S&W 5906 9mm CDNN $299.99 first look

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sky

Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
2,927
Location
Texas
I ordered the 5906 9mm 3 days ago and it showed up today. CDNN had them as a Police trade in for $299.99 in Stainless on page 21 of their on line catalog. I tore the gun down for inspection and I could not see any wear or baked on crude anyplace. The barrel rifling was there but to me looked light/maybe worn? I am used to looking at different calibers so in all honesty it could be normal for this gun.

It came with Hogue grips, night sights, and a match barrel! Gotta love law enforcement weapons!:cool:

I only had 50 rounds of 9mm with me so I will be waiting on my large order of 9mm to arrive sometime next week before I do anymore shooting with it.:mad:

For those who are not familiar with the pistol I am sorry I do not have a picture to post but like I said Pg 21 of their CDNN online catalog has a better picture than I could do.

The pistol does have the ambidextrous/safety decocker and comes in stainless with a 4" barrel. Being familiar with a single action 1911 it was rather unique for me to experiment with the 5906 double action and the decocker. I do like it's versatility already.;)

The mag holds 15 rounds in a double stack configuration and therefore the grip is not small or thin. I have big hands so to me the gun fits nicely in my shooting grip.

First three shots were taken at arms length waiting for the thing to blow up!! Very smooth recoil and no problems so I went to my normal point, aim, shoot and tried hitting some knock down targets 30 yards away. These targets are 4" wide and 7" tall. Three shots and one hit:what: OoooKKKK. Tried the double action for three shots just getting the feel with no hits at 30 yards which was expected for me. I like the trigger in both double and single action. The sights *for me* had the rounds impacting about 4" high but on line for POI.

I finally figured out where to aim to get the round on target and started knocking some of the plates down buy the last few rounds.:eek:

So far I am happy with my purchase and have not found anything I need to change or work out with the pistol. I am pretty picky about hand guns and think I have a keeper here. The slide spring has a lot of tension and is a bugger when trying to hold the slide back and remove the take down pin...1911 is easier to remove the pin because the spring tension is gone. In truth though the weapon and my hands had a nice coating of Breakfree CLP which did not make the tear down any easier. Yes I tore it down once and lubed and inspected it. Tore it down again after putting it together just to see if I could do it easier than the first time....Answer was no....need to work on it a bit! Suggestion; remove all lubricant from hands and exterior before trying this! :scrutiny:

If something breaks later on or I want to replace a part either S&W should have the parts or I will call Numrich 866-686-7424 which seems to have something for everything!! Someone else have any ideas I am all eyeballs!!:D

P.S. I know beat me with a spoon for no pictures; sorry! :barf:
 
Last edited:
I carried one for nearly a decade as a duty weapon. They are well made guns. They usually were very reliable as far as cycling. However, they were not really what I would call accurate. If my memory serves me correctly 4" 25 yard groups from a rest were about the best they usually would do.

Personally, I don't care for them as a defensive weapon. That double action first shot is the one that counts the most, but is often thrown off by the shooter.
 
ColtPythonElite maybe I got your old weapon?? I agree the double action first shot is not like a first shot with a Glock or a condition one 1911. I thought about either thumb cocking if a round is chambered, using the slide to chamber and cock or just use the double action. Pretty sure at 3 to 4 yards even with the double action I can achieve MOA of barn.
 
I bought my old weapon waay back when...I paid 180 bucks for it with 3 high cap mags (A plus when the Brady bill was in effect)...It had been issued to me new and I had kept the box and paperwork that came with it.
 
I can buy whatever I want but this will be my next. I'm in the stage of life where I'm replacing guns I had to sell for emergeicies. This is one.
 
It's not "Chrome," it's stainless steel.

Any handgunner worth their salt will master the DA pull, so first shot acccuracy is a sure thing.

A spring kit would help this along, but it's not difficult to master the DA pull.

Further, a serious handgunner will also master the first to second shot transition (by not moving their finger on the trigger) and have accurate double taps.
 
David E I may be half a shaker short on my salt level but do intend to do some serious work on improving. Its double action trigger seems to be solid with no give or play. I have not shot a double action pistol "in forever" and even when I was around them I always just shot single action. Revolver I always just cocked and shot. Just one of my many short comings due to the way I grew up shooting.
 
Last edited:
It's a rolling motion, don't worry about the trigger or the shot break, just concentrate on rolling the trigger smoothly and keeping your sights where they should be. I found that I actually got better at shooting because of spending a lot of time in DA mode. Really hammers home the importance of keeping your sight picture straight.
 
I bought one of those long time ago but I got the 40 cal version. Like you I couldn't find any wear and tear anywhere. Mine shoots great. Too big and heavy to carry though. I keep it in my desk drawer at work. I hated the grip on it so I changed it. It's a little better now but still not great. I ordered a model 65 revolver at the same time. It was also a police trade in. I prefer the revolver.
 
The grip is large to accommodate the double stack mag (but my hands are large and it fits me) and yes it is heavy. The purpose for me is a car pistol and the occasional night stand duty. My 1911 has the Crimsontrace laser for bumps in the dark and I always have my little p22 just because it goes in my pocket so well and is light. I just needed (relative term) something I could shoot and practice with that would function and not break the bank. The P22 is fun but not in the same class with the 5906 as far as recoil and noise.

My brother has smaller hands and will be purchasing a single stack "something" for his personal use. Trying to steer him towards a CZ for he will not be carrying in his government building. Just wants something for HD and to and from work. He likes thin and lite but never hunted or shot growing up. I think he just figured out how to check the oil in his car last year!! hahahahah
 
Did not happen if you do not post pics....LOL I have looked at a couple of these as truck/hidden house gun.
 
I have the .40 caliber version 4006, but I've always had a longing for a 5906. The S&W 3rd gen autopistols are nice guns, and $299 seems to be an excellent price for a decent used copy. Best of luck with yours!
 
Went to the range yesterday after going to Wally World for some 9mm....

Worked on the DA thing and seem to be getting better at rounds on target...Still not as accurate as SA but good enough for the casual 15ft encounter.

For the price I paid and the price of other stuff any more I just figure I can always sell the pistol and not get hurt if I decide it is not for me. So far I do plan on keeping it and am not to worried about something breaking on the 5906...It is built rather well IMO.....
 
I can't think of anything on one to break. They are tough guns. A little polishing here and there on the outside and they aren't too bad to look at. I polished out the sides of the slide on mine.
 
The 5900 series weapons are great guns. I am the proud original owner of a 5906 bought new in 1989. They feed any kind of ammo you choose, are reliable bordering on boring and they will last forever. Everyone and their brother comments on the weight. Yes, this gun is heavier than the plastic guns now overpopulating our gun community, but the weight has its advantages and if you get the proper leather holster, it can be carried comfortably. Congrats on your new gun.
 
Just checked the trigger pull on my 5906 that has a trigger pull reduction hammer spring installed and a light return spring.

Single action trigger pull is 5 1/8 lbs and the DA pull pegs the RCBS guage at 8.5 lbs, that is as far as it will read, probably about 9-10 lbs. DA pull now.
 
This is the first pistol I have ever owned with a decocker that works like this. Kinda makes me insecure with a round in the chamber as I hit the decocker! I have been letting the hammer down manually. Has there been any known problems or ADs that you guys know of with this type of set up? Sorry for the question; I do realize there would have to be a failure of some kind....but stuff happens!
 
More likely to have an AD lowering the hammer than using the decocker. Just be certain to point it in a safe direction (always, every gun), then it won't be something you have to stress over.
 
Yea was using the decocker but catching the hammer and not letting it fall. Kinda makes me flinch if I don't catch it...It will just take a little getting used to...old dog new tricks etc etc
 
Was at the range yesterday and got to load 5 mags and really give pistol a work out. I am very please with the recoil and smoothness of the 5906.

Finally got the sights figured out and for me I am pleased with the accuracy. My 1911 is more accurate in my hand but I am also more familiar with it's sights and idiosyncrasies. I will be keeping the 5906 and really did enjoy it's smoothness and low recoil.

Side note: I also shot a RRA commander size 45acp. It was a good shooter but I do not like the finish or the grips.

If it would have been stainless I would have done the deal but the gun's finish looked like something you would find on a military issue AR barrel! It did have a trigger that seemed extremely light....almost like a match trigger with a very crisp lite pull.
 
As they say "It's a Tack-Driver" and will probably outlast you!!
Third generation Smiths are great guns and are 'classic'...
If you like the 5906, try the 4006 and 4566...
A Great Collection... one of each!

4566006.jpg
 
If you really want to start collecting...
You can go after the lighter 'alloy' versions of the 5906...
The 5903 and 5904 (Black)...

And let the collection begin!!

5904004.jpg

3NIBs024.jpg
 
I can't think of anything on one to break. They are tough guns. A little polishing here and there on the outside and they aren't too bad to look at. I polished out the sides of the slide on mine.
I was told once that they have one weakness. If you drop them on pavement and it lands butt first on the back corner of the plastic grip, it can disable the gun. The spring is retained by the plastic grip and if it breaks back there at the base, the spring is disabled. Then gun won't fire.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top