Hmmm, good question. There are many good ones out there, however to narrow it down, I prefer semi-auto rifles. I've owned a Garand and used an M-14 once which I also fell in love with. I think the Garand for it's smoother lines, caliber, reload quickness and nostalgia value.
However, at this time my only long range/hunting rifle is a Remington 700 with 3X9 Redfield in .30-06. My fun/shtf gun is the SLR-95 (Bulgarian AK-47 variant, milled receiver).
I still crave for a good Garand though.