armsmaster270: I haven't closely followed the PD cylinder issues, as I have a M&P 340 with the steel cylinder. Apparently the standard cylinders on the PD can have the chambers' coating easily scratched, leading to hard extraction and possible cylinder expansion and cylinder failure.
IOW, the M&P 340 cylinder is "better" because it is less prone to damage, albeit two ounces heavier.
I have read of owners who have had at least two cylinders replaced and then having S&W offer to install the steel cylinder (thereby making it like the M&P 340--i.e., 2 oz. heavier.)
It was an issue at least two years ago (when I researched the 340s, and selected the M&P version), and I think it can continue--but somebody else who has followed the topic closely will have to comment on that.
Jim H.