slip-on recoil pad Coach Gun ?

[mulletguter]

I picked up a Rossi 12ga Coach Gun, the recoil pad is shot so I’m going to get a slip-on for it. Limbsaver and Pachmayer have good reviews. I’m leaning to the Pachmayer because it’s leather and has an adjustable strap. Any one have experience with either one? Price is within a few bucks so that's not a factor. Thanks