Practice what you carry?

Status
Not open for further replies.

pv18463

Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2009
Messages
37
Location
Washington
I have decided to change to the 9mm for my CCW with 124gr ammo. I am interested in your opinion on whether to practice with 124gr ammo or use 115gr for less cost/more practice. Does the benefit of more practice outweight the "practice what you carry"?
 
Do some training with both types of rounds.

If you feel no noticeable difference, and have the same speed and control over both, go with the lesser round.
 
practice with the 115gr, put a couple of mags of your carry ammo through each range session to stay familiar with the muzzle flip and flash. unless your gun is really unusual, there won't be that much difference in the POI out to 25 yards
 
Once reliability is established, load a few 115 and a few 124 and see if you can tell the difference. If you can't, practice with what's cheap and make a point of hitting the range with carry ammo every 3-4 months.
 
When I go to the range I fire the first two mags that are loaded with my carry ammo, the mag in the gun and my spare.

Then I practice with the 115 gr hardball for the rest of the session.

When done playing I reload the mags with my carry ammo and head on home.

This way I have function tested the gun and mags with my every day carry ammo and have fresh ammo in the gun.

Yeah it costs a little bit but it's not going to break the bank, and the peace of mind knowing my gun functions well with my carry ammo is worth it to me.
 
Since it sounds like you do not reload your one practice ammo? I never assume anything you know what that does.

I am an advocate of shooting as close as possible ammo that has the same exact recoil impulse and point of aim as my carry/home defense/zombie ammo.

So if you want the same pick a factory load as close as possible. BTW- At least in my area they price of things like 9mm 124gr NATO ammo is fairly cheap.
 
When I first buy a gun, I go through a few boxes of defense ammo to see which one shoots the most reliably and accurately. After that, I don't shoot my defense ammo again. It is nothing but a waste of good money. I practice with FMJ or lead. Whatever is cheapest at that time.

If the time actually comes where you'll need to pull the trigger, you be at 20-30 feet. Accuracy is not an issue between different types of ammo at that distance. They will all shoot about the same. The only other argument some people have is different levels of recoil and such. It you're actually shooting under REAL CONDITIONS, you won't know or feel the difference between a 115 grain fmj winchester white box and a 147 grain buffalo-bore +P round. Your brain and adrenaline won't let you. So, assuming that you hit your target; 70% of your shots are most likely to miss; you won't be able to tell the difference in ammo. Save your money. Practice with the cheap stuff. And no, your ammo doesn't need to be "Refreshed". The same ammo can stay in the magazine for years. It will be fine as long as it's not getting wet or corroded.
 
I would recommend implementing your carry load into your practice routine; as much as you can afford to do so, that is. Of course, this takes on more prevalence if you tend to use +P ammo for defense vs standard pressure loads.

Regardless, the main idea here is to make sure that your carry gun maintains a reliable consistency when firing your defense load of choice.

Where to divide the line between how often to shoot "practice" ammo vs "defense" ammo is entirely up to you, ammo availability and your budget.
 
Last edited:
i would do most of my practicing with what is cheapest to shoot, but i would also run a couple of magazines of my carry rounds to make sure they always feed reliably. shooting inexpensive ball round is nice, but if you like to use winchester silver tips for a carry round, you best make sure that they feed reliably on a regular basis.
 
I have decided to change to the 9mm for my CCW with 124gr ammo. I am interested in your opinion on whether to practice with 124gr ammo or use 115gr for less cost/more practice. Does the benefit of more practice outweight the "practice what you carry"?
Practice with the 115 gr, but end your session with a box of the 124 gr carry rounds so you develop muscle memory. I am doing that with my 357, shooting 124 gr for practice, but also shooting a few cylinders of 158 gr full power loads before I go home.
 
Old Shooter said:
When I go to the range I fire the first two mags that are loaded with my carry ammo, the mag in the gun and my spare.

Then I practice with the 115 gr hardball for the rest of the session.

When done playing I reload the mags with my carry ammo and head on home.

This way I have function tested the gun and mags with my every day carry ammo and have fresh ammo in the gun.

Yeah it costs a little bit but it's not going to break the bank, and the peace of mind knowing my gun functions well with my carry ammo is worth it to me.

That's exactly what I do, for exactly the same reasons.

Les
 
In 9mm I can't tell much difference in recoil/accuracy between 115gr +P+ JHP's and whitre box FMJ....so I do about 90% of my practice with the cheaper stuff.
 
Load a mag with alternating rounds of each and shoot a group. If you don't notice any difference (and I doubt you will) then just keep the carry ammo for carrying and practice with the cheap stuff.
 
I agree with some of the others here that at SD ranges, with 9mm, the change in POI will be so small that it's irrelevant. In that scenario the more one practices and becomes familiar with their gun, the more natural and instinctive it will be to use under duress. The cheaper the ammo, the more one shoots. To a non-reloader, the difference in costs between defensive ammo and utility ammo can be great and can have a significant impact on how much one practices. To most handloaders this difference is small and sometimes isn't enough to justify shooting something different. Many times we just use the plinking stuff to save wear and tear on our guns and on us. That said, I advise you to still shoot enough of your defensive ammo to make sure it is as accurate as possible outta your gun.....and don't make a decision on your ammo because of what a friend or the media tells you is best. Try different types to see what performs best and shoots the most accurate outta your gun, then make the switch to cheap practice rounds.....and if your cheap practice rounds are more accurate than the SD ammo you have, you might want to consider using it for your SD. I see all the time where folks put more importance on the hype the manufacturer of a new bullet puts out there than how the round actually performs outta their weapon, and sometimes, because it is so cost prohibitive, they don't shoot enough of it to realized, it don't shoot worth a hoot outta their weapon.
 
At 5-10 yards, there's not going to be any significant accuracy difference between different ammo in the same gun. Also, my gun isn't going to go from shooting my defensive ammo perfectly to not being able to shoot it. So once I've established the best defensive ammo that I and my pistol like, I almost NEVER shoot my defensive ammo again. No, it's not going to go old and stale. I don't need to put "Fresh" ammo in my magazines. And in a real self defense situation, your brain is not going to know the difference between 115 grain and 147 +P+ Buffalo-Bore. Your anxiety and adrenaline won't allow it. I'm just not going to waste that kind of money.

Then again, I know people that NEVER PLINK with their carry or home defense weapon. They'll plink all day with other guns. But before they leave, they'll put a whole $20-$30 box of defensive ammo through their carry/defense pistol, so they can stay proficient with it. I guess they figure $300 a year to practice a box a month through the pistol is worth it. And there's something to be said for that. You can do probably 80-90% of your training using a 22LR pistol. You only need to shoot your carry/defensive pistol enough to become desensitized to the recoil and to not lose touch of the feel. I could probably do that too because I own enough guns, but I choose to shoot for fun. I've been shooting for so long that I don't worry about things like muscle memory or recoil. And my 45acp isn't going to shoot any different with 230 grain lead or 230 grain golden sabers. Neither will my other carry weapons like my 9mm mak, 32acp, or 380acp. Save your money!!! You don't gain a thing by shooting your defensive ammo once you know it functions properly with that ammo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top