She shoots and carrys a piece she chose for herself. I talked with her about calibers and about taking some classes and that was about it. I took her shooting with me and gave some initial instruction, for the rest, she's on her own.
I would no more pick a gun for her than I would for anyone else.
I'd rather someone else train her than that my ego get in the way (or that hers does), or that I pass on my mistakes to her and hear about it 3 years later. I still hear about $500. I loaned a friend 6 years ago without telling her. I forgot her birthday once 13 years ago and have not been allowed to forget that. Her receiving proper training in handling a gun is too important for me to get in the way of it.
She shoots what I do. A gun that she feels comfortable with, a caliber she has confidence in, and one that she shoots well enough to defend herself with. After that it's all fun.
If you feel Bruss flamed you, when he didn't, how will you stand up to your S/Os criticism? How will she respond to yours?
The objective here is for another potential shooter to learn to handle firearms well, to enjoy the experience and to choose a gun for themselves for self defense and sport. Some husband/boyfriends (maybe not you but many others I've seen) seem to think the objective is to impress their honeys with their manliness, power, or widerangeing experience, etc. Usually it don't work.
Nothing I've said here is in any way meant to be disrepectful.
tipoc