BSA1
member
This is more of a general interest question rather than a gunsmithing question as I do not consider the gun "broke" at this time.
I picked up a used S&W Model 10-5 with a skinny barrel in very good condition. Upon cleaning it after my first range session with it I discovered that there is loose spot in the interior of the barrel where the barrel is screwed into the frame. I have ran several patches through it and measured the spot carefully and it is in the barrel where it screws into the frame.
My first thought is a bulge from a stuck bullet once upon a time. While there is no sign of cracking or any other damage on the forcing cone or the barrel or on the frame there is a slight hump or maybe more correctly a "taper" in the contour on the barrel where it meets the frame. It is barely noticeable and seems to go all the way around the barrel except the bottom where the barrel is milled flat for the ejector rod. Also the loose spot is farther back in the barrel under the frame where the barrel is screwed in. It would seem the pressure from a stuck bullet would have caused more obvious damage. So I attribute the slight "hump" or "taper" or "contour" as being the the way the barrel is made by the factory correct?
The cylinder and chambers appear to be fine.
My first range session was a bit of disappointment to me with the gun shooting to 2 1/2" to 3" to the left from 7 - 10 yards. However I attributed much of it due to using the magna service grips which are way to small for my hand, pain in my shoulder from recent surgery and white paint on the front sight causing me to lose the sight picture in the bright sunlight. At three yards firing double action it put 4 rounds plum center inside the X-ring of the target measuring less than 1" outside hole to outside hole
Bear in mind that this is a 30 year old cop gun so who knows what has been shot in it. I was using 158 gr. SWC I reloaded myself so there were not any ammo problems at all. I am unwilling to state the gun has accuracy issues until I can get back out onto the range with grips that fit my hand without the dang white paint and shoot it side by side with another Model 10.
As this is the first revolver I have ever had with loose spot in the barrel I am looking for feedback about what, if any, problems it might cause.
I picked up a used S&W Model 10-5 with a skinny barrel in very good condition. Upon cleaning it after my first range session with it I discovered that there is loose spot in the interior of the barrel where the barrel is screwed into the frame. I have ran several patches through it and measured the spot carefully and it is in the barrel where it screws into the frame.
My first thought is a bulge from a stuck bullet once upon a time. While there is no sign of cracking or any other damage on the forcing cone or the barrel or on the frame there is a slight hump or maybe more correctly a "taper" in the contour on the barrel where it meets the frame. It is barely noticeable and seems to go all the way around the barrel except the bottom where the barrel is milled flat for the ejector rod. Also the loose spot is farther back in the barrel under the frame where the barrel is screwed in. It would seem the pressure from a stuck bullet would have caused more obvious damage. So I attribute the slight "hump" or "taper" or "contour" as being the the way the barrel is made by the factory correct?
The cylinder and chambers appear to be fine.
My first range session was a bit of disappointment to me with the gun shooting to 2 1/2" to 3" to the left from 7 - 10 yards. However I attributed much of it due to using the magna service grips which are way to small for my hand, pain in my shoulder from recent surgery and white paint on the front sight causing me to lose the sight picture in the bright sunlight. At three yards firing double action it put 4 rounds plum center inside the X-ring of the target measuring less than 1" outside hole to outside hole
Bear in mind that this is a 30 year old cop gun so who knows what has been shot in it. I was using 158 gr. SWC I reloaded myself so there were not any ammo problems at all. I am unwilling to state the gun has accuracy issues until I can get back out onto the range with grips that fit my hand without the dang white paint and shoot it side by side with another Model 10.
As this is the first revolver I have ever had with loose spot in the barrel I am looking for feedback about what, if any, problems it might cause.
Last edited: