Stainless or blued?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BP Hunter

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2006
Messages
1,516
Location
WA
Many guns come in either stainless or blued. The stainless obviosuly costs more than the blued. I am looking into a 1911, most probably a Taurus PT 1911. (please don't get started over a Taurus):eek: The stainless is "prettier" than the blued. Are there any advantages of stainless over blued? Will it last longer? Or is it just for the looks?
 
The main difference between stainless and blued guns will be answered by how the gun is used. Bluing is actually a form of introduced corrosion to the metal, but not like corrosion in the sense of rust. But like rust, if you rub blued metal with something for long enough, the bluing will come off completely, showing bare metal. Holsters will do this with continual use. You'll see it on guns that have spent most of their life inside a holster. Stainless won't rub off like bluing will. So in cases where the gun is holstered, the stainless will look the same for a significantly longer period than the blued gun will. Blued guns will also have a tendancy to rust on their own. Leave a blued gun in a basement without any oil and you'll see surface rust in a matter of months, whether the gun has been used or not. Grab a blued gun with your bare hand and leave it alone for a few months and you'll see surface rust form where you touched the gun because of the moisture and salts of your hand. If you drop a blued gun and put a scratch in the finish, it will be that way forever unless you introduce bluing back to the scratched area. Drop a stainless gun and put a scratch on it and you can generally buff and polish the scratch right out. I'm not very good with metalurgy, but stainless has less carbon which makes it more resistant to rust. I have for a fact seen cheaper grade stainless actually rust and I was told that because it was cheap stainless, it had more carbon content which caused it to rust more easily.

As to "prettier", that's all the in eye of the beholder. I've got a Python with a perfect Royal Blue finish that will put any stainless gun to shame. Not all bluing is the same. My first 1911 was a Taurus with a blued finish. That gun has a very poor bluing and it would surface rust within a week if not kept with a sheen of oil. Put that gun next to the Python and you'll see two totally different finishes, even though they're both blued.
 
It's personal taste largely, but I think for concealed carry blued is more ideal, if only because it's less likely to draw attention. That said, I have both. I think any well-maintained firearm will last a long time.
 
Hello BP Hunter and Cyclops.... I'm over here in Pullman

"Prettier" is in the eye of the beholder.

I have a S&W 1911 in Stainless Steel, it has the
"Matte" ( via bead blasting ) finish I also have a
S&W 625 5" Bbl. also with the "Matte" finish" Most of
the Stainless steel revolvers by S&W including my 617
and 60 have the 'Satin" finish" which is shiny/polished
Most friends or others who compare the "Matt" to "Satin"
as I do, prefer the "matte" However the "Matte" finish
with the roughing up by the bead blasting may be
less corrosion resistant than a "Satin" finish" In either case
Stainless Steel is more corrosion resistant to a Blued carbon
steel firearm.

Personally, I think the S&Ws with the deluxe high pollish
like the 27, 25-2 etc. blued have a depth in the finish that
cannot be matched by any Stainless Steel model.

Taurus huh, well best of luck should you need customer service.

Randall - grew up in Quincy Same Green and Gold
as the Richland Bombers.
 
Blued for looks, stainless for rust resistance. If you live in a sultry, humid climate, you're best off with stainless, especially if you are going to be wearing the gun IWB and you sweat a lot.

If you're conscientious about cleaning and maintenance of your guns, then perhaps blued would suit you. If you're like most people and don't like all the extra work involved, get stainless, as it tolerates neglect far better than blued guns do.
 
I like SS Ruger wheelguns, and blue S&W wheelguns. Colts wheelguns can can be SS or blue. Auto's can be either. I have two nickle wheelguns, and have decided I am not wild about them. One will probably make way for something else one day.
 
For a carry gun for myself, I really only buy stainless. I just sweat a lot, and I think my skin oils or something must be corrosive. A blued carry gun would be a royal pain for me as I would need to carry a silicon cloth in my back pocket to keep it wiped down. My main HD gun is an FNP-45 - polymer frame and stainless slide. Pocket gun is a SIG P232 but in all stainless.

Blued for a range gun is okay for me - one of my Ruger GP100's is blued. I just make sure to be really thorough with wiping it down with oil before storing it between shooting sessions.

P.S. I have a Taurus PT1911 stainless and really love it - great shooter and no problems after a few thousand rounds now.
 
I didn't see anything in the OP's post to indicate he was going to be using the gun for carrying purposes. If so, your body heat and the humidity created when you sweat will go to work on a blued gun.

I currently have the stainless Taurus 1911 as well. I traded the blued one I had for it. I absolutely love the gun.
 
The OP lives in Richland Wash affectionately refered to as
one of the Dry *hities ahem.... it's a dry climate It's on the
Dry Side of wash state. I grew up north of there - had a S&W
MOdel 18 in my youth - rust wasn't a problem with it.

FYI/SWIW and all that

Randall
 
Blued finishes really are no problem, unless you plan to use the gun for anything.
 
Thanks for the replies. I will not be carrying the 1911, not now at least.

Thanks for the gun care advise. Yes, I also apply a thin film of oil on the blued guns I have, after cleaning them after every shoot. I guess I was doing the right thing. Wow! I must be good, I must be made to own guns.:what::rolleyes:
 
[Crotchety Old Man Voice] Stainless Guns are just a fad... they are for young whippersnappers who don't know how to take care of a real gun... when I was your age, we only had blued guns, and we lubricated them with whale oil, and were happy to get it... I even hear they are making guns out of aluminum and plastic nowadays... what will they think of next?[/Crotchety Old Man Voice]

Seriously, there is nothing like fine blued steel and walnut... but for carry, stainless all the way. If you dropped or scratched you finely blued gun, it was all over but the crying... with stainless, you can buff it right out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top