War Movies You Would Like To See Made

Status
Not open for further replies.
A good ancient Celt movie.
One about Vercingetorix would be awesome.
I'd like to see movies made along the Timeline 191 storyline (with none of that time traveling AK crap, possibly starting with How Few Remain), as well as a movie with a slightly different plot but based around the same concept as The Disunited States of America (Ohio and Virginia on the brink of nuclear war! :what:).
There are so many conflicts that have been overlooked by the movie industry.
I'd really go for a lot of alternate history and straight-up fiction. Good, realistic fiction and sci-fi. Stuff that looks like it could have actually happened, but didn't.
By the way, a Ghengis Khan movie is coming out soon.
 
Korea!

i would want a Korean war movie and an alternate history of what if the Germans killed hitler with that suitcase bomb and stopped the genocide and was just imperialistic.

Marsh
 
I'd like to see the book 'Sing a song to Jenny Next' put into movie form. The book is allegedly the true story of a top secret mission of a squad of Marines in China in the 50's. They were there to destroy a secret nuclear reactor, and wound up destroying a second reactor that no one knew existed. There is lots of info on what the CIA was doing in China during the 50's along with accounts of American POW's in Beijing. It's a great read and would make a fantastic movie.
 
A series about the Pacific Theater using the Band of Brothers theme. I thought I read three or so years ago that Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg were doing to do such a project but nothing ever happened.

Is being done as we speak. Filming started in Australia last August and it is in post-production now. Should be out by the end of the year if we're lucky.
 
A good accurate one on irregular forces in WWll. Guerrillas of Mindanao, Popskies Private Army, the Cassock groups who fought both the Germans and the Russians, Greek irregulars. And stick to the truth!
 
1>a movie about the exploits of SOG units during the Vietnam war A la John Plaster's book.

2>A movie about the exploits of the CIA's actions in Afghanistan after 911 but before the arrival of Special Forces.

3>A movie about the takedown of the Taliban by Special Forces and the Air Force.

4>Buffalo soldiers.
 
I would like to see a Movie made about Marine Sniper Carlos Hathcock. He had 93 confirmed Kills. One Shot One Kill. He was one hell of an American.
 
4>Buffalo soldiers.
I think there was one mady by Turner, starring Danny Glover. I saw parts of it here and there. What I saw of it at least wasn't offensive. Can't say much more than that.

A factual movie about the 10th Cavalry in Texas would be interesting.
 
+ 1 for Marine Corp Gen. Smedley Butler's life story. 30+ years in the Marines, all over the globe fighting, 3 Medals of Honor and he concluded that war was a racket.

+1 for the 9th Cavalry Buffalo Soldiers in New Mexico during the Apache Wars. Several of them are buried close to where they fell in graves lost to time.
 
USS Johnston DD-557
Would like to see a movie about CMDR. Ernest Evans and the USS Johnston during the Battle of Leyte Gulf. Sorta like David vs. Goliath, but with tin cans and Japanese capital ships.
Agreed entirely! From Wiki:

"In the battle, the very powerful force of Japanese battleships, cruisers, and destroyers commanded by Admiral Kurita engaged a U.S. task group of three escort aircraft carrier units. The Americans were taken entirely by surprise because the U.S. Seventh Fleet, of which it was a part, had firmly believed that its northern flank was being protected by Admiral Halsey's immensely powerful Third Fleet. However, Halsey and the Third Fleet had been lured away from their covering mission by a Japanese decoy force commanded by Admiral Ozawa.

The brunt of the Japanese attack fell on the northernmost of the escort carrier units, Rear Admiral Clifton Sprague's Task Unit 77.4.3 (usually referred to by its radio call-sign "Taffy 3"). Ill-equipped to fight a battle with large-gunned warships, Taffy 3's escort carriers attempted to escape from the Japanese force, while its destroyers, destroyer escorts, and aircraft made sustained attacks on Kurita's ships. The ordnance for the escort carriers' aircraft consisted mostly of small high-explosive bombs used in ground support missions, and depth charges used in anti-submarine work, rather than the armor-piercing bombs and torpedoes which would been more effective against heavily armored warships. Nevertheless, even when they were out of ammunition, the American aircraft continued to harass the enemy ships, making repeated mock attacks, which distracted them and disrupted their formations.

In all, two U.S. destroyers, a destroyer escort, and an escort carrier were sunk by Japanese gunfire, and another U.S. escort carrier was hit and sunk by a Kamikaze aircraft during the battle. Kurita's battleships were driven away from the engagement by torpedo attacks by American destroyers; they were unable to regroup in the chaos, while three cruisers were lost due to air attack and several other cruisers were damaged. Due to the ferocity of the defense, Kurita was convinced that he was facing a far superior force and withdrew from the battle, ending the threat to the troop transports and supply ships.

The battle was one of the last major naval engagements between U.S. and Japanese surface forces in World War II. After this, the Imperial Japanese Navy never again sailed to battle in such force, but returned to its bases to remain largely inactive for the rest of the war.

This battle is often depicted as one of the major "what-ifs" in World War II. If Kurita had continued the attack instead of withdrawing, it is thought possible that the U.S. could have suffered heavy losses in troops and supplies, which would have delayed their capture of the Philippines. It is also likely that had Kurita's and Halsey's forces met, that would have set the stage for the long awaited "decisive battle" where both sides would have finally been able to pit their largest battleships against each other."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taffy_3

I urge you to take the time to read the article. It's truly riveting, and the bravery of the Tin Can Sailors is astounding.

I became aware of this battle from History Channel's "Dogfights."

To portray the Johnston's CO, Lieutenant Commander Ernest E. Evans, I'd suggest Tommy Lee Jones.
 
A non animated version of When the Wind Bows...

If you havent seen it... well worth it. It will really accelerate your disaster preperations.
 
The Tourist, make no assumptions please,

I'm aware of Sonny Barger's letter,

It was one of several from, shall we say 'unconventional' sources volunteering their services.

Bikers have excellent, for lack of a better word 'unit cohesion'. See the video of a knife and gun fight at a casino some years back. It takes major mojo/insane to take a knife to a gun fight.

I heard some years ago Barger's was one of several offers, none that I know of were accepted.

It would have been a unique operation to say the least.

Now days the bikers I see are generally ex .mil or Dr/Lawyer types.

It doesn't help that the bikes seem to run more than I paid for my first house.

But they are really nice rides.

r

back to the movies,

I actually thought Born Loosers was pretty good for an antiwar flick.(as in how not to run a war)
 
USS Johnston DD-557
Would like to see a movie about CMDR. Ernest Evans and the USS Johnston during the Battle of Leyte Gulf. Sorta like David vs. Goliath, but with tin cans and Japanese capital ships.

Yet another vote for a move about the Battle off Samar. I would just hope it wouldn't turn into a hollow "CGI Spectacular", and instead focus on the bravery and courage of the men who fought in that desperate engagement.

For fiction, I always thought Tom Clancy's Red Storm Rising would be pretty good. I am looking forward to seeing Without Remorse, which is suppposed to be released sometime in '08.
 
"A good ancient Celt movie.
One about Vercingetorix would be awesome."

Yes, again I agree -- a good movie about Vercingetorix and the siege of Alesia would be great... not like that hideous Christopher Lambert film Druids from a couple years back....

"a Ghengis Khan movie is coming out soon."
Actually, there's one out now, called Mongol: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0416044/

Apparently, it's pretty good.... almost certainly better than The Conqueror, but that's not saying much.... :uhoh:
 
woerm said:
I'm aware of Sonny Barger's letter

And I'm glad we had an additional chance to exchange ideas. I do think I've been here long enough for people to know where I stand on issues, coupled with my bizarre sense of humor.

Sonny is a brilliant man. He would have succeeded in anything. And I believe a movie would have helped people with the stereotype.

Let me proffer this. I am a member of several forums, although that's changing along with my age. I like it here and in forums related to my job.

In that regard, I correspond with many co-members, privately and on the telephone.

In many cases, when that person simply believes me to be a retired credit manager (very true), I get a certain tone in their responses.

I am also open on being bipolar and a club member. After all these decades, I still get the old townie insult, "You guys think you're so tough..."

As a credit manager I get a polite debate. As a biker I get derision. Same guy.

Now, imagine life for Sonny Barger. No matter what other things he has done (which include inventing the high-mileage little car called "The Sparrow") he will always be known as the president of one of the toughest clubs in history. That's not fair.

He's also ex-military, an inventor and an author. But you will hear the epithets long before you hear the rest of the truth.

In many ways I became an aggressive, tenacious credit manager, saving several companies and re-couping tens of millions of dollars for clients, because as a boy I read about the exploits of Sonny Barger. I learned that if a 5' 7" brawler could galvanize an important life it was foolish for me to hide under my bed.

I think it's a good plot for a movie, if they could tell it honestly.
 
There are more than enough WWII or Vietnam movies. What I would like to see is a factual recount of something from Iraq or Afghanistan, without all of the touchy feely cheese, political commentary, and with a high degree of technical accuracy.

On a side note, apparently "Generation Kill" is supposed to be pretty good (about Iraq). It is going to be a 7 part HBO mini-series. The only reason I am giving it credit is apparently they relied heavily on a USMC combat veteran advisor, who repeatedly had to over-turn and correct stuff the writers made up, to make it more accurate.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_Kill_(TV_series)

Other than that:

1. I agree, way too many WWII movies. There are especially too many cheesy WWII movies from the 50's and 60's, bad acting, Peter Pan plots, and unrealistic combat. Veterans laughed at the "The Longest Day" because guys were running around the beach like it was Bull Run- when in reality if you weren't crawling you were mowed down. However, directors were also heavily censored back then.

2. Rhodesian Bush War would be interesting, but I would imagine the filming and "theme" portrayed would get political. :scrutiny:

3. On that note, a movie about the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale (Dec 1987, largest battle in post-WWII African history) would be interesting- but again, how would Hollywood portray the theme? Both sides claim they won. On one end, you have South Africa kicking some Cuban commie a--, on the other end, the propaganda version is the "racist whites" got beat by Castro and this helped destroy Apartheid, etc etc. So in reality, it might be a tough movie to make. :uhoh:


4. This is a very little known battle that would make a good HBO movie- the Mayagüez incident from May 1975. It is actually a pretty sad story- the USMC invaded a Khmer Rogue held island to free captured U.S. sailors (who already had been released prior to the attack on the island). The Marines got chewed up landing on the island (it was heavily defended and the USMC was outnumbered) and tragically, some Marines were left behind only to face capture and summary execution. :(

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mayagüez_incident
 
Last edited:
Yeah, the fact that "Pork Chop Hill" and "MASH" are pretty much the only movies of the Korean War is a source of consternation for me.
I don't think people realize just how desperate the fighting was over there. As anywhere I suppose.
 
JohnL2, get Taegukgi if you want a modern treatment of the Korean War as a brutal civil war. Here's a clip of the first engagement:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxdMAt7uAlc&feature=related

Here's the scene where the South Korean forces are back on their heels and starving, before the US landings.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o5_VahwJrJ0

One about Vercingetorix would be awesome."

I was really disappointed in HBO's Rome for skipping over the great battle. But I guess they were on a budget and wanted to concentrate on the politics.
 
I like the idea of the Winter War of the Finns against the soviets but I would like to see the air war portrayed. Take the Finnish pilot, Ilmari Juutilainen, ( try and pronounce that twice), he had 94 confirmed kills and lived to a ripe old age after the war. More impressive is the fact that he never lost a wingman and he was never hit by an enemy bullet. (He was forced down once by friendly fire). The Finns flew cast off airplanes that no one else wanted, like the Brewster Buffalo. Obsolete when it was designed, the Finns got their hands on 50 or so and ripped up the Soviet planes that had been battle tested in the Spanish Civil War. Later in the Continuation War, when the Russians had more advanced warplanes coming into production, the Finns persuaded German to sell them some Me-109G's. Again, a plane outclassed and past it's prime, developed a fantastic kill rate when used by the Finns. Other Finnish pilots were almost as successful with scores in the two brief wars that would embarrass Allied pilots.

As for remakes, I normally detest what Hollywood does with them, for example: Pearl Harbor. If done right, I would love to see No Man is an Island, The Battle of Britain, For Whom the Bell Tolls, Away all Boats, The Enemy Below, The Hunters and some things that have never been filmed like The Mexican-American War.

Not very firearm related but I had fun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top