Light 223 load for 11.5" Stag AR

Status
Not open for further replies.

igoodnessi

Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2010
Messages
12
Ok folks, I've seen this subject touched but, never answered exactly. Can anyone give me info on light loads for my new Stag pistol? I'm looking specifically to quiet the gun down a little, reduce recoil and save powder. If anyone can give me an idea about recipes that will best accomplish this I'll dance at your wedding. I'd like to get two recipes out of this. One that is as quiet as possible while not risking a stuck bullet and one that is quiet as possible while reliably cycling. Shooting the rifle single shot would be novel but, also being able to use the weapon as designed is important. I do not own a suppressor, nor do I intend on getting one or any other item that requires me to sign my soul over to the draconian agency I will not name.

As always, thanks in advance for the valuable input. Find you folks very knowledable on this forum.
 
I don't own a 11" AR but my guess is you would have to have the gas system reported & lighten the recoil spring to get it to run auto.

I'll get you some data when I get the chance. For now try 10gn of BD.
 
10 grains of BlueDot, 10-4

With 55 gr. FMJ's? That's what I have now. I'll go get some 40-50 gr Hornady A-Max/Z-Max on payday. I saw those were recommended by Sea Fire on a related thread that stopped in 2010.

#2830452 - 02/20/09 09:55 PM Re: .223 ?? [Re: WyoJoe]


Heres some info on Blue Dot loads,Please be carefull,This guy has done a lot of reserch and was a big help to me.
Bob.
Seafire Seafire
Campfire Ranger


Registered: 04/20/04
Posts: 2469
Loc: Southern Oregon USA

Offline
Originally Posted By: WyoJoe
Seafire,
Didn't you do some work with Blue Dot in the .223?


Nope!

Blue Dot Range Report: 223 Caliber ( Full )

Bullet Weights Tested:
1. 35 grain Hornady V Max
2. 40 grain Hornady Vmax
3. 45 grain Sierra SP
4. 50 grain Sierra SMP
5. 52 grain Sierra Boat Tail Match
6. 55 grain Winchester FMJ

Rifle Used: Ruger 77 Mk 2, VT 26 inch Barrel, Stainless Steel First yr Model

Case: Lake City Surplus, previously fired

Primer: Remington 6 ½

Powder: Blue Dot

Charge Weight Tested: 4 grains to 14 grains.


Weather: Sunny, NO clouds, 80 degrees, NO wind,

Altitude: 2000 ft

Humidity: Very Low


Field Results:


35 grain Hornady V Max:

4 grs: 1284 fps
5 grs: 1488 fps
6 grs: 1862 fps
7 grs: 2163 fps
8 grs: 2392 fps

9 grs: 2636 fps
10 grs: 2722 fps
11 grs: 3076 fps
12 grs: 3205 fps
13 grs: NO Reading
14 grs: 3518 fps

15 grs: NO Reading, Too hot, Extractor Marks, Scrapped Case
16 grs: NO Reading, Too Hot Blew Primer


Hornady 40 grain Vmax:

4 grs: 1161 fps
5 grs: 1538 fps
6 grs: 1798 fps
7 grs: 2148 fps

8 grs: 2243 fps
9 grs: 2539 fps
10 grs: 2771 fps
11 grs: 2956 fps

12 grs: 3013 fps
13 grs: 3218 fps
14 grs: 3375 fps


Sierra 45 grain SP

4 grs: 1239 fps
5 grs: 1447 fps
6 grs: 1688 fps
7 grs: 1880 fps

8 grs: 2118 fps
9 grs: 2363 fps
10 grs: 2553 fps
11 grs: 2811 fps

12 grs: 2875 fps
13 grs: 3008 fps
14 grs: 3164 fps


Sierra 50 grains SMP

4 grs: 1064 fps
5 grs: 1345 fps
6 grs: 1624 fps
7 grs: 1788 fps

8 grs: 2033 fps
9 grs: 2257 fps
10 grs: 2466 fps
11 grs: 2655 fps
12 grs: 2779 fps

13 grs: 2882 fps
14 grs: 3038 fps


Sierra 52 grain Boattail Hollow Point Match

4 grs: 1061 fps
5grs: 1460 fps
6 grs: 1632 fps
7 grs: 1916 fps

8 grs: 2142 fps
9 grs: 2225 fps
10 gr: NO Reading
11 grs: 2673 fps

12 grs: 2782 fps
13 grs: 2879 fps
14 grs: 3012 fps


Winchester 55 grain FMJ

4 grs: 896 fps
5 grs: 1264 fps
6 grs: 1568 fps
7 grs: 1825 fps
8 grs: 1994 fps

9 grs: 2201 fps
10 grs: 2328 fps
11 grs: 2453 fps

12 grs: 2677 fps
13 grs: 2821 fps
14 grs: 2915 fps





Notes:

1. IN the evaluation of the 223, I came further to the conclusion of the versatility of the 223 in the use of training new shooters, and for a very versatile varmint caliber.
2. Essentially the 223 can be loaded to the specs of a 22 Long rifle, a 218 Bee, a 221 Fireball, a 222 Remington, a 22 Hornet, and a 22 Win Mag., while allowing the shooter to be able to pick the type of bullet that he prefers.
3. Bullets were limited to use of 35 grains to 55 grains. Heavier bullets will not serve any purpose unless a 223 is to be used for deer hunting. I do not believe that their would be a significant difference in the use of a 55 grain bullet vs a 60 grain bullet.
4. The recoil on the lighter loads using 4 to 6 grains of powder had minimal recoil if any at all. These would be ideal for young shooters being trained.
5. Noise level on the lighter loads ( 4 to 6 grains) were on par with a rim fire. An increase in noise level was very noticeable above 7 grains, but still very acceptable. ( No sounding like a rim fire any more)

Noted Observations:

1. It was noted but not considered part of the testing, with a tree used as a back stop for some of the testing, that all bullets ( 45 to 55 grains)penetrated thru the tree at a distance of 20 yds.
2. The diameter of the tree was measured at 5 inches.
3. The 40 grain Vmax loads failed to penetrate the tree at loads above 10 grs, above 2771 fps. However at 10 grains and less, the bullets penetrated thru the tree and did a large amount of damage ( like turning the wood into tooth picks) on the exit side of the tree. The penetration stopped at the 5 grain load.


Some of the Author’s Conclusions:

1. I learned some significant items beyond the versatility of the 223 with the bullets tested, but focusing on its use in the field, got some ideas.
2. A light rifle such as a Winchester Featherweight or Rugers Compact model with a 16.5 inch barrel or the Ultra Light with a 20 inch barrel would make a good combo with the use of Blue Dot.
3. Since the powder is burned cleanly in the first 10 to 12 inches of barrel, the shorter barrels are not handicappiing velocity in the lighter shorter rifles.
4. The penetration of the 40 grain Vmax into the tree did make me ponder the use of those plastic tip varmint rounds as potential loads for small deer for youth shooters. Just like my observations in the larger calibers, the plastic tipped bullet seem to do a lot more damage, at velocities under 2700 fps. The Vmax surprised me. This is a decision any shooter will have to test on his own and make their own decisions. I am just passing on that I saw potential merit in the application.
5. Although one has to weigh out the potential of Plastic Tipped Varmint bullets on bigger game like deer and antelope, some of these loads in real life use, utilizing Barnes’s X bullets in 22 caliber I can recommend. They make a 45 grain, 50 grain and 53 grain bullet. The way I saw much better penetration and more damage in wood, at the lower range velocities, 2200 to 2700 fps, this would make a good deer load in many parts of the USA, and recoil is minimal.


I did not test any bigger bullets as I feel that those tested would be represent the best potential with the powder. 60, 63, 64, 65 grain bullets and then the larger match bullets did not give what I considered useful velocity when I have shot them before with Blue Dot, in respect to their field design uses.

223 Range Report

Powder: Blue Dot

Bullet: Berger 30 grain HP, Varmint

Rifle Used: Ruger 77 VT

Barrel Length: 26 inches

Primer Used: Winchester Small Rifle

Bullet O.A.L. : 15.55 mms

Cartridge O.A.L. : 57.93 mms


10 grs: 2844 fps

11 grs: 3082 fps

12 grs: 3210 fps

13 grs: 3407 fps

14 grs: 3712 fps

15 grs: 3797 fps

15.5 grs: 3814 fps

16 grs: 3873 fps

16.5 grs: 3957 fps.

Accuracy Potential:
Load of 15 grains of Blue Dot, 30 gr Berger, WSR primer:
5 shot group size@ 100 yds: 0.4260 –0.224 bullet diameter = 0.202 group size
Scope: 6.5 x 20 Simmons.. setting at 10 Power.




Blue Dot:

223 & 36 grain Barnes Varmint Grenade HP.

Primer: CCI Small Pistol

Brass: Lake City

Rifle : Ruger 77 Mk 2

Barrel: 22inch


1. 7 grs: 1946 fps
2. 8 grs: 2286 fps
3. 9 grs: 2477 fps
4. 10 grs; No Reading
5. 11 grs: 2704 fps
6. 12 grs: 3024 fps
7. 13 grs: 3201 fps
8. 14 grs: 3321 fps
_________________________
 
Very interesting to say the least.

Of note in the posting that you inserted, the experimenter is shooting from bolt action rifles. There may be some issues in getting a direct impingment weapon to cycle at the lower end of the loadings. You also lose some velocity but I can't see any chance of a bullet getting stuck in the barrel as 1200 fps with a 35 grain bullet is still way faster than 22lr subsonic rounds. I wouldn't risk going much lower though because I'm not sure if there are any differences in the actual bore diameter between 22lr and .223 or if that would actually matter.
 
If you have read SeaFire's data I can't add much to it just confirm it as I got almost the same results. One exception I decided max was about 2gn less then him.
 
Sea Fire was thorough but...

As you mentioned he was testing with a bolt gun... I don't want to run into something serious involving stuck bullets or some sort of gas system specific catastrophe. Eventually, I'd like to get a good recipe for the quietest load that will safely fire as a single shot and a good recipe for the quietest load that will reliably function in my 11.5'' Stag upper. I'm just bugging ya'll for short cuts because I KNOW that someone on here has done it before me so I thought I'd ask instead of spending $100 to figure it out from scratch for myself and risk blowing my new gun up.
 
Working on Blue Dot Loads

I've loaded some Blue Dot loads ranging from 10-14 grain charges using Remington 55 gr. FMJ bullets. I'm going to do the same thing with some 40 grain Hornady Z-max bullets I picked-up from Cabela's today. In the next week I'll go out to the desert and test the loads thru a Stag 16'' and Stag 11.5'' inch M4-gery. I will report on cycling, recoil and noise levels. I don't have a lead sled or a chrono so info on accuracy and velocity will be spotty at best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top