I will make this as simple as possible for those on the left who haven't gotten what is obvious to those of us who are not idealogically blinded by socialist pathology:
The government CANNOT redistribute wealth. Wealth is something that is sustainable, that is grown and nurtured by an individual who is an active participant in its creation. The government, in an addle-brained left socialist approach that conveniently buys votes at the same time, redistributes MONEY from one group to another.
If you give most people who are chronically poor, making 15k per year, another 20k to spend, what will they MOST LIKELY do with it? Will they save some for their kids education? Will they make investments in real estate? Will they buy some bonds to lock in a rate of return that will likely beat inflation? What will that person do? They will likely SPEND that money on useless junk that will NOT increase their chances of sustaining a better way of life in the future. Most poor people are poor for one of two reasons, and I really hate to boil it down to this: They are either lazy, stupid, or some combination of both. No matter what the dream of the redistributionist mentality, the reality is that we were not all created equal. There are smart people and there are dumb people in the same way that there are tall people and there are short people. Short people usually have short kids, tall people usually have tall kids. Smart people usually have smart kids. Smart kids grow up to be smart adults to most likely outwit and outproduce people who don't have the same ability. Do some research, theres plenty out there on this.
The smarter you are the more in demand you are in the labor market. If you have specialized skills, or are extremely adept at what you do, someone will be willing to pay you more. People with special skills or talent are more RARE than people without. For the same reason that people pay MORE for some THINGS that are rare, the labor market prices their skills accordingly and in the same manner. Its called capitalism and it works EXTREMELY well for getting goods and services to the greatest number of people at the cheapest possible price with the greatest efficiency.
Oh, says the lefty-socialist-would be communist, lets just pay doctors and proffessionals the same as we pay the guy who mows your lawn. Yeah, well, if you haven't learned by now that this kinda FAILED miserably then there is no hope for you. Yeah, lets trade in a vibrant middle class, a small underclass, a small upperclass, for a massive group where basically everyone has very little and a few people have control and power. Yeah, thats a great trade. Sadly, that is the direction that socialism takes you. Look to Europe in the next few decades to see what socialism will get you. Hell, look at France now! Cradle to grave nanny-state nonsense where even the most sensible labor laws are protested in the streets by leftist students who are basically kissing any hope of a future goodbye.
End of rant.