I LOVE my 686-1!

Status
Not open for further replies.

MacTech

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
774
Location
Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
Http://www.flickr.com/photos/79690335@N03/9882321996/

Just got back from a quick trip to the range to test out my new toy, and let me just say this....

I had my doubts at first, I'd owned .357's in the past, a Taurus 689 4" barrel, and a couple different 4" Ruger GP-100's, and I always found them unpleasant to shoot, mainly due to the earsplitting report and muzzle blast, the recoil was also similarly snappier than I'd like...

I was expecting more of the same with the 686, I was prepared to hate it, to regret trading in the old Winchester '92 44-40 for it (basically an equal swap, a shooter grade '92 for the 686 seen in the Flikr link above), expecting unpleasant muzzle blast, noise and recoil, I should've just traded for that Rock River 1911 I had my eye on....

But no, I'm a revolver guy through and through, and the 686 called to me, stirring something deep in my soul, a place that the RRA couldn't touch, the RRA appealed to my logical side, and my cheap bugger side, but it didn't truly call to me, it called more to my wallet than anything

So, I was expecting disappointment as I loaded up my first cylinder, alternating 3 rounds of .38 Spl +P Gold Dot defensive ammo, and 3 rounds of inexpensive PMC 158Gn soft point flat nose .357, lining up the cylinder so it brought one of the .38's under the hammer for the first round....

The first shot was amazingly tame, felt like a .22 Magnum, no recoil, no muzzle blast or shock wave, and a reasonably mild report, this thing makes shooting .38 Spl an absolute joy

Up next was a .357, I steeled myself for the blast, pressure wave, and recoil, I'd be lying if I said I wasn't a tad apprehensive...

I pulled the trigger and was surprised, sure it had a bit more punch than the .38, that's a given, but it was only marginally more recoil and noise than those .38's..... Could it be, the 686 actually made shooting .357's.......enjoyable?

I went through the remaining rounds, each time noticing how minimal the difference was between .357 and .38 in this heavy duty beast of a revolver, basically, the only difference between the two was a bit more noise, a little bit of recoil, and the shockwave, that was really the only unpleasant part of the experience, and it wasn't all that bad....

Oh well, out of .38's, now to the remaining .357's....

Each cylinder I fed through the gun, my grin got bigger, before I knew it, I had fired off 25 of my 50 rounds, and I had the biggest grin I have had in a long time, out of the multitude of handguns I've owned, played with, and eventually traded off for my next flight of fancy, this humble, used 686-1 has given me the biggest Grin-for-the-Buck of any of my handguns, short of my Ruger Single Six with the .22 Magnum cylinder fitted

I actually had to restrain myself from shooting up all the ammo I brought, because as of right now, I only have 25 rounds of the cheap PMC .357, 20 rounds of Speer Gold Dot .357 and 12 rounds of Speer gold dot .38+P left, thankfully, due to my tendency to squirrel away brass, I have at least 300 pieces of fired .38 brass ready for reloads, once I grab a set of dies, some primers, and bullets, (I'm thinking full wad cutters over a heavy load of Trail Boss for plinking) I'll be set for a while....

Haven't had this much fun with a handgun in ages....

There's no hesitation in my mind at all now, I'm glad I traded that old Winchester '92 for this brilliant revolver
 
Oh, and another thing, the guy in the next stall over was shooting some form of Wondernine, and also had a Ruger GP-100 4" .357, between shooting sessions we got to chatting.

up until today, he had previously been a strictly semiauto guy, he had purchased his GP on a whim and he was remarking about how much he loved it, and how he wished he had gotten into revolvers sooner, he said that he was having so much fun with his GP that he had to force himself to put it down and switch to his 9mm so he wouldn't burn up all his .357 ammo....

He wondered how much of a difference the 6" barrel made, so I loaded in the snap caps (I was getting ready to leave anyway) and let him try the balance, he was amazed at the difference it made, then he tried the trigger, when he tried the SA, his jaw hit the floor, he was utterly amazed at the crisp break and no creep, and was equally impressed with the DA pull

I told him that his GP was also a great revolver, rugged, built like a tank, and that it was hard to go wrong with either a Smith or a Ruger and that he had made a great choice in the GP, it would serve him well, his kids well, and their kids well, you really can't kill a Ruger revolver

We then discussed our favorite reloading recipes, and I told him about my favorite powder, Trail Boss, he really wants to try that powder now, especially when I told him about my subsonic .30-06 rounds that even a preteen can handle, he was looking for a way to get his son to try his .308, but the son was scared of the recoil.....
 
Congrats on your 686 as it is one of the best 357s that you get. I have a 4" and 6" which I shoot on a regular basis.
 
I hear ya, it's an amazing gun. I just got done stoning my old 686 trigger and was blown away by how buttery smooth it is now. I mean it wasn't bad before but now it's perfect. Still haven't shot it live yet, but I've really been enjoying dry practice with it. I've fallen in love with mine all over again so I know what you're going through!
 
I have a 686 snub on the way....and can't wait to bring it to the range!

Going to be my primary carry gun.....I know, it is heavy. I have great gun belts and love hefty guns!
 
I bet your do like it. The L frame is one helluva revolver.
This is coming from someone who never liked the L frames, and finally got one.
I decided since I was into Smiths now, I needed to add an L frame to the stable.
So, I picked up a 4" 586.
The trigger is amazing. I still love my GP100, just not as much as I did before I got the l frame.
Since I can't afford a Python, I went with the 586.
I have no complaints. Smith really got things right, with the L frame. I think it's one of the best .357s ever made.
Remember, this comes from someone who NEVER liked the L frames. Just couldn't stomach how they looked.
Now, I find them beautiful. Kind of like how your tastes in women change between your teens and your 40s.
 
Yep, I feel the same way about my model 28. The large frame Smiths are somethig special.
 
When I started at the BPD our duty weapon was the S&W 686 (no dash) it was the BEST revolver I ever shot and it was the best looking revolver made in my opinion. When I retired we were carrying the Glock 22. The Glock is one ugly gun but the damn thing shoots great too. Congratulations enjoy...
 
I have grown to like my 686 4 inch . I practice aiming with one hand right and left. THe DA and SA is buttery smooth. Thats the edge in older Smiths. SOmeday i need a 6 incher , be it a 586 or 19 model.
 
I have a nickle 586 and a 686. Both no dashes. Very good guns. I also have a couple of 27's, a couple of 19's and a 66. I can never make up my mind which one I like the best. Usually the one that is with me at the range. :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top