Girlfriend Doesn't Approve of Carrying

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sometimes the obvious problem in a relationship is not so obvious to us. Sometimes it is "us" that is the issue. I've dated women that were exactly as Obsidian is describing-emotionally unstable, prone to unsubstantiated rage, wild & drastic mood swings.. I wrote that girl off as a "head case".. Well, I found out later that she started dating another guy after me, and she basically became quite "normal". Do I think I drove her over the edge and made her act that way? I can't recall doing anything specific that would warrant that type of behavior. What I am getting at is that sometimes it's the combination of 2 certain people together that brings out bad behavior from one, or both, parties in the relationship. Like mixing oil & water-it's just not going to work.

So, I tell you this-if you REALLY care about her you will end this relationship. It is the honorable thing to do. It might just be the combination of the two of you together that is making her the way that she is.. If you will quit being selfish, you can let her go and you will both be better off for it. She'll find someone that appreciates her for who she is and worships her EXACTLY like she is. You are not that person. Likewise, you may go on and find another girl that is a better match for you.. You are very young though and you SHOULD NOT be in a toxic relationship, or any long-term relationship at this point. Wait for serious stuff until your late 30's..

You already know she is capable of behavior that WILL EVENTUALLY land you in jail. If you stay with this girl, and you don't believe you are going to wind up in jail because of her then you are the one that has mental problems.

For now, I'd tell her straight to her face that the guns will stay and that while you don't want to fight about it, she just needs to come to the understanding that this is the way it is going to be. Tell her that you will compromise and keep them out of her sight as much as possible in respect for her, but that is all that you are willing to compromise on.

In closing-get on with your life. Stop holding HER and yourself back. Let her go. She is suffering just as much as you and you are being selfish by trying to keep her around. You both are suffering and you as the man needs to step up to the plate and do the right thing for both of you.
 
My Father told me once that if I could not see myself married to a woman I should not date them. If had taken his advice it would have saved me a fair amount of pain & heartache. If I can not accept a person as they are I have no business in a serious relationship with them. The next time she told me that she, "was the lowest priority in my life." I would probably ask her, "If you feel that way why do you stay with me?" I am older & tend to be blunt though.
 
ObsidianOne
Girlfriend Doesn't Approve of Carrying

Like so many wise people have already said, it isn't about the guns but more about control, especially when you pointed out that she grew up around firearms. You're young. Do you want to be controlled by this woman for another 50+ year? Trust this middle age guy when I say that it will only get worst. ;)
 
I appreciate all the responses, though I think some of them got off topic.
I do intend on continuing to try and resolve this, and am at least giving it until the main cause of stress (job issues) is resolved and then measure it from there.
I tried talking to her last night again, same response. Hysterical crying and yelling, refusal to talk, but insisted on getting her point across at first.
I can't seem to get a word in as far as trying to get her to be rational about the CC situation. I've left it holstered and in the bedroom, accessible, but not wearing it around the house and it doesn't seem to really be changing much. If it is, the difference is subtle.

ObsidianOne,

This doesn't sound like it has anything to do with guns at all. They are just one of the catalysts.

This is a hard thing to say, but it needs to be said. If you find yourself in a dysfunctional relationship, and you aren't married, you need to take a long hard look at what your needs and motivations are. Why are you staying? If it was really to "help her", it sounds like she would be much happier by herself. If it's to meet your needs, then you really need to consider whether they are being met, or are you uncomfortable with being alone.

These feelings can be sorted out pretty easily by a professional. If money is an issue with you, then your Minister, Priest, or Rabbi can be of great help. They frequently have similar training.

Frankly, I'm really concerned that you have turned to the internet for help. I believe that you will be much happier in life if you seek help from a professional now. Think of it as if your chest had been hurting for a couple of weeks or more. Where should you turn for help.
 
Like I said previously, things are not perfect by any means, there are a lot of things that should be worked out. I'm not at the conclusion that they CAN'T be, though I am getting close.
She was a sweet and understanding person, caring, always listened and showed interest in everything about me (I know, typical first impression), but shortly after we started dating, her brother passed away. This is the ONLY other topic that I know her to be as sensitive too, which, as far as I can see or know, there is no connection between the two at all.
He was not interested in guns, wasn't uninterested, just wasn't his thing. He died from a heart issue. Once that happened, she became a very angry, impatient, and hurtful person. It's been a slow transition, but it's been happening.
Like I said, this is the ONLY other topic that triggers the same response as the gun situation, which leads me to believe there is SOMETHING here that is being left out of the equation. The topic is literally like a lightswitch. We talk about guns, she's uninterested and bored by it, if it comes to me carrying, wham, instant crying, screaming, comments like "You don't care how I feel", "You never listen to me", "All you care about is yourself".
This whole thing is just utterly baffling me.

Like I said before, I am conscious of what is going on, and no, I am not happy, she isn't either, but I'm not quite convinced that it is a total loss, though it is looking that way.
I'm not going to just toss the towel in quite yet, but if things continue to progress backwards instead of forwards, I know that I may have to leave.

As far as the concern of her using the guns, I know you can never be too sure, but she is not the type to grab a gun when angry. I've seen her pretty out there, and she's just not the type. Her way of dealing with things is screaming, yelling, crying, slamming doors, or just plain running away. Anytime we fight, she gets in her car and drives away.
Very counterproductive.
 
You should be able to buy an awesome set of night sights now with the money you won't be wasting on a Valentine's Day gift!

Come on man!

She's flipping-out with hysterical antics, and assaulting you, and you need to come here to ask what to do about it???

Where is your "mature judgment" laddie?
 
Time for a new girlfriend, perhaps? Start looking for some hotties at the local range. If the ones at the range are already dating someone else, then take a look at the local women's shooting clubs. They're there...you just have to find them. :)
 
My EX girlfriend of 5 years didn't approve of my carrying, and got upset if I even brought it into the house.

In my experience, the issue will never go away, and will likely get to be a BIGGER issue with her the longer she's with you.

It did for me. YMMV
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top