The woods duplicating the shape of the insert-style factory grips win by a mile, at least where appearance is concerned. Letts, right? I have been searching for something like that for quite a while.
Second place, the factory rubber with those black laminated wood inserts, look really good.
Hogues, ugh! I dislike their garish appearance, and in actual practice, the palm swells are too low, and the finger grooves badly placed, for my hands. Some Hogue autopistol grips are really good, but their revolver grips are no good for me.