S&W pre-18 .22 is a “masterpiece.”

vanfunk

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
1,335
Location
The widening gyre
Hello all:

Hope you’re all good out there. Haven’t posted in a loooong time. I’ve just been busy with work, family and, well, I just haven’t been shooting. Anyway, I’ve decided to step off the treadmill for a while and catch up on life as my father recently passed away and his death has reminded me of my own mortality. He had given me most of his guns already but as I was going through his things I found a few I didn’t even know about. In the back of his closet, wrapped in a silicon rag and then stuffed in a wool sock, was a gorgeous S&W pre-18 .22 combat masterpiece. It took me a minute to remember that this gun was actually my grandfather’s and that it had passed to my father upon his death in 1987. I hadn’t seen it since the early 80’s, and although I did a lot of shooting with my grandfather when I was a teenager, I had never shot this particular piece.

I believe it dates to the early 50’s and exhibits the duller, more matte blue of that era (as an aside, I actually kind of prefer this style of bluing over the higher polish). It was clearly shot but was taken care of. A little holster wear is evident at the end of the muzzle and there’s a small speck of rust on the trigger guard (which I’m sure I can improve with a little oil and brass wool). I’d say it’s a 95% gun.

I finally carved out an opportunity to shoot it today, and to say the least, it blew my little mind. Mind you, I have not been shooting in YEARS and I was way out of practice, so I wasn’t expecting much of myself. I put up a target at an optimistic 50 feet and loaded the cylinder with older Winchester Super-X high velocity fodder, the only .22LR I had on hand. The gun felt great in my hand and was so easy to put on target. I fired 6 rounds, single action, and took my time. Oh. My. Lord. The result was one ragged hole with one shot dropping just a half-inch low and to the left of the others. I was astonished and it was at that moment I realized why my Dad hadn’t given it to me before he died - he wanted it for himself! Good on you, old man! What a phenomenal firearm - everything about it - the “old world” craftsmanship, the style and form factor, the natural feel in the hand, the astonishing practical accuracy… it is a true masterpiece! Thanks for listening, dear reader!
 
The .22 Combat Masterpiece began production in 1949. Yours is a 5-screw; the top side plate screw was eliminated in 1955, so yours dates between 1949 and 1955. If you care to give the first 3 numbers of the serial number on the bottom of the grip I'll try to get closer.

edit: I have one from the 1970s, love it!
 
Last edited:
I have one just like it. Also like yours, it was my father's. It was the first handgun I ever shot; dad allowed me access to it whenever I wanted. I inherited it after he passed away several years ago. I have probably put more rounds through that revolver than I have through any other firearm, and it still looks pristine. It occupies a special place in my collection and I'll never part with it, at least until I pass.
 
I have a Model 18 or 22 4"...not sure which. It was heavily used when I got it. Grant Cunningham got it running again, but it finally degraded to the point where I won't shoot it.

I must say that the quality of the gun exceeds the feel of the newer ones. I don't know why, but I can tell. Perhaps it's just heavier by a little bit.
 
Thanks everyone! These little .22’s do seem to stir the emotions, don’t they? Driftwood, thank you for pointing out the distinction between hammer styles on our respective revolvers. I’ll presume for now that my example was made between ‘49 and ‘52 until I can check the serial number. My grandfather had a brace of H&R 999 revolvers he bought and carried pre-war on his farm in Michigan. They’re both 6” versions and I can see him buying this S&W to have something more deluxe and portable. I have those H&R’s as well and plan to give them to my two kids when they’re a bit older.
 
Thanks everyone! These little .22’s do seem to stir the emotions, don’t they? Driftwood, thank you for pointing out the distinction between hammer styles on our respective revolvers. I’ll presume for now that my example was made between ‘49 and ‘52 until I can check the serial number. My grandfather had a brace of H&R 999 revolvers he bought and carried pre-war on his farm in Michigan. They’re both 6” versions and I can see him buying this S&W to have something more deluxe and portable. I have those H&R’s as well and plan to give them to my two kids when they’re a bit older.
Gun's handed down from family are special guns. Before I bought my first revolver my wife's father, retired state police, passed and left his Colt Trooper 357 service weapon to my wife. After getting my permit I took it to the range, put the target out 50ft. and said to myself "I need a little help here, Bill." All six shots in the bullseye, most touching which never happened before or since that day. I quit shooting after one cylinder because I didn't want to ruin that moment. I've no doubt Bill was standing beside me that day.
 
I’ve looked up the date of manufacture and it’s in the range for 1953 production like Driftwood’s. It must be a “transitional” specimen as it has the earlier “speed” hammer. Interesting. I love it and I can’t wait to take my son and daughter shooting with it. It brings me joy to know they’ll be able to shoot some of their great-grandfather’s guns. I think I’ll wait on introducing them to the Thomas Bland and Sons .470 Nitro Express double rifle though!
 
Great looking 5-screw...and a wonderful history for it as well. A superb gift to your children when the time comes.

Here's mine, and It'd be the last .22 I'd sell if forced. This one will stay with my M-41 Smith for accuracy and is world's better for reliability. Some might say the weight's a bit much or a .22, but I'd counter with, 'the weight helps for a steady hold...K frames are my #1 love of all the Smith revolvers, and this one is just perfect. Best Regards, Rod

S-W-M18.jpg
 
A very cool story about a special revolver, thank you for sharing! :thumbup:

My Dad wasn’t a handgunner. He has an old Colt Huntsman he bought new ages ago, but he would rather chase quail and chuckar through the desert with a Remington shotgun than shoot targets or rabbits with his .22. Same with my Grandfather, as rifles and shotgun were his thing on the ranch. He had a new frontier .22, a US Property marked 1911 and a .38 S&W break top that he found, but I can’t recall ever seeing him shoot one of them. Unlike me, they just weren’t that into handguns.

So, I had to get involved with S&W .22 revolvers on my own. Started with a 6” 17-3 .22 LR, then a 6” 48 in .22 WMR. Once I got on a bit of a K-frame run, I saw a nice used Model 18 4” that just had to be paired with the 4” .38’s I had. As I expected, it is a great understudy for the center fires. Like the 6” rimfire pair, the Model 18 was followed by a NIB 4” Model 48.

I couldn’t be happier, the K-frame rimfires are all fantastic revolvers.

C0E447D7-D31A-4060-A125-D7F30D92F93F.jpeg

I need to start looking for a smith revolver in 22

You won’t be disappointed. Once you see, feel and shoot a well cared for older K frame rimfire you will be hooked. :thumbup:

Stay safe.
 
I love all the stories and the pictures! Thank you for all the replies! It’s 45 degrees and sunny here in the Northeast, so I decided to take the Masterpiece out for another go. I set up my .22 bullet trap in the backyard and backed up to the 25 yard line. Again all I had on hand was the pretty old (30 years!) Winchester Super-X high velocity copper-plated stuff. Here are the results of four cylinders-full, single action, slow fire:
upload_2023-3-9_13-11-29.jpeg

Most of them went into the same hole, about a half-inch higher than the red dot in the center. I was using a six-o’clock hold. That’s an astonishing group for me; the poor revolver is capable of much more accuracy than I am. I just love this thing.
 
You have proven that old Winchester ammo is good, but I don't buy Winchester or Remington .22LR these days. Too many failures to fire.

You might see how your revolver likes Federal, CCI, or Eley ammo. And I wanna see pictures! :thumbup:
 
Back
Top