Uberti Cattleman II

Not open for further replies.

deadeye dick

Mar 5, 2010
Easley S.C.
Was at Cabelas today checking out the Cattleman .357 brass models. Noticed they had the Cattleman II. Is this a new design of the old model Cattleman? Also will it shoot .38 sp also like my Blackhawk? Thought up these questions after I left the store so i'm asking here.

Happy turkey day to all.
The Cattleman II features a trigger actuated transient firing pin on the hammer to theoretically prevent AD/ND if resting on a live round. Most purists are not fond of it, but some people like to be able to load six and treat it like a New Model Blackhawk.
I had a 1995-vintage Uberti SAA .45 Colt replica with a 4 5/8” barrel. It was a nice gun, fit and finish were very good, some color case hardening on the frame, etc. IMHO Uberti makes some nice stuff for sure.

Many years ago I sold it to a friend who moved to far Northern Idaho as a carrying-about piece on his patch of land. As far as I know it’s still 4-clicking along :thumbup:.

Stay safe.
While I like the idea of a more true to form 1873 that can theoretically load 6 six up, I'm not too keen on all the moving pieces.

For me, if I want to carry 6, I'll pack a Blackhawk. If I want to get the 4 click action of a Colt clone, I'll stick with the Pietta Great Western II.

The Cattleman are finely made. I do like the workman finish on them, but I'm not super jazzed about the new safety.

As others have said, .38 special is fine out of any .357.
deadeye dick

I have an older Beretta Stampede (made by Uberti), in .45 Colt and it uses the transfer bar firing system. It's very well built and nicely finished. I still load 5 rounds out of habit as I have a couple of vintage Ruger Single Actions that have the older lock work.

I've got a Cimarron version (Cattleman II) in 45 Colt w/the floating firing pin. Have put nearly 1k rounds through it since I got it (about a year) and no problems. For the range it's fine...but I would never trust any safety (other than a transfer) if I were carrying with all 6 loaded...but that's just me.

However, all else being equal I would prefer the traditional 4 clicks just because.
Thanks for all the good info. and input. I have a Stallion in .22-22 mag and like it a lot. Fit and finish are great and it shoots well. Like the brass look also. Howie

This new design was introduced about three years ago. As the older Cattlemen with a fixed firing pin in the hammer are bought up, the newer model, with the floating firing pin will be the only type Uberti is shipping.

I got a chance to shoot a couple of them a couple of years ago. One worked fine, the other was a bit problematic. If the trigger was yanked with authority, it fired every time. However the owner, a small woman, was used to squeezing the triggers on her revolvers very slowly, like a good target shooter, until the gun fired. She kept getting misfires with her trigger technique. I tried her technique of a slow pull, increasing pressure slightly until the hammer fell, and sure enough I go a few failures to fire too.

I suspected there was something inside, perhaps a burr, preventing the firing pin from extending all the way when the trigger was pulled. Seeing as it was not my revolver, I did not get a chance to tear it apart, so do not know what the final resolution was.
Not open for further replies.