Since the Beretta 87 has been mentioned, let me bring up the another fine .22 in that price range - the CZ 75 Kadet. Highly recommended by many.
For "plinking with a modicum of style", get a Beretta 87. Yes, it's not cheap. But it functions 100%, is more accurate than you are, looks terrific, and will last forever. You'll have forgotten the price long before you've come close to wearing it out.
Photo added: