Pinuti: Kris Cutlery or Valiant Co?

[Skofnung]

I've been taking Modern Arnis classes for some time now, and I've decided that I want a live blade that fits in with this martial art.

The Pinuti seems to fit my style better than a Bolo or a Barong, as I tend to thrust as often as I slash. I guess it's just my prior fencing experience showing through.

Anyway, Kris Cutlery and Valiant both offer Pinutis at comparable prices, the Valiant having a better sheath for a slightly higher price. My concern is with the blade and hilt.

Does anyone know if one is better than the other?

Thanks.

 

[SeanSw]

With a name like Skofnung, I'd suggest this:



But....... since you asked specifically, I'd go for the Kris Cutlery pinuti. I have only read great things about it, and my experiences with KC sword blades have all been positive.

 

[Skofnung]

Yhea, don't think for a minute that I won't have a pattern welded Type VI or a Migration Type I at some point... There's a very good local swordsmith that I'll get to do it if I ever get enough mad money to do so. Who made that one?

 

[hso]

I've handled products from both and both are excellent so it's just a question of what you like the feel and look of best. I will say that the new Cas Iberia Fillipino line is excellent. They're using L6 steel built into solid weapons instead of wall hangers. The company took a big step into expanding their MA weapons last year and have very seriously moved to produce real weapons for real use.

 

[SeanSw]

Skofnung, that's a Vince Evans piece. I've owned a number of Viking era swords but nothing that compares to that level of craftsmanship.

I'm impressed that CAS Iberia is marketing L6 steel weapons. I don't use swords any longer but I'd love to see what's new in the industry.

 

[Skofnung]

Hmmm, I wasn't aware of the CAS Iberia line... Would you consider it to be superior to Kris or Valiant?

Please note that I plan on using this thing for real cutting, as in pool noodles, mats, and in the unlikley event that I am without a firearm and it is nearby, self defense in extremis.

Thanks for the help.

 

[hso]

I'll let you know after next weekend since I'll see them at the Blade Show in Atlanta. I expect them to be a notch above the other 2.

 

[Skofnung]

Thanks. I'll be eagerly awaiting your thoughts. Have fun at the show!

 

[Skofnung]

So HSO,

Did you get a chance to check out the CAS Iberia line of blades? What did you think?

Thanks.

 

[hso]

No joy!

CAS is going to be bought by Paul Chen and the entire booth was set up to display the Japanese and Chinese works. Not a single FMA item in sight!!!

 

[Skofnung]

That's a let down.

Thanks for keeping an eye out though!