Ruger SP101...in .38 Special...worth the extra cash??

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 1, 2005
Messages
249
Location
Louisiana
I have a good number of .38 Specials in snub and service sizes built by Charter Arms, Rossi, Taurus and of course S&W. I have the chance to pick up a Ruger SP101 with a 3" barrel in .38 Special. I have shot such guns and lover how they handle. But, I am wondering if it is worth the extra cash. I know the SP101 is built to handle .357 Magnums all day long. But, in .38 Special can it do any more say than my Model 10s S&W??

Thanks
 
I've had a 2 inch SP101 in .38 Special ever since they came out and Crimson Trace laser grips on it. I carry the Federal 147-gr. HydraShok +P+ LE loads in it and have shot this gun ALOT with +P equivalent handloads for practice. The SP101 is one of the most sturdy compact .38s out there. In my experience the S&W Model 10 firing +P service loads requires adjustment by a factory-trained armorer every 2000 rounds to avoid problems with excessive cylinder end play from frame stretch. You can stretch the crane on a K- or J-frame twice before cylinder gap opens to exceed the maximum tolerance of 0.008." When you get to that point the gun needs to either have the barrel set back and or have a new cylinder fitted. When I worked at Ruger on the SP101 its design objective was to stand firing 5000 rounds of U.S. Treasury Q4070 110-gr. +P+ ammunition without cleaning, only "dunking" the hot gun in a bucket of water to cool it off, no malfunctions, repairs or parts replacements beyond the user level. That objective was met fully.

Having a .38 Special chambered cylinder is more accurate when firing soft lead or lightweight jacketed bullets in +P loads than when firing the same .38 Special ammo in the longer chambers of a .357 cylinder. I had a .357 SP101 for a while but sold it because it was less accurate with all ammos than my .38 and firing magnum ammunition in the 2-inch barrel had excessive muzzle flash which was detracting. Magnums will perform better in a 3 inch barrel, but I don't miss the ability to fire .357 ammo. The Federal 147-gr. HydraShok +P+ shoots to the sights, has lower muzzle flash than magnum ammo, will stay on my business card firing rapid DA at 7 yards, prints 3 inches or less off sandbags at 25 yards and gets 920 f.p.s. out of my 2 inch barrel. Works for me.
 
Last edited:
If this was your first .38, I'd say go for it.

But since it's not, I would get the SP-101 in .357. It's a little too clunky to be a .38 carry gun for me, although there is certainly nothing wrong with the design.
 
Yes...it is not my first .38 Special which complicates things. If it were in .357 Magnum it would be more difficult to so no to...even though I already have two Ruger Speed-Six .357 Magnums...LOL
 
When you ask can it doing anything more, what do you mean, "more"? The heavier barrel might help reduce muzzle flip, but other than that, I don't know what "more" it can do that your Model 10s won't do. I will say this though. I have the 3" SP101 .38 Special, and it is a heckuva gun in all respects. The trigger pull is perhaps more stout than your S&Ws, but if it's important, that can be taken care of with a little smithing. Maybe you should buy it and sell one of your other .38s. :D
 
I own a “38 Special Only” Ruger revolver and I love it. The only difference between in a 357 Ruger and 38 Ruger is the cylinder honing. Everything else is the same.
 
I'd say it would be a great gun to have. It might be stouter than a Model 10, but its for sure not any weaker. I have two SP101s (both magnums), but if the price was right, I'd sure buy another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top