My Browning Hi Power...A Newbie's Perspective...

Status
Not open for further replies.

silversport

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2004
Messages
718
Location
Chicagoland/USA
...so please take whatever I say with a BIG grain of salt... ;D

The Pistol-
...a Browning Hi Power Practical, made in Belgium by Fabrique Nationale and assembled lovingly in Portugal...changes to include, removal of the stock epoxy finish and being professionally Blue'd...Heinie all black serrated SlantPro's...Cylinder and Slide Drop in Trigger Pull Set with the Type II Hammer...removal of the magazine disconnect safety...Herrett's cocobolo aggressively checkered stocks...2 original mousetrap phosphate finished Law Enforcement/Government marked 13 round magazines and 3 more shiny blue MecGar made 10 round magazines...

The Bullets-
...Speer brand 124GR Total Metal Jacket Lawman and Gold Dot Hollowpoint standard velocity bullets...150 rounds total...

The Place-
...After today, never again will I complain about high prices at the nice public range I am used to shooting at...I live about a mile from the range I shot at today...little to no ventilation, hot, (at it is in the 30 degree range in ChicagoLand right now)...narrow lanes with manual runners, lots of people...

The Set Up-
...New to me pistol and I needed to function fire and try out the venerable P-35 type pistol...a pistol I have loved since reading the book Serpico in 1975 but which has eluded my ownership for one reason or the other... until this week...

3 weeks ago, while shooting at a public range I frequent I saw a new addition to their range guns...a Browning Hi Power Practical...this version has been my favorite Hi Power for some time and I am still kicking myself for missing out on an unadvertised special at Gander Mountain some years back that had them for $499.00...well...I tell the man I brought my own guns to shoot but maybe I'll be back..."You'll be back." he says..."You'll be back."...well I went back...tried it out and other than a couple of minor things...I was in love...

My brother and my nephew were with me on this shooting day and my brother says to the owner, everything's for sale if you pay the price in response to me asking the guy if they sell the range guns (this one looked like it had little use)...the guy agrees with my brother but when I say "How much?" (What was I thinking??? ::) )...he replies "I have two Hi Powers over in the new cabinet."...My reply is "But I like this one, it's the Practical, right?" (sez I thinking I will act like I don't know much about it in hopes I won't get completely taken ;) )..."Those are owned by the manufacturers and I can't sell it."...I am deflated for now but it will spark my urgency (like I needed any help there) to finally get a Hi Power...

...the rest you all know from all my questions and responses here and elsewhere for the last two weeks or so...and for your help, I thank you... :cool:

As a gun guy, I am not stuck on any one design or philosophy and I mainly buy whatever I like either for looks, function or if it's design or style means something to me personally...I have single action revolvers, double action revolvers from Colt and Smith & Wesson, single action semiautomatics as well as the double/single action semiautomatics from Colt, Kimber, Springfield, SiG, GLOCK and different types like an HK squeezcocking P7 and a DAO Seecamp...an eclectic array for sure...but this Browning is a bit different too...

Let's Get Down To It-
...place up the target on the modified carrier holder (spring loaded clip) and turn the crank sending it down range to the lighted area (minimum distance this range will allow, 21 feet or so...

I have already cleaned and lubed the pistol as well as familiarized myself a bit with it...I load up one of the mousetrap mags with duty style Speer Gold Dots in 124GR hollopoints and touch the first one off...it goes bang...good...but I seem to have pulled the shot a bit to my right...(I'm a Southpaw)...still the sights are pretty much right on but I 'aint holding up my end of the bargain...

I try a few more and I'm doing okay but my nearly 49 year old eyes, while really liking these Heinie SlantPro's could use a bit of contrast on the front sights...I have similar sights on a Kimber Custom II that Teddy Jacobson did up for me in 2003 and he painted the front sight with blaze orange paint...the front sight still appears like the day he did it and the contrast has helped me qualify every time I use the Kimber...so...note to self...get to the eye doctor for some prescription lenses and perhaps, paint the front sight...

These mousetrap mags really come out of the pistol with authority...I like it...such a contrast to the 10 rounders...something else I find out...I can't feel the trigger reset...it is different than my SiGs, Glocks, 1911s and P7s...hmmm...trigger is nice, I bet about 4.5-5lbs but different than other pistols I own or have shot...nice but different...

...Hammer bit...nope...I am surprised but one I settle in, there is no hammer bite for me...I do see some redness where the hammer is just giving me a kiss but nothing now after shooting...as for these aggressive Herrett's stock's, well, I get more redness from them...again...nothing now after shooting...

...Muzzle flip...what muzzle flip???...maybe it's because I'm more used to .45ACP...perhaps it's the all steel construction...perhaps it is the fantastic ergonomics of John Browning and Dieudonné Saive but nothing negative to speak of here...

...Ambi-Safety goes on easy and sniks off with little drama...I don't know if this will go on or off when I don't want it to (while inside the holster from clothing or the like) but it relieves a concern I had about being able to operate it without a paddle...should I find myself needing that later, I can always pick one of Jim Hoag's superb designed ambi paddles from Cylinder and Slide whom I believe are the current owner's of that design...

The Recap-
...150 rounds of both Lawman TMJ and Gold Dot HP and if I would do my part, this pistol will do it's...

...the trigger...I had a couple failures to fire but they were traced to me not allowing the trigger to reset...I was allowing the motion I do for 1911's and GLOCK's and this was not enough to allow the reset on the Hi Power...this is my learning curve and I had this same problem with the range Hi Power some weeks back...I'm sure the blame is mine now...hurray for me... :p

...accuracy...well, I didn't do my part today as I was just ringing it out but truth be told...I will need some contrast to the front sight and some more range time with mine but I believe the pistol's accuracy is right on...

...extraction and ejection of brass...other than many rounds finding themselves going down the back of my neck with their red hot touch, primers show a strong central strike and no damaged brass...the Browning is functioning properly...

...the trigger's pull...feels less than the range gun I tried and the Cylinder and Slide sear, springs and hammer all did what they were designed to...I need more range time to get used to what this trigger can do but it's nice for what I want it for...carry and perhaps some duty...

...Herrett's stocks with their aggressive checkering, I didn't feel the Hi Power move about in my hand at all...i might like to find some Spegal's in the future or a pair of Uncle Mike's if they ever appear either on the 'bay or at some of the smaller gun shops...but I have no complaints from these and in fact think I would prefer them to the stock Walnut's and I know I prefer them to Pachmayr's that would have come standard on a Practical (like the range gun had)...

...Magazines...I prefer the mousetrap's both for their ability to spring from the magazine well upon hitting the magazine release and for their full 13 round capacity...as for the standard type 10 rounders...well...they'll make fine range mags...they are quality but I don't need to use 10 rounders so I see no reason to buy any more like these...

...Clean up was rather easy...only 150 rounds down range...take down is super simple (I know 'cuz I can do it :D) and reassembly was also a snap...the reinsertion of the recoil spring and guide plug being the only thing to slow the process down and only by a few extra moments...

...Visually I find the P-35 Hi Power design to be beautiful and the Practical with cocobolo's stunningly so...many others look nice too as I find I like any of the Mk IIIs even with the epoxy finish preferring their high combat sights to the smaller ones or adjustables on other Hi Power's but some of the older one's with their deep Blueing look stunning as well...and don't think I've forgotten any of the engraved models or the Parkerized one's...I guess I'm just one of those that likes the design...

...This one is mine (cheating a bit with an Alessi/Heinie DOJ holster for a 1911) and I think it's a keeper...

P1000151_edited-1.gif

Thanks everyone...

Bill
 
As a BHP fan, I enjoyed every word of your post.
Thanks for your detailed report and great story.
 
Another BHP fan here. I CCW'ed one for years.

Great report and I'm glad you like it. Your pistol is a looker; I especially like the grips.

Good info on the mouse-trap mags. I've not tried them yet basically since I was waiting for a report on them - thanks!

Take care,
DFW1911
 
I bought my BHP in 1993 and have fired thousands of rounds through it. I remember buying Remington yellow box 9mm FMJ ammo for $6.00 a box in 1998. I should have bought a truckload.

My BHP is matte blue and wears Hogue rubber grips. The two 13-shot factory mags (marked "Made in Italy") have worked flawlessly all these years. The HP's trigger is not great, but otherwise I'm completely satified with my Browning.
 
Wow that is a gorgeous BHP! I would love to buy a well used BHP or 1911 and do some custom work like this.
 
sorry to bump this thread back to the top...but I need some input from some of the hi pwr folks. Does a new recoil spring need to be "broken in"? I decided to beef up mine to a 18.5lb and had read some of Stephen Camp's info regarding this.. I had several fail-to-eject's and one stove pipe while shooting 115gr sellier/bellott's. I will try some winchester next (hopefully in 124gr if I can find them). I have no way to check the strength of the previous spring, but was a little concerned because it threw casings a country mile and also had a few F-T-E's. The new spring is considerably longer than the previous. The extractor claw looks good and spring seems nice and stiff. The ejector does not have excesive wear. Should I run a 100 rounds thru it and see if it improves? I'm also thinking I need to replace my mag springs..They may be original. This is a early 70's BHP.
 
Hello, BUFF. If standard pressure ammunition being used with the 18.5-lb spring is causing problems, go with the 17-lb factory standard either from Wolff or Browning. The spring doesn't necessarily need to be "broken in" but a new one will normally become a bit shorter than when new and is engineered that way, according to the folks at Wolff Gunsprings. (www.gunsprings.com)

I copied and pasted this from their FAQ section:

"6. My spring got shorter after I used it for a short time. Is it bad?
Most new springs will take a set when they are first compressed. That means they will shorten up. This is a normal event and you should not be immediately alarmed. The greater the stress on the spring, generally the more set that will occur. All Wolff springs take this set into consideration. The ratings of the springs you receive are the ratings after the set has occurred. After set has taken place, the spring should remain essentially stable for the life of the spring."

Best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top