To each their own
MOPAR,
I would try both at a range and go with the one that scores the highest and feels the best. Gun preference is based on feel, recoil perception, trigger, sights and looks as well as reliability, accuracy and firepower.
Both have good reviews and reputations. I have a SPRINGFIELD XD and think it is great. I have not shot the RUGER yet, so my opinions would be biased.
I would just try both and then choose. Both are good guns.
Jim