I didn’t set up the chrony for this test so no velocity reading this time. The first round penetrated to 21.5 inches and expanded to .41 inches. Round tow exited the right side block at about the 20-inch mark and was found on the floor. It had expanded to .44 inches. Since the second round left the block I decided to shoot a third. It penetrated to 17.75 inches and expanded to .49 inches.

Ot3HwMZl.jpg
 
4 layers of denim is quite an obstacle, those .357 bullets did pretty darn well with that test.

I can’t wait to see the 135gr +P 9mm in comparison.

Thanks for the posts.
 
Good performance by these rounds. Thanks for doing the tests.

Thing is, a moderate to hot .357mag hollow point will expand, no need for premium bullets. The old-school Rem 125gr and 158gr SJHP rounds perform terrifically in all the tests I have seen, through bare gel and clothing. Makes me think that the reputation of the .357mag 125gr & 158gr HP was made mostly because they had enough velocity for the HP to work as designed.
 
I believe Hornady only advertises 1275fps from an 8" bbl so to get 1227 from a snub is awesome. Im not sure why they loaded them so soft?

Huh, only like 100 fps more than the +p 9mm? Seems kinda ... weak ... to me.

Though the gel tests look good, thanks for posting it 5pins.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top