1911TURNER posted:
"Joe McCarthy may have been a little over-zealous...and he may have wrongly accused a *few* people, or ones that didn't have the clout to do anything except spew communistic filth...but he was absolutely correct in his assertions that communism was the greatest threat to America then...and it still is. I remember my old man saying that they'd better listen to McCarthy...and added that they probably wouldn't."
I have some other homework that may open a few eyes about Joe McCarthy. McCarthy has always been portrayed as being the bad guy, looking for commies under every bush, during the "House Committee on Un-American Activities"
McCarthy was never involved at all in that since it was the House committee and he was a Senator. He actually was called as a witness to testify in the Senate "Army" hearings, not the House committee hearings.
He was ONLY concerned with soviet operatives infiltrating into positions of power in the Armed Services, or the State Department, that would be in a position to influence policy (Alger Hiss, advisor to Roosevelt and Truman) or reveal secrets to the Soviets.
Movies and our revisionist history teachers, always portrayed McCarthy as a Gay Bashing nutball, looking for commies under every bush. The transcripts of the Senate "Army" hearing reveal everything we were taught, was B.S.
McCarthy was being hounded by Senator Scott Lucas from Illinois, to reveal the names of the suspected communists. He insisted and interrupted McCarthy repeatedly, demanding McCarthy "tell us the names for the record".
McCarthy finally said in response the following: (after you read the following, ask yourself, Did McCarthy mean spiritedly accuse innocent people?)
McCArthy: "The Senator from Illinois demanded, loudly, that I furnish all the names. I told him at the time that so far as I was concerned, I thought that would be improper; that I did not have all the information about these individuals...I have enough to CONVINCE ME THAT EITHER THEY ARE MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNIST PARTY OR THEY HAVE GIVEN GREAT AID TO THE COMMUNISTS. I MAY BE WRONG. THAT IS WHY I SAID THAT UNLESS THE SENATE DEMANDED THAT I DO SO, I WOULD NOT SUBMIT THIS PUBLICLY, BUT I WOULD SUBMIT IT TO ANY COMMITTEE--AND WOULD LET THE COMMITTEE GO OVER THESE IN EXECUTIVE SESSION. IT IS POSSIBLE THAT SOME OF THESE PERSONS WILL GET A CLEAN BILL OF HEALTH"
So what actually happened is, McCarthy was trying to have folks like Alger Hiss investigated in closed session since McCarthy felt the evidence he had indicated Alger Hiss was not only a member of the Communist party, but cooperating and transferring information to the Soviets while working inside the State Department offices and having almost daily contact with President Roosevelt during WW II.
All this is in the Library of Congress. Also, these transcripts show McCarthy was not the one to "out" any homosexuals as being security risks in government during open testimony in these hearings, as is often portrayed in movies or insinuated in history text books. McCarthy's friend, Roy Cohen was the victim of the leftists trying to embarrass McCarthy, by outing Cohen since Cohen was on McCarthy's team in the investigation of the soviet infiltration. The snow job put upon America by the left wing socialist sympathizers in both the media, and in academia, has been total and complete. There are conservative Americans that quake in fear of being accused of "McCarthyism", who totally believe that McCarthy was simply a mean spirited, gay bashing, red-baiting nut case, due to being schooled to believe the exact opposite of what the Senate "Army" hearings transcripst show to be the case.
In fact, the majority of Americans believe McCarthy was the Chairman/Prosecutor/Inquisitor, of the "House Committee on Un-American Activities". The misinformation about McCarthy "falsley" accusing innocent citizens just because they happened to be members of an unpopular political party, was a total and concerted misinformation plot. A great book to read with an open mind, is "Treason" "Liberal Treachery from the Cold War to the War on Terrorists" by Ann Coulter. It will literally shock you how badly we got conned as kids, and how it has worked so well that if you even think about defending McCarthy, you are automatically considered to be a racist, red-bashing homo-phobe.
Isn't it interesting that MCarthy is somehow an Anti-Gay Hate Monger, when actually, Roy Cohen was his friend, working with him in his Senate office? How could he be a gay basher, if he knew, and did not care, that his aide was gay, but outed by his opponents on the issue, in order to try and embarrass McCarthy???