How many rounds before you trust A CENTERFIRE REVOLVER for carry?

Status
Not open for further replies.
H

halvey

Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2004
Messages
1,914
There's all kinds of threads saying 'I run 200 (or 500, or 100) rounds of defense ammo in my (whatever brand) semi-auto before I trust it to carry'.

Well, what is a good number for a centerfire wheelgun, used for concealed carry?
 
A lot of times it's not the gun that needs the "break in" It's the Mags.
I have a 1911 that I've had for years and who knows how many rounds.
If I pick up a new set of mags I use them at the range for quite a while before I trust them for carry.
There's no set time or round count. I just get that warm fuzzy feeling they're ok. It's the same with a new gun.
But remember a gun is a mechanical device. It can fail or break anytime without a bit of warning. 500 rounds of flawless performance doesn't mean it won't fail on round 501 or round 10,165. Part of it is a crap shoot.

AFS
 
Well, I hate 1911s. Two of the biggest POSs I ever owned were an AMT hardballer, and worse, a Auto Ordinance 1911. The AO would NOT fire anything, but ball and wasn't really 100 percent with that! I'd get a stove pipe occasionally. Sold it at a gun show. I got the hardballer 100 percent, after a trip to a gunsmith, with ball. I also loaded a 200 grain SWC for it, had to load it out to head space on the rifling to get the OAL long enough, though. That gun was real OAL dependent. Want a jam every round, try CCI Lawman 200 grain JHP (old flying ashtrays).

I've never had a jam with my Ruger P90, feeds any and everything I've ever tried in it 100 percent and is awesome accurate. I like having confidence in a firearm.

I own just 4 autos that have proven reliable to me. I really prefer to fire hundreds of rounds in competition (IDPA) if I have the choice before I rely on 'em. I have done that with my Kel Tec P11, my Ruger P85, and my P90. I have a lot more revolvers than I do autos, but my Rugers have proved to be about as reliable. Now, I've never tried any Sigs, know Glocks are reliable, hear great things about CZ, but I'm a revolver guy at heart and I got the Rugers because I like Rugers. They have not disappointed me. But, when it comes down to a social encounter, I know my revolvers aren't gonna jam. Those 1911 POSs still haunt me. I'll never own another, not in my lifetime. I don't like cocked and locked anyway, prefer DA with a decocker if I carry auto or DAO especially in a pocket auto.

If someone forced me to carry a 1911, I could put 2K rounds trouble free through it and still not trust it. LOL
 
With semi autos I shoot about 100 rounds of my carry ammo choice while limp wristing, offhand, sideways etc.

With a good revolver I run a box or ammo through and call it a day.

Chris
 
After a break in period I require 100 flawless rounds. I do this for both semi-auto and revolver as I have had a revolver start light striking before.
 
Well, what is a good number for a centerfire wheelgun, used for concealed carry?
Click to expand...

Lots of answers about semi auto pistols including 1911s. The question was about centerfire wheelguns....:rolleyes:

My answer: five or six, depending on the revolver.
 
Lots of answers about semi auto pistols including 1911s. The question was about centerfire wheelguns....

My answer: five or six, depending on the revolver.
Click to expand...


And I believe my answer was....
I just shoot my carry load for accuracy, fire a few rounds off hand for fun, good to go. You ain't gonna get any stove pipes in a revolver or FTEs or such. Six (or five) for sure.
Click to expand...
 
50-60 rounds through a wheelie will do.....IMHO.

On revolvers you just need to make sure your gun is okay with the primers in the ammo. Some wheel guns (very rare mind you) will pop a primer. This will cause a pain the rear lock-up.

I have never had this happen to me but have seen it happen once.
 
I take my carry weapon a Taurus PT145 (45ACP) Millennium Pro and/or my Taurus PT1911 (45ACP) with me whenever I go to the range. I shoot 200rnds+ around once a month. I've had only FTE with the PT145 when I purposly limp wristed it. I don't trust a new firearm until I've shot multiple types of ammo through it and at least 600rnds or 3 range sessions or so. I'm not talking about break in I'm talking about trusting that it will work. When I go to the range it is in my IWB with one in the tube I pull it out and it goes bang bang bang every time! Yea I know they aren't Revolvers if they were I'd probably be fine with shooting a box of 50rnds or so and then just get better with it.
 
I don't have a set amount of rounds, but I do check the following before trusting a revolver to carry -- and I do CCW revolvers on a daily basis here in Sunny Califor-ni-a.
1. REMOVE SIDEPLATE AND TAKE A LOOK AT THE LOCKWORK. Make sure trigger and hammer engagement points look okay, make sure springs are factory. I will not carry a revolver that has had the springs shaved down, or altered in anyway. Replacement Wolff springs are fine but no altered springs!
2. Check timing of revolver for any significant issues.
3. Check end shake. Excessive endshake WILL RESULT IN LIGHT STRIKES.
4. Locktite. sideplate screws with a light grade of locktite.
5. Make sure ejector rod is tightly threaded (not applicable to GP100,SP101Rugers.)
6. Check for speedloader clearance on left grip panel.
7. Check cylinder gap for dragging. I have yet to see a factory revolver with a cylinder gap that was too large, ie., so big it was a problem. I have seen several where the cylinder dragged on the forcing cone.
8. Shoot the gun enough to get it hot rapidly. Some guns will lock up when they get hot, or will have trigger return problems, or will have cylinder drag problems from the gas ring swelling up.
9. Shoot the gun to confirm suffiicient accuracy and POI v. POA.

If the revolver passes all these inspection points, it then goes into service subject to regular maintenance and inspection. And LOTS of shooting!
 
Two of the biggest POSs I ever owned were an AMT hardballer, and worse, a Auto Ordinance 1911.
Click to expand...

Well, there is your problem with 1911's McGunner. :neener:

Some folks just don't like em and if you have had a bad experience, it's hard to try them again.

Your advice, which is go with what you are comfortable with and have faith in, is very sound. :)

I love 1911's, and have a couple I would, and do, carry, but I would be comfortable with a couple of wheelguns I have as well.

Auto: When I get the "warm fuzzy" feeling.

Wheelgun: A few cylinder fulls.
 
Enough to make YOU comfortable with its operation: loading, unloading, firing (both hands, then either), holstering, drawing, cleaning. What seems to be forgotten in the rush to 'get-it-going' is that the shooter must depend on both the gun and his/her skill at using it (in a hurry). It may take 6 rounds or 600. Ideally, making it go bang is an extension of your thought process, not simply some heavy thing in your hand. Along the way, one develops confidence; knowing that the gun is there and one is ready, allows freedom to find less lethal solutions.
 
To some degree it's kind of questionable to answer such a question. How many miles should you drive a car before you trust it to drive? :what:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

W
  • Locked
Reliability testing for a carry revolver?
Replies
12
Views
661
Brian Dale
B
D
  • Locked
A test period/method for CCW revolvers before considering them "reliable" for CCW?
Replies
17
Views
526
ArchAngelCD
ArchAngelCD
StrikeFire83
  • Locked
  • Poll
How many rounds of a certain ammo must your pistol cycle before you trust that ammo?
2 3
Replies
60
Views
2K
Warp
Warp
S
  • Locked
New revolver owner and ammo
Replies
8
Views
363
exavid
E
W
  • Locked
Whats life expectancy of a wheel gun?
Replies
19
Views
6K
Peter M. Eick
P
Back
Top