Need help selecting film about war for 9/10th grade HS students

Status
Not open for further replies.
I concur with Glory, and if you had time, Band of Brothers. If you're looking for a human-impact side of war, I'd suggest The Pianist, or Schindler's List. Good examples of what happens when evil regimes are allowed to flourish.

...or more importantly, when only the government has guns...
 
Last edited:
If you could have shown FMJ, you could show practically any war film, documentary or series that doesn't also have nudity (Band of Brothers had some; it's a requisite to get on HBO :D)

My shortlist:
- All Quiet on the Western Front (I read the book and saw the movie sophomore year, and it's a poignant statement of what war does to people)
- Saving Private Ryan (there are some images, especially at the front of that movie, that do not pull any punches about the horror and cost of war)
- Band of Brothers (find an episode that doesn't have any scenes opening on casual sex :rolleyes:)
- FMJ (think VERY hard about this one; it makes less of a statement about war and more of a statement about the abuse you take before you even get there)
- Platoon (saw a censored version; it was less for the shock or "jugheads are crazy/war is hell" value and more for the prose of the letters written by the main character)
- Jughead (pretty fair, cleaner than reality of course, a decent portrait of modern war)
-Glory (great movie, saw that one in high school too)
 
Perhaps the best movie depiction of war and being an American is The Patriot (Mel Gibson) It should be required viewing in middle school.
 
It has been a long time since I saw it , "Breaker Morant" is a standout story about the Boer war.
 
In my HS we watched We Were Soldiers during the Sr class on Vietnam. The instructor was a veteran and he thought it was the best portrayal.

My vote would be Black Hawk Down.`
 
I have to go with finding time for "Band of Brothers", or at least a few installments of it. Kids are so inured to hollywood, it really breaks down a wall to watch the commentary and know, these are the men who were there, this is not just a story, here are the real words, from the real men who lived it.

WWII vets are leaving us in droves by the day, few things can compare to listening not to an actor, but to a man who jumped out of an airplane over France. Amazing.
 
Jarhead. Very good "modern" story. They might be able to relate better.

Saving Private Ryan. Just a fantastic film, war or otherwise. Very realistic.

Schindler's List. While not a war film per se, it occurred during WWII and portrays the worst part of WWII. Remind them that genocide occurred before and after the Holocaust, and that it is still occurring today.
 
WWI...............All Quiet on the Western Front
WWII..............Saving Private Ryan or The Longest Day or Band of Brothers
Korean War......Pork Chop Hill
Vietnam...........Once We Were Soldiers
War on Terror...Blackhawk Down

The beginning of Full Metal Jacket is the best to show what guys went through to become Marines in the 60s according to guys I know who have been through it. The rest of it doesn't impress me that much. I'm a Vietnam Vet (Army) with active duty and reserve time starting in 1967.

PS Check the ratings if you're showing them in a high school class
 
Last edited:
The film "Downfall". It is in German, but is subtitled. Excellent war movie that is portrayed from eyes other than the victors.
 
does it need to be about a real war? star ship troopers is pretty good, but has a brief nude shower scene. lots of things to think about.

does it need to be about viet nam? zulu is a very fine war movie. mostly about how very average people can do a lot when they really have to. richard burton's narration at the end is a classic moment IMO.
 
Platoon is a great movie.
Black Hawk Down is good.
Band of Brothers.
Saving Private Ryan.
Bravo Two Zero is ok, but it deals with torture and stuff for a different take.
We Were Soldiers.
Jarhead.
 
To Hell And Back
written by Audie Murphy most decorated soldger in ww2
staring Audie Murphy
based on book by Audie Murphy
Murphy was 16 when he went in and 19 when he came out
 
In no particular order
Saving Private Ryan-The first twenty minutes should do it.
Gallipoli-A very good movie for an Australian flick.
The Lost Battalion-A fantastic movie.
Glory-
84 Charlie Mopic-Obscure Nam flick in 1st person POV
Hamburger Hill-Gruesome
We Were Soldiers
The Big Red One-Wish they would remake this one.

It's too bad that being in an English class they're nor reading a book. There are too many good war books out there to mention but I digress...
 
I didn't like Jarhead. Honestly, I didn't really like the focus around the main character's girlfriend for about half of the movie.
Saving Private Ryan was... well, it's a good movie but most younger people see that sorta thing for the violence, not the story. Just make sure they understand what's going on. Or only show the beach landing scene, and discuss it, perhaps.
Starship Troopers?
HA! Okay, I will admit, it had some good scenes. Playing the propaganda angle would be interesting.
And of course... "What good's a knife in a nuke fight? All you have to do is press a button... sir."
 
Once We Were Soilders - i love this movie (although i have a hard time not crying). it has a very good message about soilders of both sides of a conflict being people. and although it is made up, the part about the wives is very moving. This movie is good for historical purposes because it follows a battle that really changed how americans viewed the war and how the war would be fought. my Vietnam History teacher (who was also a vetren of the war) praised this movie on multiple levels.
Full Metel Jacket is a good movie for an english class, not so much because that its a war movie, but because its an intresting storyline.
if you watch Apocolypse Now, make them read the book first. i will also add that in Virginia Public Schools, we covered this in 12 grade english (we read the book and we're told to watch the movie at home if our parents would allow it)
Black Hawk Down is my favorite newer war movie about a modern conflict. i happen to like the fact that its not so much a story, but rather a reinactment. i also love the line "Sir, their shooting at us!" "Then shoot Back!" *grin*
 
Band Of Brothers. If you can only show 1 episode, show them the 80 minute documentary on it titled "We Stand Alone Together : The Men of Easy Company"

Also, I have not seen it yet but, Ken Burns has a new Documentary titled "The War". I have heard that it is VERY, VERY good. It's 15 hours and $130 for the 6 dvd set so, I dunno. http://www.pbs.org/thewar/

Edited to add.

Actually, I just notice this. "The War" by Ken Burns has something just for you...

For Educators

The wealth of themes explored in THE WAR offer an extraordinary educational opportunity for your classroom. The materials on this web site are specifically designed to help teachers use THE WAR and its themes not only to teach the history of the Second World War, but also to bring the powerful medium of storytelling into the classroom.


http://www.pbs.org/thewar/edu_overview.htm
 
Though I'm not a veteran (as per the OP's wishes), I really cannot state enough how well I think "Saints and Soldiers" fits the bill. It's a well done film that shows heroism, some of the senselessness of war, some of the just "reality"/intensity of conflict, importance of the mission, and shows some of the "personal/character development" aspects of good films.

I'd give it a shot. Not a "major motion picture" by the "industry", but for an independent developer, it's pretty spiffy.
 
Actually, if you can encourage them to read, you might have some luck with "The Short-Timers," the story FMJ was based on, as well as its sequel, "The Phantom Blooper"
I encourage FMJ fans to read both
here
if you've got the time.

Also, in "The Short Timers" readers get to actually see Joker's thoughts and emotions as the film could not properly portray.

Training continues.
I teach Leonard everything I know, from how to lace his black combat boots to the assembly and disassembly of the M-14 semi-automatic shoulder weapon.
I teach Leonard that Marines do not ditty-bop, they do not just walk. Marines run; they double-time. Or, if the distance to be covered is great, Marines hump, one foot after the other, one step at a time, for as long as necessary. Marines work hard. Only ****birds try to avoid work, only ****birds try to skate. Marines are clean, not skuzzy. I teach Leonard to value his rifle as he values his life. I teach him that blood makes the grass grow.
"This here gun is one mean-looking piece of iron, sure enough." Leonard's clumsy fingers snap his weapon together.
I'm repulsed by the look and feel of my own weapon. The rifle is cold and heavy in my hands. "Think of your rifle as a tool, Leonard. Like an ax on the farm."
Leonard grins. "Okay. You right, Joker." He looks at me. "I'm sure glad you're helping me, Joker. You're my friend. I know I'm slow. I always been slow. Nobody ever helped me..."
I turn away. "That sounds like a personal problem," I say. I keep my eyes on my weapon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top