What is my S & W

[buckhead]

I was just given, by the widow of a Pinkerton Agent, a S&W 38, 5 shot flip open revolver with a 4" barrel. The patten #s on top run from 1896-1906.
The serial # on the rounded butt are 3350, then 399 is upside down.

 

[Jim K]

The only S&W .38 breaktop with those patent dates is the Perfected model, which is a breaktop but also has a push type lock like the swing cylinder guns. As a further identification point, it is the only S&W top break with the trigger guard integral with the frame.

The serial number would be one of those (I suspect the 3350) and would be in tiny numbers. The other number is probably a Pinkerton inventory number.

The Perfected Model is a highly desireable collectible. 59,400 were made from 1909 to 1920, numbered in their own series. Yours was made early in production no matter which number is the serial number.

Value depends on condition. In top condition, it would bring $900+, less if worn, rusted, or missing parts, or with cracked or missing grips. I don't know if Pinkerton marked their guns, but if so such a marking would bring a premium. If possible, try to obtain an affidavit or some other paper documenting the Pinkerton connection. Also, get a S&W letter; it may have been shipped directly to the Agency.

Jim

 

[buckhead]

Thanks so much. You are right, the 3350# is tiny, What about the plastic grips

 

[Old Fuff]

Those aren't plastic - as least as we know it.

The material is called, gutta-purcha, and its use goes back to the Civil War. A number of companies, including Smith & Wesson and Colt used gutta-purcha (also called "black hard rubber,") to make revolver stocks during the late 1800's and early 1900's.

Unfortunately with the passage of time they become brittle, and are easily cracked or chipped. The pair on your revolver were individually fitted to it, and are serial numbered to the gun on the inside. That kind of workmanship would be unthinkable today. As a consequence they add to the overall value, so be very gentle in the way you handle them.

 

[buckhead]

Thanks: