russlate
Member
Like the cars of the '50's had fins, and the cars of the late '90's and early twenty-first century have rear end spoilers, the revolver makers have been succumbing to a perverse trend that says all handguns should have ribbed and fully underlugged or heavy bull barrels.
Tried to buy a 22 auto without a bull barrel lately?
I recently picked up a Police Positive Mark V. It has a low but solid rib on top of the barrel, a heavy untapered cylindrical barrel and a Diamondback like full length underlug running all the way to the muzzle. Late model 36 3" target sighted chiefs' have also succumbed to such tomfoolery. And the K-22 has been ruined with a similar addition.
It's time to tell the gun companies to knock the trend off!
There are good reasons for a heavy bull barrel, a ventilated rib, and a solid underlug on a target or hunting handgun. The heavy barrel dampens twitches. The ventilated rib helps dissipate heatwaves. The underlug breaks up the harmonic vibrations to stiffen the barrel.
Anyway, the point of this diatribe is that heavy barrels are heavy to carry. They also take more momentum to start and stop moving. Try an early Police Positive Special with 4" pencil barrel and exposted ejector against a 4" PP Mark V or a Diamondback. Now Smith and Wesson is about to discontinue the K frame in favor of the L frame. Fine: put a 4" pencil barrel model 10 up against a 4" L frame with top rib and full underlug. Guess which Colt and S&W is going to get the first hit? The lighter more easily manuverable ones.
The moral of this story is to carry "just enough" gun and no more. or you'll end up leaving it at home instead of having it on you when it's needed.
I feel much better now that I've said that.
Tried to buy a 22 auto without a bull barrel lately?
I recently picked up a Police Positive Mark V. It has a low but solid rib on top of the barrel, a heavy untapered cylindrical barrel and a Diamondback like full length underlug running all the way to the muzzle. Late model 36 3" target sighted chiefs' have also succumbed to such tomfoolery. And the K-22 has been ruined with a similar addition.
It's time to tell the gun companies to knock the trend off!
There are good reasons for a heavy bull barrel, a ventilated rib, and a solid underlug on a target or hunting handgun. The heavy barrel dampens twitches. The ventilated rib helps dissipate heatwaves. The underlug breaks up the harmonic vibrations to stiffen the barrel.
Anyway, the point of this diatribe is that heavy barrels are heavy to carry. They also take more momentum to start and stop moving. Try an early Police Positive Special with 4" pencil barrel and exposted ejector against a 4" PP Mark V or a Diamondback. Now Smith and Wesson is about to discontinue the K frame in favor of the L frame. Fine: put a 4" pencil barrel model 10 up against a 4" L frame with top rib and full underlug. Guess which Colt and S&W is going to get the first hit? The lighter more easily manuverable ones.
The moral of this story is to carry "just enough" gun and no more. or you'll end up leaving it at home instead of having it on you when it's needed.
I feel much better now that I've said that.