LED for a weapon light?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DMK

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
8,868
Location
Over the hills and far, far away
Would an LED light work good for a weapon light? Would it would be less susceptable to shock than a regular light?

I'm looking for something small and lightweight to mount on an AR-15.
 
not sure

i dont think a led light is bright enough..arent they more of a flood type..i have a scorpion light that is great fixed beam and focus and i have a 8 led light and it isnt as bright..just seems to light up an area...hope that helps some too.....as for reliable they are sure that
 
LED's don't really put out that much light, compared to "tactical" lights. The tactical lights use high-output lithium batteries and then run them on a fairly-high current, to get a LOT of light out of a very small flashlight. They don't run for a very long time, but that's not what they are intended for.
......
LED's are for long-term efficiency at lower light levels. You can for instance take a 3-cell flashlight and convert it to a white LED and with the same type batteries it will shine for 20-30 times as long as the regular incandescent bulb will, but the overall light level will be way down. You can still use it, but it's not the same output.
-----------
And I have converted a 2-D mag-lite to run red and IR LED's and I can certainly say they are not nearly as bright (-well, the red LED I can say,,, <:D ). Works great with night-vision scopes though:
http://www.norcom2000.com/users/dcimper/assorted/whatever/led_lite.html
Most LED's need <3 volts, but white LEDs you need at least around 3.2 volts, so you must have 3 (regular) batteries or use a pulsing circuit to get that voltage--most little white LED flashlights use a pulsing circuit. Which you can do, if you have a soldering iron, a voltmeter and the desire--the actual parts only cost a few dollars. But a cheaper way to see how well it can work is to just spend $10 for a Brinkman Long-Life LED flashlight that uses 2 AA batteries, and just tape it shut to keep it from coming unscrewed! It throws a small, central spot of light and a larger much fainter one, it works but a 2-AA mini-mag-lite with its regular krypton bulb gives off much more light.
~
 
I'm looking for something small and lightweight to mount on an AR-15.
Look into the Surefire X200. Mounts on any picatinny or universal rail.



i dont think a led light is bright enough
LED's don't really put out that much light, compared to "tactical" lights.

This isn't a personal attack, but y'all are waaaaaaay off base. Look into the Surefire L4, L5, and L6 lights.
 
I've just ordered an LED light from www.ccrane.com ,it's new technology a new LED and a special lens to give a 10 degree beam. I'll let you know about it when I get it. I'll giv e direct comparison with a standard LED light from ccrane.
 
"LED's don't really put out that much light, compared to "tactical" lights." - me!

"This isn't a personal attack, but y'all are waaaaaaay off base. Look into the Surefire L4, L5, and L6 lights." - TechBrute
-Well no offense, but I don't know anywhere near me that stocks a bunch of different $150+ tactical lights for me to try--but among lesser flashlights, the LED's just don't put out as much apparent light as a regular krypton or zenon bulb will, and the colors are usually no good, and the pulsing nature of the light makes it look funny too (sometimes you see a "stroboscopic" effect). If I had the chance to see one first I might change my mind, but I wouldn't believe an advertisement claiming as much. A typical single LED looks extremely bright when viewed from the front--but because of the way they are made and packaged, they throw most of their light in a forward-facing cone-shaped area. A regular light bulb by comparison gives off basically the same amount of light in all directions. Consider how we are seeing cheaper LED flashlights with multiple LED's become available--the reason is that a single LED just doesn't work that well.
- Also note: it is now common (at least in the US) to see red LED's used as brake lights in automobiles--but there's a couple things to realize about that. The actual reason that LED's are used is because of their vastly-longer lifetimes--and because they are less bright, it is necessary to use multiple LED's where previously just one regular light bulb was used.
-------------
There might be special/high-cost LED's out there that can directly compare with krypton and zenon, but wherever they are, they aren't cheap. One of the highest-output brands are the Luxeon LED setups, but many of these types of LED drivers run their LED's extremely hot--and it is not unreasonable to wonder if they will last that whole advertised "10-year lifetime".
~
 
I guess the major and significant issue here is that when "LED" is mentioned, two different types of LED are thought of.

The "5mm LED" - output ~1 Lumen. Powered by watch batteries. Typical product - Photon Microlight.

When somebody says "LED" - I think of the Luxeon. Depending on the model and how it is driven, output can range from ~15 to over a 100 Lumens. Usually powered with multiple Alkaline or Lithium batteries.

SureFire's use of the "5W" Luxeon in the L4, L5 & L6 does produce more than enough light to be use as weapon-mounted and "tactical" lights.

LEDs make excellent WeaponLights because they do not rely on a thin wire heated to almost melting in a bulb of high pressure gas. LEDs do not need to be shock isolated against recoil.

Of course, your incandescent bulbs used by tactical lights are not just any old bulbs - they are the cream of the flashlight world - some of the most powerful, compact bulbs ever created to be powered by batteries. They are like Luxeons - a tiny market.

When LEDs are powerful enough to compare to traditional tactical lights, the efficiency savings normally associated with LEDs don't apply. High Output LEDs get hot. Very hot and if the heat isn't managed, the lifespan will decrease. The 5W Luxeon used by SureFires can have a 5000 hour life. Even a 1000 hour life is a saving over bulbs sometimes that can have a 20-30 hour life.

The LuxeonIII used by the SureFire X200 handgun WeaponLight is a major advance - longer lifespan, more efficient (longer runtime), smaller source (more intense beam).

LEDs for WeaponLights are here and they are the future.

Al
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top