Like every one else said that's a tall order BUT if I were you I would be keeping my eyes open for auctions. Large 2-3 day auctions with multiple rings going at once(split up the people) or "sportsman" type auctions with only guns, bows hunting and related items.
Your probably not going to find a $200 remington 1100, or a benelli m1, but I'm sure you you'll be able to find a number of jc higgens, Stevens, western field, etc. Yeah there used and at $200 some better models may have bluing wear or even a little rust but as long as you look them over good and make sure they function well your golden.
Personally I like buying used guns because number one: they are cheaper than new(and if you do your homework and know how to check them over before buying there shouldn't be any reason to worry about them being used)
Number two: they are usually better made ie less plastic more milling, ready to last a few lifetimes
And third: they just have more character than new guns. But hey that's just me