Depending on your actual budget, and I know how that is, either would suit your needs.
I would not worry with anything longer than 7.5" in barrel length or right at it, as this will give you all the authority you need on shots out to 100yds with the 41.
As for scopes, well been there done that, and while some might find them a needed venture, with a revolver, nothing beats simple open sights and plenty of practice. IF you decide you need a scope, I HIGHLY suggest sticking with 2X or lower. Anything higher, IMO, will result in lost shot opportunities due to eye relief issues. Handgun scopes aren't quite as forgiving as rifle scopes. The higher the magnification, the harder they are to use in most hunting situations, unless your hunting form a fixed position with a solid rest.
If it were me, I would use the money your looking at spending on optics, on the best handgun you can find with adjustable, and replaceable sights. The one thing I hate about my Tarus Raging Bull is the non replaceable sights. I like to have options, and I REALLY don't like hunting with the broad balded type sights. But thats just me. Not that their bad, I just don't like them. With a Ruger Redhawk I can at least swap out the factory sights with different front and rear options if wanted or needed in some cases.
Good luck I hope you find what your looking for and are happy with it. I have been in love with the 41 for over 25years and never see a day I will be with out it.