looking for a replacement for my CS mini gurkha light kukri.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Andrew Wyatt

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
4,472
Location
Bakersfield, California
I lost my CS mini gurkha light kukri factory second on a camping trip recently, and i 'm looking for a suitable replacement.

The mini gurkha light kukri was a fantastic GP knife and i need something to fill the role of a light, handy chopper, hammer and general trail knife.


I've been looking really hard at the HI kukris, and i'm favorably impressed, but I don't have enough experience to judge which one would work best for me.


What would you suggest?
 
I think the 16.5" HI WWII Model is the best all around kukri pattern. It is heavy enough to do some serious utility work but it isn't prohibitively heavy. A great all around blade.
 
The HI WW II 16.5" wood handled kukuri is a great choice for an all-around camp knife and close range defensive tool.

Another choice that works well is the 18" Chitlangi.

Both of these kuks aren't terribly heavy, and are quite capable.

John
 
are the blemished HI knives still functional blades?

the main reason i'm worried about getting a HI blade is i might find it too pretty to use, and a blemished blade (if it were still functional) might be a way around that.
 
I'm pretty sure that they're functional. But some of the blemished ones have cracks in the handles (especially the horn ones), which makes it unusable in my mind. So make sure what kind of blemish you're getting.
 
Most of the folks who regularly populate the HI forum pounce on seconds. Seconds are usually things like very small cracks in handles, small amounts of rust on blade tips, or handles with small chips. In every case, function is not affected, and the knife retain the HI lifetime warranty.

Many of the "secondary" (get it? :rolleyes: ) problems are caused by the long transit from damp Nepal to dry Arizona. Horn handles seem to be most sensitive to the humidity change. Cracks in handles can be super-glued or epoxied- Byron hasn't bothered with the tiny handle crack on the 18" WW II model I gave him. (In fact, he recently was looking at his kuk, and he said, "This made it a second? Hell.")

I have no financial relationship with HI, but I have purchased many of their products, and I give HI knives to my best friends and training partners.

John
 
Hello there: up front, understand that I'm co-moderator of the HI forum. Definitely not apologizing, just want you to know.

There's a very different attitude over there, as the HI stuff is handmade and you don't get perfection that way, forging things by hand.

Someone said that the marvel of a dancing bear is not how well he dances, but that he dances at all. Same with the HI khukuris. No jigs, no fixtures, just the kami ( blacksmith ) and the steel, basically.

Likewise, it doesn't sound normal over here in the west, but somehow the maker seems to put a bit of himself, his sweat, blood, soul, into each blade he makes. I know it sounds like mumbo-jumbo, but the khuks themselves are very solid, and handle cracks become a non-issue when you hold it in your hand and feel entranced. What would be considered flaws or blemishes in the custom knife game just add to the character of khuk's. Uncle Bill says the knives find their rightful owners.

I will tell you that they do seem to have a spirit in them that no factory knife can. One that says I was made for you. I know that sounds odd. But I believe in it.

If you want to try something completely different, and are open to good honest tools, try an HI 12" AK or a Pen knife ( named after a forumite whose handle is Pendentive ). Then take it out and use it hard. What seems like an ugly duckling will transform in your mind to a graceful swan. Don't think of the HI's as Ferrrati's, Lamborghini's and Corvettes, think of them as John Deere's, Massey-Fergusons, McCormicks, and Ford tractors.

Now shut up, Rusty, you're not in the Cantina. Thanks for letting me spout off, JS.
 
No prob, Rusty. Thanks for the additional input, which was phrased better than I could have put it.

John
 
Aye. my CS kukri had no soul (which is one of the reasons why it got lost) and was the same as every other CS mini light kukri.

IMHO, weapons made the HI way are more appealing, as each one is a separate piece, as opposed to a member of a vast number of identical items with the same model number.

I'm definitely going to sell some stuff and mow some extra lawns to get the 16.5 inch WWII HI kukri. thanks for the information.
 
You're sure to like it, Andrew. They are certainly purty, but that has never stopped me from using them. They just cry out for use, ya know?


Hi Rusty

Hi John

;)
 
My "second" BAS looks rather blemished after 3 years of utility

still straight and sharp and hardly dinged

but its been used to chop wood
scrape mastic
and kill bears
(well maybe wolly bears)

Its a tool not a drawer queen
 
I realize they may look the same from a quick and far glance, but I tend to become suspicious when kuks are advertised with "India" and Ghurkas in the same sentence.

John
 
Uncle Bill's HI kamis use the magic stone that wards off accidental boo boos to the owner

you only buy quality once
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top