(WI) Owner shoots intruder

Status
Not open for further replies.

Drizzt

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
2,647
Location
Moscow on the Colorado, TX
Owner shoots intruder

(Published Tuesday, November 1, 2005 10:49:52 AM CDT)

By Sid Schwartz
Gazette Staff

A Janesville homeowner shot and critically wounded a man that police say broke into the attic through a roof vent and then crashed into the living room through the ceiling Monday night.

Kurt E. Prochaska, 38, of 3920 Afton Road, Janesville, remained in critical condition this morning at Mercy Hospital, Janesville.

Prochaska was shot once in the back by Michael L. Rainiero, 45, of 2520 Linden Ave., Janesville, said Lt. Danny Davis, head of Janesville police detectives.

Davis said Rainiero, his wife and three children were asleep when Rainiero woke at 11:24 p.m. to the sound of Prochaska crashing through the living room ceiling and falling 8 feet to the floor.

"He removed the attic vent and at some point while he was in the attic fell through the rafters and onto the living room floor," Davis said.

Davis said he wasn't sure if Prochaska was hurt in the fall, but Prochaska was walking when Rainiero confronted him in the hallway between the living room and bedrooms, Davis said.

"Both the homeowner and Prochaska are at opposite ends of the hallway. The homeowner verbally challenges him, tells him to leave, to get out," Davis said.

This morning, investigators still had not talked with Prochaska, but Davis said Rainiero told officers that after ordering Prochaska out of the house, Prochaska stepped into a bathroom off the hallway.

"That's when the homeowner retreated to the bedroom and got his gun," Davis said.

Rainiero told police he loaded the .380-caliber semiautomatic pistol that he keeps in his bedroom and cocked a shell into the chamber, Davis said.

"When the homeowner stepped back into the hallway with his firearm, Prochaska emerged from the bathroom and was now back in the hallway," Davis said.

Rainiero told police he verbally challenged the intruder again, Davis said.

"When Prochaska did not respond to the homeowner's request to leave, the homeowner shot him," Davis said.

From a range of several feet, Rainiero fired one shot from the small handgun, and the bullet struck Prochaska in the back, Davis said.

Before Rainiero pulled the trigger, Prochaska said something, but Davis declined to reveal what Prochaska said.

After being shot, Prochaska fell to the floor. Rainiero remained in the hallway, and his wife called 911, Davis said.

Davis said Prochaska was not armed and was not carrying burglary tools.

When asked if Rainiero was justified in shooting Prochaska, Davis replied that the case remains under investigation.

Davis said police are trained "in a nutshell" that they can use deadly force when they are protecting themselves or someone else from imminent danger of death or great bodily harm.

When asked if Rainiero was in imminent danger of death or great bodily harm, Davis replied that the case remains under investigation.

He also declined to comment on whether Prochaska displayed any threatening behavior before Rainiero pulled the trigger.

Police reports list Rainiero as the victim and Prochaska as the suspect.

Court records indicate Prochaska carries a long criminal record that includes burglary, theft, criminal damage to property and battery convictions. Since 1997, he has been sentenced to stints of probation, prison and jail.

According to court and Gazette records:

-- Prochaska was convicted of felony criminal damage to property in December 2003. The conviction stemmed from his arrest for an attempted burglary at Cork & Bottle liquor store, 2807 W. Court St., Janesville, in October 2003.

The judge in that case revoked Prochaska's probation imposed for a 1997 burglary and theft.

-- Prochaska was convicted of misdemeanor battery in December 2000.

-- Prochaska was convicted of felony escape in 1998.

In one case, Prochaska was arrested for stealing supplies from a hospital, where he was being treated for injuries sustained in a burglary for which he was convicted.

More recently, Prochaska was convicted of misdemeanor theft in Rock County Court on Feb. 14, 2005.

Police have arrested him at least twice for drunken driving. In one of those incidents, he was also charged with carrying a concealed weapon, a knife.

The Janesville Gazette was not able to reach Rainiero for a comment this morning.

The Dean Health System Web site lists Rainiero as a surgeon who joined Dean in 1994. He practices at Dean's clinics in Edgerton and at Riverview in Janesville, as well as Mercy Hospital.

A Beloit homeowner who shot a young man outside his front door was charged in 1987.

Rodney Yttrie of Beloit was convicted of misdemeanor reckless use of a weapon for shooting 16-year-old Christopher Gammons. Yttrie fired the shots through his closed front door while Gammons was pounding on it from the other side.

Yttrie said he shot in self-defense.

While Yttrie was not convicted of a felony in that case, it set off a storm of lawsuits from at least three parties. Yttrie eventually settled out of court with Gammons, agreeing to pay him $7,500, according to media reports at the time.

http://www.gazetteextra.com/rainiero110105.asp
 
".380-caliber semiautomatic pistol that he keeps in his bedroom and cocked a shell into the chamber."

Love the cocked shell into the chamber.
This can't be true a underpowered 380 had a 1 shot stop. not possible. Takes a 44 or 45 for that kind of performence. or at least a +P++ 9mm:D
 
I work with this guy so I need to be careful - but this is a great example of not talking to police until your attorney is present. They are already trying this guy in the court of public opinion. There is a difference between shooting someone in the back, and shooting someone and having the bullet hit them in the back.

JM
 
entropy ~

A human being turn his back in less than the time it takes someone who has already made the decision to shoot and begun to pull the trigger to spot the action and stop pulling the trigger. A shot in the back might mean a bad shooting, but it doesn't necessarily.

As for the rest, I'm glad I live in a state with a good Castle Doctrine.

pax
 
IF the story is accurate, the homeowner will probably be alright legally because of the intruders rap sheet, regardless if he shot him in the back.

Telling the guy to leave and he doesn't will also bode well for the homeowner.
 
IF the story is accurate, the homeowner will probably be alright legally because of the intruders rap sheet, regardless if he shot him in the back.
Not true. The usual standard is "knowing what you knew at the time." If the homeowner didn't already know about the intruder's rap sheet, then no matter how long it is, it isn't relevant to whether the homeowner acted properly by shooting him.

pax
 
Pax
That's not what I meant. A jury is much more likely to convict a guy who's previously been in trouble.
 
'verbally challenged him' ----then -- 'got his gun' ??? Not too bright.
 
It is such a shame that an intruder who destroyed personal property breaking into a home. Was told not once, but twice to leave the residence. Ended up getting his fool self shot. :cuss: And now the homeowner has to go through a bunch of legal mumbo-jumbo to straighten things out.:banghead: Sometimes things just do not seem fair. Makes me wish that the gun was a larger caliber so that the intruder would not have the chance to make his rap sheet even longer.:mad:
 
Follow-up story in the Janesville Gazette:

I live in Janesville, so I felt it nice to check on the follow-up, and there was another story. Since the Gazette's website (http://www.gazetteextra.com) isn't nice enough to let me link to the story directly, I'll just post it:

Was it self-defense?

(Published Wednesday, November 2, 2005 10:41:23 AM CST)

From what investigators know so far, they believe the decision by a Janesville homeowner to shoot an intruder in his home Monday night is within Wisconsin's self-defense statute.

Michael L. Rainiero, 45, of 2520 Linden Ave., Janesville, shot and critically wounded Kurt E. Prochaska, 38, of 3920 Afton Road, Janesville, inside Rainiero's home. Police say Prochaska broke into the home's attic through a roof vent and then crashed into the living room through the ceiling.

"At this point in this case, the doctor's decision to shoot when compared to the statute seems reasonable," Lt. Danny Davis, head of Janesville police detectives, said about Rainiero.

"The bottom line is that this person who was awaked from his sleep to find an intruder in his house verbally challenged the intruder to leave, and his perception at that time of that person's movements were that that person was not leaving," Davis said.

He emphasized, however, that detectives still haven't gotten Prochaska's version of events.

Detectives tried Tuesday but were not been able to interview Prochaska, who remained in serious condition this morning at Mercy Hospital, Janesville.

"He was sedated to the point that we didn't think that anything that he gave us would have any legal standing," Davis said.

Rainiero told police that he, his wife and three children were asleep when Rainiero woke at 11:24 p.m. Monday to the sound of Prochaska crashing through the living room ceiling.

Rainiero got out of bed and confronted Prochaska in the hallway between the living room and bedrooms. He told Prochaska to get out and turned on the hallway light, but Prochaska ducked into a bathroom off the hallway, police said.

Rainiero told police he went back to his bedroom, loaded his .380-caliber semiautomatic pistol and returned to the hallway.

Rainiero said he stood outside his bedroom door. To his left were the two bedrooms of his children. At the far end of the hallway with dark-colored walls was the bathroom where he'd last seen the intruder.

Rainiero told investigators Prochaska emerged from the bathroom into the hallway, and he again told the intruder to leave, Davis said.

In addition to the hallway light, Prochaska was silhouetted by a kitchen light. Rainiero told police he could see Prochaska about 25 feet away, could see that Prochaska was moving but didn't believe that Prochaska was leaving, Davis said.

"Prochaska did turn away from him, and he expected him for whatever reason to head down the stairs to go outside, and when he didn't do it, he was afraid he was going into another part of the house, and that's why he shot him," Davis said.

Instead of crossing the hallway and heading for the stairs leading to the back door, Prochaska instead turned and headed back toward the living room, where he'd fallen through the ceiling, Rainiero told police.

Rainiero fired one shot, which struck Prochaska near the spine, Davis said.

"The doctor took a position in the hallway and he had made the decision that this person was not going to get to him or his kids," Davis said. "When he told him to leave and he wasn't leaving, he felt that he had to make a decision, and that's the decision that he made."

Davis said investigators already have conferred about the case with the Rock County District Attorney's Office and reports that are finished will be sent to that office today.

"We routinely confer with the district attorneys' office on cases and look for their legal guidance and expertise," Davis said.

He agreed it could be a few more days before final decisions about the case are made.
 
Court records indicate Prochaska carries a long criminal record that includes burglary, theft, criminal damage to property and battery convictions. Since 1997, he has been sentenced to stints of probation, prison and jail.

Another parole and probation poster boy.
 
and while he 'wasn't carrying burglar's tools' maybe he left them in the :cuss: attic before he fell through the :cuss: ceiling.

I'm really glad we have the make my day law in Colorado.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top