When do the ground troops think we should pull out?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sure the media will find a service member who thinks cut and run is the answer, but every Marine I've talked to says stay the course.
If we cut and run those who have already died will have died for nothing.
If we cut and run Al Queda wins huge.
 
I'm sure the media will find a service member who thinks cut and run is the answer...

I'd like to think that we'd portray a united front but in all likelyhood they'll find some someone...

If we cut and run those who have already died will have died for nothing. If we cut and run Al Queda wins huge.

My sentiments exactly. While I'm not a ground pounder, I did reside there a few (three) months last year. It's important we get them to stand on their own and leave in a timely manner but to set a timeline and leave before the job is done would be futile.

Ed
 
I haven't (yet) heard anybody except the Republicans in Congress suggest we "cut and run".

Most people agree that (despite their individual feelings on why we went) to leave before Iraq is ready to stand independently would be criminal.
 
ceetee said:
I haven't (yet) heard anybody except the Republicans in Congress suggest we "cut and run".

You obviously haven't been paying attention for the last 2 years. :)
 
Often lost in all the rhetoric about the war is the simple fact that our military is an all volunteer force. Most of us joined knowing full well we'd have to go to war should war happen; all of us know that we, as part of our normal duties, will train for war and make deployments. And since we have to deploy, most of us would prefer that during our deployments, we do what we train for -- which is to fight wars. It's what we do.

Not to make light of what is a very serious situation (our current war), but, let's face it -- if you are in the military for a career, going to war, and being successful, is much better for your career than staying home ...

With only one exception, every person in my branch of service whose situation I was personally acquainted with, who did not want to deploy to Iraq, was resisting deploying for personal reasons -- not because they objected to the war on moral grounds -- but rather, for reasons such as a desire to stay home with their new spouse, new child, new car, didn't really like their job in the service, did not want the break in their off-duty education or simply wanted to get out to go back to school or get a new job ...

Of course -- I would never presume to speak for the reservists and National Guard personnel that have been wrenched from their civilian lives and in some cases, forced to endure multiple deployments ...
 
I'm a ground troop (Seabees), and I think we should leave when the job is done, and not a minute sooner. This probably means that I'll go back at least one more time, but I didn't enlist to sit around the reserve center drinking coffee.
 
I would venture to guess that an honest on-camera answer would not be gotten by anyone. Way back when God was a boy and I was a private, if some reporter had asked me about how I felt about the war, I would've told them what my CO would've wanted me to tell them regardless of what I thought, if I bothered to answer at all, and I likely would've opted not to.
You *do not* PO the CO, and especially Top.
They can make your life miserable.
Besides, you signed up to do a job. Shut up, do it and go home.
Biker
 
I'd like to think that we'd portray a united front but in all likelyhood they'll find some someone...
As silly as it sounds, that would require effort and an attempt at real journalism. What will actually happen is that they will find some soldier who is exhausted from thirty straight hours on patrol, or perhaps somebody with an IQ in the lower range so that they can manipulate him with a loaded question:

"Excuse me, Private."
"Yes, sir."
"I'm from UPI. Tell me, would you like this war to be over so you can just go home?"
"Oh hell yes!"

And then...

SOLDIERS SAY AMERICA SHOULD PULL OUT OF IRAQ
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top