$ Value of Luger?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Art Eatman

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 22, 2002
Messages
46,725
Location
Terlingua, TX; Thomasville,GA
Nothing special about it. Stamped as 1911 production. NRA 80%-90%. All matching serial numbers, including the holster and the two magazines. Disassembly tool missing. Family WW II souvenir, so I've no doubt it's "real".

Any horseback guesstimates of approximate value?

Art
 
I'd hazard a guess that you could ask between $1100 up to $2000 depending on who's buying...if'n you were thinking of selling it.

Probably have it appraised a bit higher with 2 matching magazines, holster, etc. if they're also in the 80-90%, if it were for insurance purposes and gonna be left to the grandkids (or whatever). If you could add documentation, who knows?

Of course I could be wrong, it is Pre WWI mfg. date so it survived the two big ones to be brought home in good condition.

Adios
 
I don't know a whole lot about Lugers. I have shopped around for a shooter on and off for a couple years. That seems very high to me. I have seen mismatched shooters going for around $500 and matching numbers going for a couple hundred more.
But, that is coming from someone who doesn't know much about the subject.

These guys would know, get back to us with your findings.
http://www.lugerforum.com/

I have always heard that this guy is the Luger guru and have actually called and talked to him on the phone. He was also featured on "Tales of the Gun".
http://www.worldoflugers.com/index.htm
 
Actually Baba, you look like you are very close. I guess it has been awhile since I looked into the matter.
 
1911 AND two matching mags/holster I'd say you are in the 1500-2000 category easily.

Art, some numbered authentic holsters sell for 3-400 at auction.

I asked Harley Nolden about researching lugers and he gave me some websites to look up. There is as much to know and learn about lugers as any other MFG, and many times, thanks to 2 world wars there is a LOT of obscure info about them.

Since the E. German Vupo and Black widow guns came into the market, matched # lugers are more valuable.

Do a LOT of homework before you make an offer. A mismatched re-worked ww1 Luger is selling on gunbroker for 1200, and the frame doesn't even match the rest of the parts.
 
Thanks, guys. This is one my father brought back in 1945. I figured the matching numbers made a difference.

I went to the lugerforum site and downloaded the info sheets. Next trip to Terlingua, I'll get it all together for the info and a better judgement as to relative condition.

It shoots good. :)

Art
 
I too have a family heirloom Luger. Mine is a 1916 model. All numbers match, of course. I've put in new springs, because the trigger return spring was missing, and the mainspring was from a Walther, it was a bit too long, but worked as a field replacement. I also had to replace the grips. My grandfather picked it up off a dead officer, and the grips were split and rotting. He replaced them with some plastic jobs that were horrible. I replaced those with proper walnut grips.

I've put 50 rounds through it, and keep it clean.

I have no holster or tool for it, and the magazine for it is a WWII issue one, so it doesn't fit quite right. I need to find a good vintage wood bottom mag for it.
 
I have always wanted a Luger. As a young child I had an artillery model cap gun. The first handgun I ever fired at about age 10 was a Luger one of our neighbors brought back from WWII. I remember as a child, I read an article in Gun World magazine about a guy that worked on a farm all summer to buy a handgun; he got an artillery model Luger and potted groundhogs with it off the tractor. I cut out the pictures and hung them on my bedroom wall. About five years ago, I was back home visiting my parents and I went over to that neighbor's house and asked him about that Luger I shot as a kid. He told me that in the first few days after the war ended, his unit was assigned the task of driving around to round up nazi officers who were trying to make their way back home. I guess they had to be registered or something after the war as former nazi officers. Appearently the officers were also permitted to keep their sidearms (this obviously was back in the day when the concept of honor was still alive). So, he picked up an officer who had his Luger. He asked the officer if he could have it. The officer told him, no, he wanted it. Bill told him, that was his right, and he wouldn't take it from him, but before he got done with this registration process, someone would probably take it away from him. The officer thought about it and said that since he asked him politely and didn't try to manhandle him, he would give it to him. So, Bill had the whole thing; holster, spare mag, cleaning rod and whatever else they carried excluding the belt which would have been nice. But, Bill had an additional surprise when I asked him if I could see the Luger again. He went down to the basement and returned with two Lugers. The one I had previously fired and an artillary model also complete with the holster and all the stuff (no belt or stock or snail drum) He said that one of his friends was down on his luck and Bill bought it from him.
About two years ago now, Bill died. He never had any kids and I was kind of hoping his widow would give them to me or let me have first crack at buying them. The last time I was there she said that she didn't know what she was going to do with Bill's stuff and didn't want to deal with it yet. I will make sure I pay here full market value for them if I get the chance even though I am sure she isn't hurting for money and probably doesn't care about selling them.
I have no idea why after all the hundreds of guns I have bought over the years, I never bought a Luger. I guess I have just never seen one in front of me at a realistic price. Although from reading those links, the price has gone up considerably in the last couple years.
 
I just sold a 1915 DWM for $650. Unfortunately someone refinished it (really well done) Note the pull cord on the holster to assist in pistol removal. There's an outfit on internet that advertises magloader/tools. They stamp your ser# on it. Art,...Does yours have concave style cocking knobs?
 
Art....I was just curious. I'm by no means a Luger expert. All I know is they are masterpieces of individual construction, with a ton of variations. As a shooter they are no better than a modern pistol. The extrator is a weakpoint (hook breaks off) . It is also numbered to the gun. I would avoid shooting a Luger with all matching #'s. Just an amateurs opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top