Well, I shoot lefty, but am a righty. My right eye is pretty poor, can't see well enough to shoot, for sure. Severe astigmatism. So, I've turned to handguns and now BP. I've shot cap and ball for years, but not rifles until the mid 90s. Now, I'm all worked up wanting to hunt with it before my aging eyes get much worse. My Contender has a scope on it, I cheat.
We have no primitive weapons season here for black powder, but I own my own land and set my own rules.
I can take 'em with a handgun, I can take 'em with a Hawken. I've only taken one past 100 yards out there. I wouldn't have shot at that one with a Hawken, but could have taken the others. I've taken a couple under 50 yards with a .357 magnum iron sighted Blackhawk. They'd been just as dead with the Hawken. I would say deader, but it's hard to get deader than dead.
I simply cannot hit the side of a barn from inside the danged barn with a bow. I've tried, gave up a long time ago. Just ain't got the right eye for it and don't really wanna try drawing left handed or waste money on a left handed bow. I suppose if I'd been born 10,000 years ago, unless I was good with an atlatl, I'd have starved. Well, I don't know, them mammoths are BIG targets. Not sure I'd wanna take one on with a rock tipped stick, though.