Solunar tables: whitetail horoscope or science?

Status
Not open for further replies.

springmom

Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2005
Messages
3,599
Location
Spring TX
I always check the solunar tables when I'm going hunting. I know when the "best" times and the "good" times are supposed to be, and today at least, they were correct for where I was hunting (no, didn't get one, dangit).

But I always feel a little silly doing this...sort of like when I was a kid and always read the horoscope in the paper. It was superstition, I knew it was superstition, but I just *had* to read it. Now, I just *have* to check the solunar tables.

What do you all think? Is the solunar data important? Is it valid? And if so, how important is it compared with, say, weather (temp, wind, cloud cover) in determining whitetail activity on a given day? Do you check the tables? What has your experience shown?

Springmom
 
I found a website that gave total lunar tables for white tails. Predicted the pre-rut, peak rut, all that. Gave the reasons for all the phases.

It was off by 3 weeks. I could have done better with a dart board.

If you're interested in the tables for your exact location

http://www.sunrisesunset.com

I've found the biggest factor in successful hunting is being in the field instead of home on the couch
 
I have noticed that deer removed from the suburbs, in farm country or in National forests seem to behave according to the tables, but the suburban deer may be affected by things like the movement of people, equipment, or even when the local suburbanites put out food to feed them. The last factor might be one of the most important, are the deer moving to areas where they find food based on the time it's placed out for them, not on the lunar cycles?

LD
 
I'm a retired Conservation Officer, and a Wildlife Biologist by training.

I've found "some" validity to the charts, but far too many other variable factors affect the animals to a greater degree.

The biggest factor is weather. A front approaching will trigger feeding followed by seeking shelter immediately preceding a frontal passage. After the initial blast of inclement weather, the animals will again begin feeding until the temps stabilize. They will then return to the "normal" pattern whatever that might be.

Secondly is sunset/sunrise. A peak in movement occurs after sunrise and typically ends about 2hrs. later when the diurnal animals (deer, bear,racoons, ect.) will bed down for a lengthy period. Another movement will occur preceeding sunset. Really successful hunters I know who kill a LOT of BIG deer, know they typically move from one dense area to another sometime between noon and 2pm. Knowing where this is can produce a lot of good opportunities. One typical scenerio is from dense pine thickets to a hammock on a swamp. Hunt the borders between these areas at this time. Hence, don't neccessarily sit in a single shooting house or stand ALL DAY, if experience tells you that you won't see much in the middle of the day. Shift from small woodland food plots in AM and hit the large field borders in late evening. Perhaps walk slowly through dense pines during periods of high wind in mid day.

Tactics will also trump the "Charts". By the way, deer can't read, but they do listen to the human activity, and they often have you patterned better than you do them!

Local conditions such as drought, heavy snowfall, lack or abundance of food sources add to the "guess work".

Rut and/or breeding season will alter the patterns.

Like another poster mentioned, spend a lot of time in wildlife habitat, and you are likely to be there when they move.

HINT, watching the weather forecasts are a better indicator of animal activity than the "horoscope" or solunar tables.

Also, be WHERE the game is. Generally, 95% of the game animals are in 20% of their available habitat. Find out where that 20% is and catalog it in your diary; where, when, and why! Then, you'll know where to look next year. My older brother spent many hours watching mule deer in Montana while he was stationed there guarding nuclear missle sites. He could almost predict within minutes and tenth's of a mile where the deer and antelope would be based on season (time of year), time of day, and local weather conditions. When he got time to hunt, he was able to fill all his tags with a minimum of effort and EXPENSE.

Most other biggame animals aren't much different.
 
redneck2 and GooseGestapo have covered it nicely. I've never hunted by the tables myself but I have picked up a copy left at the camp by someone and perused it from time to time. I've watched fourteen deer amble around my stand during a period the tables said to stay home and don't bother. I've hunted honey spots when the tables said it was prime time and seen nothing.

As far as being in the woods go though, to be evenhanded I must admit that I've hunted hard and often an entire season in an area where the season before I killed ten deer and only had the opportunity to miss a pair of running does the entire season. Sign everywhere-fresh tracks, scrapes, rubs, fresh droppings, even heard bucks fighting a couple of times before sunrise, they just didn't seem to be moving in daylight that season.

I've seen several groups of bucks and does this year...several weeks before the start of the rut. They have patterns but sometimes-often right about the time you finally think you know what's going on-they start doing something different.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top