Hoffy
Member
Could someone please educate me why there are few calibers that are used in both revolvers and pistols?
You should also realize that all revolvers are pistols and so are all semi automatics handguns. A pistol is any firearm that you can COMFORTABLY shoot , aim, and fire, with one hand. Doesn't have to be, but thats the overriding definition. Alot of gun rags make the distinction in only refering to semi automatics as pistols, nothing could be further from the truth.
So, are 10mm revolvers..45acp and 9mm revolvers are readily available.
warriorsociologist.
Nobody is being judged. My definition is factual and correct. Thank you for your LEO and federal training, but it does not mean that a revolver is not a pistol. Federal and leo training does not make it correct.
GLOSSARY OF FIREARMS TERMINOLOGY
http://comunidad.ciudad.com.ar/ciudadanos/efontenla/GLOSSARY.htm#Pan
Handgun / Arma corta: (n. sus.) A gun designed so that it may be held and fired in one hand. See pistol, revolver.
Pistol / Pistola: (n. sus.) Traditionally, a handgun not a revolver, e.g., a single-shot, multi-barrel, or semiautomatic. In current use the term includes revolvers. Tradicionalmente recibe este nombre aquella arma corta o de mano que no sea un revolver, puede ser monotiro, politiro, de uno o varios cañones o semiautomática, ocacionalmente tal definición puede incluir a los revólveres.
Revolver: (n. Sus.) A repeating firearm in which the ammunition is held in a multi-chambered cylinder, which is rotated to bring each chamber in line with the barrel. Most revolvers are handguns, although shoulder-fired arms have been made using this sort of mechanism. See a picture of a Colt SF-VI revolver.
A 45colt and a 9mm are BOTH PISTOL CARTRIDGES., because there are pistols chambered for them.
SEMI AUTOMATIC PISTOLS
All Semi auto pistols, including 1911s and Glocks. Steel/alloy and polymer frames united.
and
REVOLVERS AND CYLINDER HANDGUNS
Revolvers, derringers, and all cylinder handguns.
Deuling pistolsDon't be so hasty to judge him and tell him what he "should" start doing. No offense, but just because you operate with that definition does not make it universal.
Personally, I must say the way I was trained (Military & Federal LEO), both "pistols" (semi-autos) and "revolvers" (well, "wheelguns") are commonly classified as handguns and fit your general definition (one-handed/non-shoulder discharge weapons)... It's a simple distinction, actually, but when I hear someone generally refer to a revolver as a "pistol" (vs. a revolver or a "handgun")...I immediatly liken it to someone calling a magazine a "clip." Again, it seems there are "different schools" of training...and this is just my experience.
Which of us is "right"...well, that's probbaly not too important...but it's also for neither of us to decide.
I would say go with the 9mm is you want to experience it in a revolver, but in the end, what real advantage are you gaining from a .38+P, both are almost equally effective with proper shot placement.