Long review Walther p22

Status
Not open for further replies.

bigjim

Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2002
Messages
793
Review Walther P22:

I have searched in vain for five years for a pistol my wife could not only shoot but enjoy shooting as well. I have tried various 21 different pistols in calibers ranging from 22 through 45 acp.

Many were almost right but not just right. Some while they fit her hand were so inaccurate that they were not fun to shoot. Some shot very well but she could not operate the controls. Most autos were beyond her very limited hand strength when it came to racking the slide. Many had so many sharp edges my wife’s soft hands found them painful to use. Recoil is ALWAYS a problem. Almost all pistols are meant for larger males hands. After all we guys buy the vast majority of pistols.

But she wanted to learn….wanted to be with me. She wanted to be a part of this aspect of my life. I was willing to do almost anything to help her.

Then I saw a Walther P22. They grip is very small suitable for a small child or small stature female. The slide is very easy to rack because of its very light recoil spring.
The polymer frame is soft in the hand and devoid of edges that byte and pokes the soft hands of an urban female. The gun has all the controls and they are located correctly and function like a serious service pistol. This makes it a good training platform.

I bought the gun after reading about it a fair amount on the web. I learned three crucial things prior to buying this gun.

Older examples had problems. Make sure you get a gun with the L prefix serial number or newer.

The first generation magazines did not feed correctly. Make sure you get a magazine with the letter A in the part number etched on the mag.

They are ammunition sensitive. Before your turn this over to the new shooter go out and buy at least TEN (10) different kinds of 22 ammo. You will need to experiment to find a brand and type of 22 ammo that fires and ejects properly. All brands I tried fed well but many lacked the power to operate the gun or caused failures to fire due to a light firing pin strike.

Suggested Ammo so far: CCI Stingers, Remingtion Thunderbolt. CCI mini mag, Remington golden bullet. Aguila 60 supersniper subsonic.

OK results with Winchester 40 grain solids and Federal. Both of these brands had a few duds enough to bug me.

Bad results with PMC ( all types), Winchester wildcats.

Accuracy: Not world class. At ten yards I can keep the shots inside a 1 to 1 ½ inch circle. This is good enough to give useful feed back to your shooting and be fun to shoot.
Will hit soda cans out to 25 yards with ease. (once again good enough for the fun factor)

Trigger: Single action is good. Not GREAT but a solid good rating. The double action is very good. Both get better with use. This gun comes with a slide mounted safety that when engaged still allows the gun to function normally but blocks the firing pin. This means dry firing is ok. This is a nice feature for a 22 pistol. Even the double action pull is reachable with very small hands.

Sights: Very good sight picture. Not set up for bullseye that is for sure. However the sights are very easy to see and use. I would have killed for sights this good when I started out shooting. Windage adjustable rear sight and the front sight comes in three heights to adjust for elevation. I found the shortest sight to be perfect.

Weight: Just right for the gun with EXCELLENT balance. The pistol becomes a part of your hand and the recoil is very mild and pleasant. In fact it feels GOOD to shoot it. You just a get a nice little bump to let you know the gun fired properly.

Features: My wife’s pistol came with two barrels. A 5 inch and a 3 inch. The 5 inch barrel has something called a Stabilizer on the end that looks like a compensator but is not. It takes about three mins to switch between the two barrels. We have not even tried the longer barrel yet as it does add some weight to the gun, and the gun looks better to both of us with the short barrel.

How it worked out for my wife at the range: I have been dragging her to the range periodically for years. She has never fired more than fifty rounds of pistol ammo in one trip. She tolerates shooting to be with me. She does want to be a more active participant in her own safety and does want to shoot and shoot well. But in the past she has not enjoyed it. Today I brought 250 rounds of ammo I had tested to make sure it ran well in the gun. She shot all of that up and made me go buy her more from the range office. She fired 400 rounds today alone. She was able to load the magazines by herself. She was able to clear her own malfunctions. Comments like this is fun and I want to come back were heard more than once. Best of all she was developing confidence with the pistol and was able to deal with it on her own!!

Price: Full boat retail for the two barrel set is 369 dollars. Just buying the single barrel pistol saves you about 60-70 dollars. The pistol can be had cheaper if you shop.

Conclusion and over all rating on a scale of 1 thru 10 being the best.

Overall rating 9
Accuracy 8
Trigger 9
Ergonomics 10
Features 10
Ammo sensitivity 7
FUN FACTOR 10

For a fun pistol that a child or small female can have great results with and is about as cool looking as a 22 can get look no further.
 
thanks for the great report bigjim.

My girlfriend has been shooting a S&W 22A for some time and she always complains about how heavy it is. We shopped all over for other .22lr pistols that felt okay in her hand. The Beretta Neos was a no no, the rugers she didn't like, the Browning was too heavy. The closest thing she thought felt fine was a SIGtrailside, but I couldn't afford it at the time.

A few weeks ago my friend let us tinker with his new Walther P22.... it had the extended bbl and comp. My girlfriend absolutely loved it! Now she has her heart set on one, and completely forgot about the SIG.
 
Great review! Glad to hear good things about something I'm planning to buy. As far as your wife going through 400 rounds of ammo in one trip...I can see how that would happen. I picked up my first gun (Remington 597) a couple days ago, and the first night put 250 rounds through it...then I ran out of ammo. :)
 
The double action is very good.

They must've completely changed something. My P22 was fun (though I did sell it), but the DA trigger was not usable. Easily over 20 pounds and it felt like squeezing a tennis ball.
 
A big thing is to use Hi-Vel for the first 500 to 1000... then the spring wears in nicely to function with standard vel ammo...
 
You had to post this while my P22 is sitting over at S&W waiting for some work... :(

Went shooting today and I kept complaining because I wanted my P22!!

Mine has the items you mentioned, ("L" prefixing the serial#, the "A" on the mags), but I still had to send it off because the slide would catch on the hammer. :fire:

Glad she likes it!
 
Good review, pretty much mirrors my experience with the P22. I bought one to use as a training pistol to teach my 10 year old son. He loves shooting it, and is getting quite good with it. Although he now prefers shooting the 9 mm SIG P239, he still thinks the P22 is fun because it is so much easier to manage and shoot accurately.

My wife has also gone with me a couple of times and really likes the P22. My experience is very similar with regard to ammo. The Remington Golden Bullets and Thunderbolts work flawlessly, and the CCI Mini Mags are great. I bought a bulk pack Winchester Xpert which was junk--wouldn't work in either the P22 or the Ruger 10/22.

I am very happy with this little handgun, and have never had a bit of trouble with it.
 
Walther P22

I love my Wather P-22 . And I also have a silver kimber .22LR target. Both guns are very finicky when it comes to ammo. But I have found the Winchester Super X High velocity & CCI Stingers to work the best. For Both guns.

I've had the worst luck with the Remington golden Bullets and the Federal Game-shok high velocity.:banghead: :banghead:

Also the wife loves both of these guns for shooting. But she prefers the Walther over the Kimber because the slide is easier to pull back and it locks open with an empty mag.

The Kimber is way more accurate.
 
I have above-average sized hands (good fit for the CZ P-01/SP-01 grip size and standard 1911s) and find the P22 surprisingly comfortable to hold for such a small gun.
 
my buddy just bought one for his wife..i doubt she has even shot it..its her first gun..i took it to the range with my buddy and shot a mag or two with it...the polymer has a different feel to it than my xd..i like the way it felt and for my hands it fit really well size wise..i plan on picking up one at some time just to say i have a .22 thats not a rifle..i know it has issues as some people will say but id still buy one
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top