my top five survival knives

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow MosinFreak, an Original Bowie!:eek:
100_0251.jpg

I thought I was the only one....:rolleyes:

It was my first big knife as a kid and now it wears a custom Scott USA ski pole grip handle..:D

Last time I used it was cutting sod in the back yard a few summers ago.

OriginalBowie.jpg
 
To tell you the truth, I thought I was one of the only ones as well, lol. Yes my handle is custom fab'd as well, I used an old three foot dowel, cut it to about 5.5", cut it in half, screwed it to tang after I drilled out holes for it (broke four drill bits drilling two holes though stainless steel) rounded out the corners, did my own thumb dips, sanded, puttied, stained, accidentally ruined putty job, wrapped five rings of lead solder around handle, then electrical taped and heat shrunk the tape. There, mouthful of words, but that's how this knife came to be as it is. Here's a picture of how the knife looked before the tape:
p_00100.jpg

I found the knife in the alleyway behind my grandmother's house as a kid (alleyway was adjacent to a nice golf course that is as expensive as ice-water in holey-hell!!) and took it home from there. Here's how one should really look like (without the electrical tape around the handle):
Bowie2.jpg
 
I'm fairly surprised nobody has mentioned the venerable M9 bayonet. I personally prefer the M-11 issued to the bomb disposal units, I like the handguard better esp since I'm not using it as a bayonet, purely a survival tool. I used the factory sheath for a long time until recently I picked up a very nice Spec-Ops brand one, that has a pocket on it to hold extras, right now just a lighter, but I'd like to add a magnifying glass, etc.

attachment.php


attachment.php
 
The original handle was pretty basic just a couple of flat rosewood slabs riveted on....I can't remember when mine broke off but the ski pole grip is way better!

It's kind of funny looking at this knife now because I think I paid around $20 for it in the early 80's and it seemed pretty impressive and expensive at the time but when I look at it know it's a beater with a pretty thin flimsy blade...

Hoosier yours looks like it might be older then mine, Are you the original owner?
 
First - the Buck 119, still available from WallyWorlds for <$34, uses their standard Paul Bos heat treated 420HC - a far cry from 'regular' 420HC, if you've ever used it. Some like the seemingly more stout bladed, same steel, 650 Nighthawk with a black coating and more comfortable grip - definitely better in the wet & cold. I've camped with a 119 - even 'just' a 110 Folding Hunter.

The old KaBar, like my late Dad's from the S. Pacific in WWII, was the answer for a 'utility' knife - made of non-strategic materials. I used his - a USN variant less the secondary edge - for camping for many years. It was big - but ideal - until I got a Plumb camping hatchet - then my pocket knife, a 110, Vic SAK, or Buck 301, was all I had for a knife. I usually had a backpack 3-man tent, so no shed 'construction' was needed.

Of the less expensive 'bushcraft/survival' fb's I have now, these are the least expensive, with the RC-5 at $125 slightly over the $100 limit. They are all US-made, too. The LMFII is for comparison's sake - it was a gift from my son, else it wouldn't be here - my serrated 'knives' are real saws! I guess my favorites go RC-5, KaBar, Nighthawk, many other knives, finally, the LMFII. That's just my opinion... and the pictured knives have only been used in my wooded back yard. The 16 oz RC-5 might get heavy - and I don't like the original MOLLE sheath mine came with.

IMG_3518.jpg

I'm not apologetic of my nationalist pride. I've fondled that Falkniven - a 'Made in Japan' Swedish rubber-like handled knife gets no high points here. The rehandled VG-10 blades available via KSF might be interesting - love Micarta - but I have plenty of US-steel bladed regular Bark Rivers to choose from - but we are getting near double the OP's price. The USN-style, ie, no sharpened secondary edge, KaBar really is a useful, but large, camping knife - and a fairly priced one, too.

Survival is what you have on you when needed. As a boy of twelve in NY in the summer of 1960, specifically, in a park cut-off by the LIE and the unopened Throggs Neck Bridge approach, I was chasing my beagle through some overgrowth when I got tangled in brambles. As I struggled to get to my BSA pocket knife - which likely would get me arrested there nowadays - I saw the yellow jackets. I alternated between cutting the yellow jackets in half as they stung my thighs and cutting the brambles that held me as their target. I was on the LIE overpass awaiting the light change to get to my folk's apartment when I noticed my beagle was at my side. Aspirin and cold compresses eased my 'shakes' - no epi pens or benadryl then. My mother counted 21 stings on my right leg - more on my left leg and arms. I carry benadryl now - allergic to everything - and a Vic 'Farmer' SAK. 'Survival' can take many turns... it's not all about building a lean-to. YMMV.

Stainz
 
LJ-Mosin Freak

Thanks. That is walnut that, believe it or not, was our baseboards in the old farm house. Whenever my dad refinished or remodeled a room, he'd replace it with painted modern lumber and set this fantastic stuff aside...unless he could reuse it.

The original handles on mine were very cheap plastic molded to look like jigged bone...they were never tight and they fell off.

I have never carried this knife (since I was a kid) because I just assumed that it's low price probably meant that it was inferior steel. It was my EDC when I was about 12...with the original handle and then a makeshift redwood one that my dad put on it. I put this walnut handle on it back in probably '77, '78 or something like that. Right now the thing is razor sharp.

This may be a better knife than I have given it credit for as an adult, seeing so many other ones out there.
 
I didn't realize the knives themselves were that old. Mine is sharp as it ever was, too. I've got a scar at the base of my index finger because of that, ended up severing the nerve on the outside of my trigger finger (go figure). I can't feel a thing on the outside edge of my finger now.

I carry it on my person every single day and I'd trust the knife with my life. It's gutted and skinned quite a few deer, and never have I regretted owning this knife. I gotta find some AA batteries for my digital camera so I can show you how I can carry this knife concealed.
 
Stainz

I have an LMF too. I have the "coyote" colored one. I really want to like it. It is very heavy and I have never been very happy with the sharpness of the fine edge. I have gone over it with my Lansky many times trying to find an angle that suites me. I'm not sure if the steel is not good, if I am just obsessing too much or what. This is the thickest, heaviest knife I have and that may be the problem. The workmanship on the thing is top notch and the sheath is excellent...but what a heavy package.

I have a Camillus version of the Marine Corps knive with the leather washers painted a very dark brown originally and the straight. That thing is like a razor blade.

I may just convert all the way over to Mora's, buy 20 of them, make decent sheaths, and just be happy.
 
You know, I have to admire this. For a guy named "Mosin-Freak" he has a certain charm with his very inexpensive ways of making stuff work.

Bravo sir.
 
My Pics of Survival Knives and what I own!

hello all, RON L here, I don't know that what I have can fix the "UNDER 100$" requirement and Frankly thjats not inmprotant to me, here is my list of what I have and what I recomend:


Ka-Bar Next Gen Combat/Utility Knife Kraylon handle ande Kydenex Sheath KnivesandHolsters001.jpg

CRTT Copy of Russel Sting 1A Boot Knife
KnivesandHolsters002.jpg

Gerber Multi Tool with Mag lite and LED conversion, Pouch Holds all and more Plus EMT Shears KnivesandHolsters004.gif

LeatherMan "Wave" Tool with Pouch
KnivesandHolsters005.gif

Spyderco Police Model Combat/Utility Folder
KnivesandHolsters001-1.gif
KnivesandHolsters002-1.gif

Mini tool andLed lite butane lighter
KnivesandHolsters003-1.gif

Swiss Tool
KnivesandHolsters006-1.gif
KnivesandHolsters007-1.gif

Swiss Key Chain Pocket Knife
SWISSKEYCHAIN001.gif

Kershaw Scallion
KERSHAW001.gif



I said, more than $100.00 more than a few repeathed fixed blade knives and gives me a "Mix" of items I need and use day to day!
 
ok those pics are awesome. i am going to have to go get pics of my EDC stuff.

And AWESOME wear on that spyderco lol.. you can tell this guy is not a poseur.
 
Hey RON...SURPLUS: How do you like that Kydex Ka-Bar sheath?

I've got a the older Camillus version of that knife and the sheath, while original I guess (bought new at Army Navy store), is not so hot...cheap rivets, soft leather etc.

They sell that sheath by itself and wonder if it would be worth the $25 bucks to get one for myself.
 
LJ-Mosin Freak

Thanks. That is walnut that, believe it or not, was our baseboards in the old farm house. Whenever my dad refinished or remodeled a room, he'd replace it with painted modern lumber and set this fantastic stuff aside...unless he could reuse it.

The original handles on mine were very cheap plastic molded to look like jigged bone...they were never tight and they fell off.

I have never carried this knife (since I was a kid) because I just assumed that it's low price probably meant that it was inferior steel. It was my EDC when I was about 12...with the original handle and then a makeshift redwood one that my dad put on it. I put this walnut handle on it back in probably '77, '78 or something like that. Right now the thing is razor sharp.

This may be a better knife than I have given it credit for as an adult, seeing so many other ones out there.

It looks better then mine that's for sure.... the one I have is stainless and flexes easily with hand pressure.

Yours appears to be developing a patina and has a different grind and no hilt.
 
Lead Head

It had an oval hilt back in the day but that is long gone, along with the plastic jigged bone.

This is definitely carbon steel. It has a pretty decent patina. The metal stains very easily. It has never really had any rust on it.

What I did was cut the two halves out with a jigsaw and then inletted each scale with a chisel so that the scales meet all the way around. I chiseled very slowly so that just as soon as the scaled met, I stopped...I am happy with the way it fits. So it is a full thickness tang. The holes I used for the pins are the orginal...other than doing without the hilt, the metal is unaltered from the orginal. I did this handle when I was about 19 or 20 (1978ish).

I got this orginally at the "dime store" in Tipton Indiana probably in 1968 or 1969 I would imagine. I would have been 10 or so. Couldn't have costed much more than $5 or else my parents would not have bought it for me. I remember seeing it in a glass case.
 
hso I totally agree. A bunch of you guys are saying that you think they are the bet knives simply by specs, but you have never actually used it or carried it? I say you can't say that it's the best survival knife until you've taken it out and tested it. That said, my favorite has been the Buck Nighthawk. Nice and heavy, nylon sheath with a plastic insert and easy to carry, and I've split plenty of wood with it.

Todd, what is the brand of the fixed blade knives in your pictures? I like the looks of them.
 
Todds knives are custom-made from JK Handmade Knives, about whom you can learn more by clicking here: Linky

If you like the look of his, you should see the cool little knife he got from JK for his son, which he posted about a couple three or four months ago.
 
I apologize for taking this off thread. Seeing a couple of my knive got me talking.

I have never been in a "survival situation" so can't really judge very well. When I "go out on a limb" like traveling a long way across the country or whatever, I always take:

  • My Collins Legitimus Machete...actually it goes everywhere in the trunk.
  • Either my Gerber LMF, my Camillus 7-inch (Ka-Bar alternative), or one of my Glock Field knives...for the heavy stuff.
  • One of my Moras...for when razor sharpness counts.
  • Victorinox Super Tinker.
  • Leatherman Surge.
 
Todd, what is the brand of the fixed blade knives in your pictures? I like the looks of them.

Todds knives are custom-made from JK Handmade Knives, about whom you can learn more by clicking here: Linky

Yes my go to fixed blades are made by John of JK Handmade Knives. Great knives,great prices, great guy.

you should see the cool little knife he got from JK for his son

Part of my son's survival equipment. Knife/firesteel/pocket sheath combo.

100_1142.jpg

I just got him this one too. It has the same blade/handle length as my pocket carry fixed blade. Only slimmer for his small size hands.

A "Slim Finn" from Koyote Knives..

100_1429.jpg

With his Vic Huntsman+, he is good-to-go with "survival"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top