What's the chance of Hillary or any other president repealing PLCAA?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Aim1

member
Joined
Oct 24, 2015
Messages
2,310
What's the chance if Hillary Clinton or any other president repealing the Protection of Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act?


Could she just use executive orders to repeal the PLCAA or strip vital components from it?




http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2016/01/10/3737838/clinton-sanders-gunmaker-liability/




Clinton: Why Shrink Gun Industry’s Liability Shield When We Could Just Get Rid Of It?

BY ALAN PYKE JAN 10, 2016

With a new poll now showing Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in a statistical tie in Iowa and New Hampshire, Clinton renewed her attack on Sanders’ record of support for the firearms industry on Sunday. On CBS’ Face the Nation, Clinton again called on Sanders to say Congress should repeal a decade-old law protecting gun manufacturers and sellers from civil liability even when they had good reason to be suspicious of the intentions of their customers who later commit crimes. Then-congressman Sanders was one of 59 House Democrats to support the liability restrictions in 2005. He has since said the law should be changed. The Clinton campaign has hit Sanders on the vote repeatedly in the early months of the primary race. His openness to changing the bill isn’t good enough, she told Face the Nation. Sanders “has been unwilling to join the president and me in saying this should be repealed,” Clinton said, emphasizing that she and then-Sen. Obama opposed the measure Sanders supported in his final House term.

The law in question doesn’t give gunmakers absolute immunity from lawsuits, but it does void the logic underlying a spate of court actions that states and cities attempted to take in the late 1990s and early 2000s.
 
She (or anybody else) can no more repeal a LAW by executive action than she could declare Zoroastrianism the state religion and require everyone to be a believer.

Courts would dismiss such an action out of hand.
 
Presidents can repeal laws with a stoke of the pen ...as long as Congress passes the repeal and sends it to the President for a signature.
 
True. But the statement as originally presented didn't mention congress, and at least left an impression that a president could repeal laws unilaterally, which I don't believe is the case.

I just wanted to clear that point up, which apparently you did.
 
Yes. The only government entity that can repeal a law without one of the other branches permission is the court system.

People give the President credit for having WAY more direct power than he actually has.
 
Didn't we all learn how this worked when we were in Elementary school?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H-eYBZFEzf8

Didn't folks have civics or "social studies" classes in Junior High or High School?

No, the Executive does not repeal laws passed by Congress.

This is not a fuzzy, obscure concept -- it is the bedrock of the 3-branch governmental system, folks.
 
I think hso's typing fingers missed the "n't" on the end of that word. Just a typo -- happens to everyone.

President's CAN'T repeal laws.

They aren't the legislature, so they can't repeal them, and neither Executive Orders nor Executive Actions have the ability to nullify them, either.
 
Didn't we all learn how this worked when we were in Elementary school?

Didn't folks have civics or "social studies" classes in Junior High or High School?

I'm not so sure todays students do. Some textbooks I've looked at glorify the government as all-powerful, and the best solution for solving social and other problems. I suggest you talk to some youngsters and teens and see what they say. You might be in for an unpleasant surprise. :banghead:
 
Call me crazy but I make the assumption that Ms. Clinton would do pretty much anything to gain the Presidency...

Whether she's able to fulfill even one of those promises made will require that she first win the election (if not indicted first...), then be able to persuade Congress to do what she wants them to. As we've all seen, when a sitting executive attempts to do an end run around Congress -our judiciary is likely to stop whatever action it is that's being undertaken.

I long ago decided that Ms. C and her fine husband lacked much in the way of morals, scruples, etc. For those a bit slow on the uptake -no I'm not a fan of their past performances in public life. They certainly have shown great skill and gaining and keeping power (no matter how badly they behave when they have it...). I'm just one vote, though, so a bunch of folks will have to do the right thing the next time voting comes around...
 
yugorpk said:
The only government entity that can repeal a law without one of the other branches permission is the court system.

Congress can repeal a law without Presidential approval by overriding a veto.

Courts do not repeal laws, but can find that laws were never valid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top