Hunting shows…like them or not?

Status
Not open for further replies.

gspn

Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
2,426
Am I the only one who doesn’t connect with many of the hunting shows on TV? These shows seem to portray hunting as a shallow and materialistic endeavor, where a guy with a bunch of money buys all new gear and sits in a box until he is successful.

If you were just learning to hunt, and all you had to go on was cable TV hunting shows this is what you might takeaway:

- You must hunt from an elevated box or stand
- You must only kill the biggest animals in existence...nothing else has value
- You must hunt with the latest cutting edge and most expensive gear
- You must wear matching camo :)
- Deer only exist around food plots

I taught myself how to hunt when I was in my early 20’s. I learned everything I could about my quarry. I learned how to find them, how to move in the woods, how to track them, how to control my emotions when surrounded by animals that would take flight if they knew I was on the ground only 10 yards away. I learned how to butcher, process, and feed my family. I learned about my prey, my gun, and myself all along the way.

I started taking my son hunting when he was 3. He started hunting with his own rifle when he was 7 (and me supervising). He has learned everything I learned. We’ve spent countless hours together in the truck and in the field. We have an awesome relationship to some degree based on how much time we’ve spent enjoying the challenges and the joys of the outdoors together. He is now 14 years old and you could drop him off in the wilderness and he could feed himself.

It seems that today’s hunting shows portray our sport as one where you go sit in a box all day over a food plot until a big deer happens to come by, then you shoot him. To me that totally misses the true nature of hunting.

Shows don’t have to be like this. Steve Rinella does a show called Meat Eater...it’s a great show. Obviously I think it’s great because he sees a lot of things the way I do...but it’s proof that a show doesn’t have to follow the same tired script that portrays our sport as a shallow activity whose only connection to nature occurs because the box they sit in happens to be outdoors.

A mount for the wall is great, but it’s not the most important thing about hunting for me. The real trophies to me have been the relationship I’ve forged with my son, the love affair I’ve enjoyed with the outdoors, introducing others to hunting/shooting/fishing, or sitting down to dinner with my family to a meal that we took from the field together.

Am I alone?
 
Depends on the show. Not all are like that. There are many places, animals I'll never hunt. I actually enjoy some of the shows filmed in Africa or Alaska. There are some very good shows on from time to time showing hunts for sheep, elk, moose that are very interesting.

Whitetail, turkey, etc., not so much. I can do that myself.
 
I can almost always extract some form of pleasure from watching a hunting episode, I guess I love hunt that much. But I do understand your message, and for the most part your on target, as such. I often see right through particular aspects of a hunt in which they failed to exhibit the entire process, or how they might make it seem as though the only way to hunt is on leased food plots, which BTW don't exist in my state.

Here in Az. where public lands are immense and all around us, the only way to hunt is fair chase, which often requires very long distance shots as well.

GS
 
There's worse stuff on TV, from what I'm told. But no, hunting shows rank among the many things I couldn't possibly take the time out to sit and watch.

And the little bits I've seen left me extremely unimpressed. I don't really find entertainment in watching animals being killed. Necessary to do at times, of course. Even satisfying to do well and properly. But not a pleasurable thing to spectate.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Art, I used to watch with the sound off. Got so fed up I quit paying for the outhouse channel about 6 months ago. The best hunting and shooting video's now are on youtube. On youtube you can watch whatever subject and it's great.
 
To each his own, but I do like to see a nice trophy animal being taken with good technique. This is also something my Son's and I do during many of our hunts. It's a nice form of entertainment that we enjoy sharing with friends and other family members following a good hunting season.

I'm especially entertained by watching someone shoot and kill an animal at extreme distances. But I also enjoy watching someone call animals in, coyotes, bear, elk, moose, antelope, deer, and turkey for sure.

What I don't find entertaining or exciting is watching a hunter who just drives up to within a couple hundred yards of a blind or stand, that is set up in front of a food plot, drinking a cup of hot coffee, taking naps, waiting for an animal that has been feeding from them for months or years. Yep, it's almost 9:00 AM, that 4x4 we've been feeding for the last 9 months should be here any minute, alrighty then. That type of hunting just doesn't do it for me, nor does it express any degree of hunting talent or skill as opposed to fair chase on public lands IMO. Might as well raise them in a cage, tie them to a stake, then just shoot them. Then they talk about the quality boots that they couldn't have imagined hunting without, as if that 200 yd. trek to the blind represents any real wear and tear on any of the gear they depict as being necessary.

Locating and calling them in on hundreds of square miles of wilderness public land is nothing short of hard work, skill, and patience. One is often forced to walk huge canyons and draws, and then spend long hours behind a spotting scope searching for the right quality animal to pursue, which is commonly miles away, this is always admirable to me IMO. Many of the animals my associates, family and I have taken over the years, have taken up to 3 days to pack out of wilderness country, where the closest two track is miles and miles away, and straight up a 2,000' slope, and that's just to get to some semi flat land. You see no boots tracks other than your own, and getting lost can mean the difference between life and death. But the satisfaction that comes with harvesting a nice game animal you worked so hard to find and harvest, is something that words alone can't describe. I have often referred to hunting as something I hate to love, as much as I love to hate it.


GS
 
I watch a lot of hunting shows, but like most television, I consider what I see to be purely entertainment, not "educational". You can't "learn" to hunt watching TV.
 
I have grown up in the Southeast and have hunted with several of the main guys that really started the hunting show phenomenon. Jackie Bushman and Bill Jordan have been friends of mine since the 1980s and they are two that have led the way in the business. I was actually a model for one of the first RealTree print ads back in the 80s. Didn't get paid a dime but Bill asked us to wear some camo so we did it and then drank a lot of beer. Come to think of it we drank a lot of beer EVERY day so the photo shoot wasn't a big deal. I have hunted ducks with the Robertson clan in LA before Duck Dynasty when they were just getting started in the business.
I really like most of these guys and they are true outdoorsmen and sportsmen. With that said I do not really enjoy watching their, or any, hunting shows. They make these shows with the intent of making a profit so they sell advertisement to most anyone that will give them money. They hunt on the finest property in the world because their viewers want to see HUGE animals with monster racks. That doesn't mean they aren't good hunters. It means that they are selling a product and they sell what their customers want. I understand their business and enjoy spending time with them. Deer and duck camp with these guys is just like it is with anyone else (although the accommodations are generally a lot nicer and Trace Adkins may show up). They cut up, drink and tell lies just like everyone else.
I have personally never paid to go on a big game hunt though I have been on a lot in my life. I can't justify paying $10k to shoot anything. $25k to shoot a Brown Bear? $20k to shoot a GMO Whitetail? I might pay to go on an African safari because I've never been to Africa. Of course I spend this much to shoot at the animals on my farm every year but that's a different ballgame.
 
Most of the shows shown locally are a waste of film, or in most cases a waste of memory card. I would like to take these so-called experts cross the river into the Ozark National Forest and see if they could kill a deer. I doubt it. There is no baiting, no ATVs off-road and the food plots are weeds and rocks. You have to have your act together to kill a deer here.
 
After having a few shows film on our ranch, I must say what you see and what really happened don't really line up very well with each other. Just like any other TV show. Lot's of creative editing and re-shoots. It's entertainment designed to sell a product, plain and simple. What, you didn't really think the good looking host always happened to nail that perfect trophy buck every time he stepped in the woods did you? Lol.
 
I watch them off and on but only if it just happens to be on when I am sitting down with a cup of coffee. I don't get a lot out of them but sometimes pick up something. Do like the "with the children" clips. But there is one show that I DVR ever week and that is Michigan Out of Doors. I believe on the net you can find them under MOODtv or something like that. Just a girl and a guy driving all over Michigan, hunting, fishing, and gereral out door life. Trapping, looking for Morels and so on. Very good show and definately not a show boat show.
 
No. Many of them have little in common with the fair chase hunting that I favor. If you can afford private hunting land with food plots, bait, and in some cases a fenced in herd, luxury boxes and deer so tame you can talk while they graze in range. Not my cup of tea.
Hunts in the wild with actual wild animals do interest me but those are more rare. Nothing against canned hunts if you cam afford them and enjoy them. I like some sport in my hunting and what I watch.
 
Before I was married and had kids, back when I had time to kill (or thought I did), I used to watch a few hunting shows now and then. Never cared much for the "hunting" portions - I figured anybody could sit in a box and whisper until a monster buck walks up - but I liked seeing the animals, so I'd sit through the shows on occasion.

These days, I really don't watch any tv at all - hunting shows or otherwise. I've seen bits and pieces of Duck Dynasty (is that a hunting show?), but the parts I saw made it look like every other "reality tv" show I had ever seen: just people standing around and being over-dramatic about everyday things, like guys milking it at work, or discussing the work they've had done around the house. Big waste of time if you ask me. I'm sure they're good guys, but that doesn't mean I want to spend time watching them on television.
 
Post #12 explains what Bill Jordan and Jackie Bushman are all about, and it's all about the money. I doubt if either one of them would hunt on a property if someone hadn't previously sent pictures to show them what animals are available. That doesn't fit with most hunters who accept what is available regardless of the quality of the animal.
 
Most of my deer hunting has been either sneaky-snaking when in thicker cover, or cross-country walking in desert country to try and kick Bambi out of bed.

Can you imagine what a head-mounted camera would show? I can see why the ad-hustling producers want to use box-blinds. :D
 
Depends on the show. Not all are like that. There are many places, animals I'll never hunt. I actually enjoy some of the shows filmed in Africa or Alaska. There are some very good shows on from time to time showing hunts for sheep, elk, moose that are very interesting.

Whitetail, turkey, etc., not so much. I can do that myself.


^^^^^

This. :D Hunting is best practiced as a participation sport, though. But, I like the wing shooting stuff the best, Ducks Unlimited's stuff, used to like Tom Knapp, rest his soul. But, since we moved to the sticks, the TV package that has Pursuit in it costs more'n I figure it's worth and since Speed TV has become NASCRAP TV, well, I just get the basics, no sportsman's channels, just don't care that much about it.
 
I'd like to see them come to Utah and hunt during the general deer season just like the majority of us regular people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top