3000 pages and the author admits that the *calculus* doesn't even work that it doesn't even answer the question of killing to stop a nuclear holocaust.
He did not say that it did not work at all - its just that different people using it will often get different results.
I don't see it as a waste at all. There are plenty of people who say violence is never the answer, and some who seem to think it is always the answer.
He set out to see if he could come up with a good system to determine when violence is justified and when it is not.
Plenty of people on here, myself included, think it is 100% ok to shoot someone who is stealing your car.
Some say "thats what insurance is for" but I would counter that my car is older and paid for and if it is stolen, it is a total loss - even if it is insured, I would be lucky to get $1500 for it - yet, I know it is reliable, I know what has been done to it and to me, its worth more than that.
So if someone stole my car now, with no job, no way to replace it, I would be in a seriously bad place. How do I get a job? How do I go sell my consulting services?
Some people will say its just not worth it to shoot someone over just an old car. They are probably right. But that car is food in my sons mouth, and it is dentistry and shots and clothing to him. If I got set back and could not get a job that came up, I might have to raise him in a worse place, where he will have less opportunity and more exposure to dangerous and corrosive influence.
To me, thats worth shooting someone over.
I would definately read the book.
And I agree with what he said - it will not give you all the answers, but it will hopefully slow down your thinking process and make you think about killing.
Think of this - there are lots of things going on in this country that far and away exceed what drove the founders to throw off King Georges yoke and set off as criminals to build a new country.
Yet they say - good men will suffer injustice so long as they are sufferable rather than shed blood (paraphrase). How do we know when the time is right? What injustice will cause us to take up arms? Maybe just against a corrupt sheriff, maybe to depose a despotic judge, or free a man wrongly condemned.
We ought think long and hard on these things and know the answer long before we need to.