Personally, I go for price. If the firearm is the exact same model, I see no reason to support a shop that does not have the business sense to be competitive, nor will I waste MY time in begging a shop to be competitive. Price and convienence is what drives my purchases. Shops and the auction sites have outpriced themselves. Except for the one or two fun pieces I want to get and shoot, I bought all my personal pieces back when it was an honest deal for the most part. One of my best methods for gaining various firearms is a local ad in the local paper of "I will buy your legal firearm, call me with what you have and your price wanted. <phone>" Then if it is something I want, I set up a face to face. If not, I just pass on the phone. Most pieces, I get for close to 1/3 market price. I have acquired very nice pieces this way. Do I feel guilty, no, do I resell some, yes. Most of my parts pieces have been had this way. I do it all legal, get ID, signature on a sales receipt, video at the counter in the shop. I even hold the piece for 10 days while I allow my local district police station (2nd district, Cleveland) to run it for theft. If it is stolen, I have a deal with the county DA to rec my purchase price back in exchange for the piece and details of the purchase. If it is clean, I either sell it or keep it or ????? The only way I can legally sell pieces are at Gun Shows, auction sites, forums or face to face outside of Cleveland, as Cleveland does not allow people to buy firearms in the city limits from a retail shop.
Regards,
Mike