MatthewVanitas
Member
Greetings,
After much, much agonizing, I'm just about to order a Bushmaster Dissipator upper, M4-profile barrel on A1 receiver. BM will put the pieces together, drop in the boltparts, warranty it as BM, and sell it to me for just over $500.
I'm thinking I'll slap some A1 furniture on it, and plunk it onto a Stag Arms lower receiver. A compleat Stag Arms lower, sans buttstock, is $145. The same deal from BM is $259. So I thought I'd save myself $114 of ammo-money buy buying generic, especially as I hear that Stag is the company that makes receivers for RRA and others.
But the infamous "guy I was talking to at the range" warned that such a BM upper / Stag lower AR-15 might not work at all, or might actually be unsafe. Something about incompatible tolerances, "not MILSPEC", etc.
He also argued: "there's no point to buying a generic lower; you'll probably keep the same lower for decades, so buy a good one."
So, is he right or no? Will putting a stock-BM upper on a stock-Stag lower turn an AR into a hand-grenade or a wallhanger? Is it worth the extra $114 to have a snake on the side?
Are there any infamous "don't combine brands X and Y" out there that I should be aware of?
Thanks for any info. I was feeling pretty good about the whole "modularity" concept, but then along comes someone to fill my mind with doubts. Thanks for your time, -MV
After much, much agonizing, I'm just about to order a Bushmaster Dissipator upper, M4-profile barrel on A1 receiver. BM will put the pieces together, drop in the boltparts, warranty it as BM, and sell it to me for just over $500.
I'm thinking I'll slap some A1 furniture on it, and plunk it onto a Stag Arms lower receiver. A compleat Stag Arms lower, sans buttstock, is $145. The same deal from BM is $259. So I thought I'd save myself $114 of ammo-money buy buying generic, especially as I hear that Stag is the company that makes receivers for RRA and others.
But the infamous "guy I was talking to at the range" warned that such a BM upper / Stag lower AR-15 might not work at all, or might actually be unsafe. Something about incompatible tolerances, "not MILSPEC", etc.
He also argued: "there's no point to buying a generic lower; you'll probably keep the same lower for decades, so buy a good one."
So, is he right or no? Will putting a stock-BM upper on a stock-Stag lower turn an AR into a hand-grenade or a wallhanger? Is it worth the extra $114 to have a snake on the side?
Are there any infamous "don't combine brands X and Y" out there that I should be aware of?
Thanks for any info. I was feeling pretty good about the whole "modularity" concept, but then along comes someone to fill my mind with doubts. Thanks for your time, -MV