That's right, Joe. In the 5 years or so I've posted the challenge, NO PG fan has seen fit to take it up. That includes you.
Here's the challenge, one more time....
You determine the course of fire, range, and ammo. You use a PG only shotgun of ANY make, model and modifications. Bolt on any accessory you desire.
I'll use one of my 870s. Score determines who wins, time settles ties. Results posted rat cheer. I'll win. If we swapped shotguns, you'd win. A PG is THAT much of a handicap.
A PG with no stock turns one of the finest close range weapons into something much less lethal. It makes a fine shoulder arm into a large, awkward handgun that's hard to control and harder to shoot well.
Of if public humiliation is not your cup of tea, try this.
Shoot as you have been doing, recording scores and times. Then, add a regular stock instead of that thrice cursed PG. Shoot the same COFs again recording the scores and times. Compare, swallow hard, and sell that PG to someone you do not like.
PG only shotguns may be OK for toys, but real world folks need tools.
For the record, I got paid to shoot shotguns from the hip using State ammo. I doubt there was anyone in the state better at that time. I shot hundreds of rounds from the hip using folding stocks one summer. None of my 870s has ever seen a PG and none ever will. That's a lesson there.....
once.