Which Mags Wilson 47, ETM, or Tripp

Status
Not open for further replies.

xmanpike

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2009
Messages
452
Location
Houston, TX
I am going to purchase two good magazines for my 1911 Colt GCT. I am wondering what people have had the most luck with?

My choices are:

Wilson 47
Wilson ETM (Elite Tactical Mag)
or Tripp Research Cobramags

Thanks!
 
Tripp


I've been using Wilson 47d's and the 10 round equivilent for reloads, so unless they have something new out, I definatly prefere the Tripps. Polished lips and holds the top round a bit higher.

Check out Tripps website. The really go into detail onto thier mods to the 1911 magazine.
 
I've never had a problem with Wilson 47s or ETMs, or for that matter, Mec-Gars or CMCs.

In fact, currently when I go to the range, I make it a point to cycle between Wilson ETM, Mec-Gar, and CMC mags each shooting session. No difference in feeding, function, or reliability noticed yet.

If you are only buying two mags, go for the ETMs.

I've never used Tripp but I've never heard anything but positive reviews of them.
 
You picked the three best mags out there, IMHO. So the answer to your original question would be: YES! Can't go wrong with any of these - I personally have most of the 47Ds.
 
the 47D has the track record, but it has been bypassed by the CMC Powermag and the Tripp...that's why Wilson introduced the ETM

since you're only buying a couple of mags, you mind as well go first class.

Tripp makes the best tube, CMC Powermag has the best spring and follower
 
CMC Powermag has the best spring and follower

I really prefer the Tripp follower and spring (it is ISMI chrome-silicon). The follower has a steel insert for positive slide stop actuation, a feature lacking on the Wilson. The Devel follower on the CMC is good, but it lacks the dimple for last-round control like a Colt or the Tripp. The Devel also is know to sometimes "bobble" at the last round and gouge alloy feed ramps. Tripp makes a Devel-style follower ("flex steel"), but it has a skirt to prevent this. Very intelligent design. So with Tripp you can get either - a polymer/steel hybrid follower or a Devel-style, both superior to Wilson or CMC's designs.

For my money, 7rd Colt OEM mags, or similar builds from Metalform, can't really be beat. If you look carefully at the Tripp design, you will see in many critical ways it is closer to a factory Colt magazine than anything else - Hybrid feed lips and flat dimpled follower. Flush bases both built to 7 rounds, not trying to stuff in eight and compromise reliability. Metalfrom is having a heck of a sale right now on their 7 rd. flat bottom/flat follower blued mags - check their specials on their website and scroll down. I like Tripp's design a lot, but right now you can get five or six Metlaform mags for the cost of two of his Cobra mags.

Tripp also sells their followers and springs as a "rebuild" kit for other tubes. I keep several on hand if needed (but now I am all Colt/checkmate/Metalform and haven't had a need). They are $8 for both the follower and ISMI spring if you buy in bulk (5 or more or something).
 
Last edited:
you know now you got me having 2nd thoughts...maybe it was the Tripp follower and spring in the CMC PowerMag tube.

it's been awhile since i read Hilton Yam's article on mag selection
 
9mmepiphany said:
you know now you got me having 2nd thoughts...maybe it was the Tripp follower and spring in the CMC PowerMag tube.

I think that may be what he said - I did not read it but I think I have heard others cite it.

For the op and others, here is the page with the Metalform specials, scroll down to the last item listed:

http://www.metalformcompany.com/specials.html
 
here's part of the article i read, the whole article is a very interesting read from someone who sees alot of "hard use" 1911s

Magazines: After bad ammo, bad magazines are the biggest culprit in gun malfunctions. I have tried every 1911 magazine on the market, and my recommendations are based strictly on my experience as well as my expectations for service.

For a basic magazine, I always recommend the Chip McCormick Power Mag 8 round with the standard (.350") bumper. For 99% of your shooting tasks, this will get the job done. It has a durable tube that holds its shape reasonably well, a strong spring that resists a set when left loaded for extended periods, and good overall function. Its folded Devel style follower has some problems with some guns where it will jump the slide stop. This is typically a very rare occurrence when the gun is set up correctly. I have had hundreds of these pass through my hands, and they work well.

The Tripp Industries Cobra Mag, A8-MG, is another good candidate for an 8 round 1911 mag, and has all of the assets of the Power Mag. The added bonus is a superior follower design that is very stable and reliable (it will lock back guns that might not respond to other mags), and added tube length for a true 8 round spring column. The major issue I've had with these is that the tubes tend not to last very long and have cracked at the rear of the feed lips. Tripp has stood behind all of these mags, and I've gotten all of my cracked tubes replaced. Each generation has been better than the last, and despite these longevity issues, I still run these mags because they work very well.

The above magazines are the only 1911 magazines that I currently recommend. If you have magazine problems, look hard at the magazines and consider replacing them. Magazines need to be considered an expendable asset, much like the G.I. aluminum M16 mag. I expect a 6-12 month service cycle out of them, and I will not hesitate to replace them the moment one fails to feed or drop free. Don't get married to a set of mags, use them up and move on.

http://www.10-8consulting.com/article_page.php?articleID=13
 
I've been using Wilsons for years, but have found that in an occational 1911, the slide would fail to lock back after empty with them, especially after the mag was used for awhile. Recently I've been trying Tripp's mags and they lock back every pistol's slide, perform perfectly, are easy to clean, and look very well made. I think the "hybrid" style follower is a good idea, and may last longer than pure plastic ones. I rate the Tripp right up there with the Wilson, maybe even a little better.
 
I prefer flush fit magazines for carry, but use the ETMs in IPSC competition, they are easier to seat. All good mags, I probably get what ever is cheapest and available. I have used MidwayUSA to get most of my 1911 mags, http://midwayusa.com.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top