Suggestions for first black powder pistol?

[zaboomafoozarg]

Hello, everyone.

I've been interested in owning a black powder pistol for as long as I can remember. Some day I'll get a rifle too, of course.

But for now, I'm interested in which type of pistol you would advise for a starter.

I definitely want a percussion one, (not a revolver) and I don't want one of those novelty pea-shooting derringers, despite how cool they are.

Cheap is good, too, but I'd rather steer clear from anything reputed to be extremely poor quality.

So, I seek your advice. I've looked on Dixiegunworks and several other places, but Google only scratches the surface when trying to shop around for both deals and information. Nothing beats input from people who know what they're talking about.

That's why I'm here. Your input would be much appreciated.

And if you know of any good websites or hot deals to link me to, that would be all the better.

Much obliged.

 

[bigbadgun]

Cheap is good?
Yes you can get a cheap blackpowder pistol.
But let me recommend a Remington. If you have no experience with black powder pistols go for a steel frame remington. And then later when you have it all figured out check out the Colts.
Dixie is good but also check out cabelas they always have good deals.

 

[MICHAEL T]

I definitely want a percussion one, (not a revolver)

Well get a pistol Kit from Dixie And assemble it your self Their pretty simple to build You need to finish the wood and maybe the blue or brown barrel A few nights and you would be ready . Nothing better than one you put together

 

[BHP FAN]

Dixie's Kentucky pistol would be a good place to start.

 

[BHP FAN]

PH0700 Traditions Kentucky Pistol Kit $161.00



Click to enlarge
The Traditions Kentucky pistol kit is a fullstock with select hardwood. This is a .50 caliber percussion with a 9 3/4" octagon barrel. Features brass furniture, color casehardend lock, lockplate engraved. Single trigger. Kit does not come with blued barrel. This is skill level 1. Manufactured in Spain. THIS PRODUCT CANNOT BE SHIPPED TO NEW JERSEY OR CANADA.

note: there IS a barrel ... it's just not blued.

 

[zaboomafoozarg]

Thanks for the fast replies. BHP FAN, that's actually the one I was most leaning toward, believe it or not. I trust that dixie is a reputable store, then, and this is about as cheap as this gun can be reliably found?


Again, I appreciate the answers to my questions.

Feel free to keep the advice a-comin'.

 

[higene]

Starter Pistol

I would recommend a Lyman Plains pistol. They are a quality firearm and they come completed or in a kit for a reasonable price.

You asked - That's my opinion

 

[mykeal]

Dixie Gun Works is indeed a reputable organization. They've been around a long time, one of the pioneers in outfitting modern black powder shooting sports, and they have an excellent customer support organization. Their catalog is one of the standard reference books on black powder; the back contains a great deal of interesting and worthwhile information. It's well worth getting even if you don't buy from them.

As for the pistol itself, their store brand guns are well thought of and popular; quality is good to very good in every case. I'd refrain from use of the word 'cheap' as that implies poor quality and it's unfair in this case. 'Inexpensive' would be a better term.

Having said that, the Lyman Great Plains pistol is excellent quality but costs quite a bit more. In my personal opinion it's worth the money, but opinions are often worth what they cost. You will not be unhappy with either a Dixie Gun Works store brand gun or the Lyman pistol. The Lyman can be had from several outlets; Midsouth Shooters Supply has a good reputation and good prices. They also sell Traditions guns; their Traditions Trapper is an excellent choice as well.

 

[BullRunBear]

Take a look at the Traditions Trapper pistol. It's available from several outlets. I prefer the balance of its quasi dueling pistol style compared to the Kentucky or plains style but, if possible, try handling both types. Also I like having the double set triggers and adjustable rear sight.

Jeff

 

[bigbadgun]

Sorry about that zaboom I guess I should have read the entire post.

 

[arcticap]

Here's a great deal on a laminated Traditions .50 Buckskinner for $149 in the Traditions Bargain Bin.

http://www.traditionsfirearms.com/eshop/10Expand.asp?ProductCode=P13600

Note that Traditions will be closed from 12/23 - 1/3.
And don't forget to buy an extra nipple for it!

 

[Steven Youngblood]

Get a Colt walker replica.
Might as well start at the top.
60 grains per load, as efective as a rifle at 100 yards.
I know it is a revolver, but WHAT a gun.

 

[GENTLEMAN OF THE CHARCOAL]

With the user name he chose he'd better get a Walker. He's probably gonna need it. (!!)....

 

[zaboomafoozarg]

I don't understand. ~__^

 

[GENTLEMAN OF THE CHARCOAL]

Just joking around with you!! Get your gun and enjoy!!....

 

[mickdk2]

If you go the kit route take your time and have fun. It'll be worth it.