Rifles that kick like a mule, what you got and what's your work arounds

Status
Not open for further replies.

Paul R Zartman

Contributing Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2020
Messages
1,173
Location
Redington Shores Fl
Mine is my 1937 steel butted '94 30/30, after a few years of in the cabinet I decided it was time for her to go to the range. Grabbed some factory ammo and away we went. After 10 rounds my shoulder was throbbing, was black and blue for a week. I forgot about that kick, but I was smiling from ear to ear.
20200412_174532.jpg
Here's that butt plate...
20200412_174644.jpg
Here's my el cheapo fix...
20200412_174428.jpg
 
I used to compete in BPCR competitions with an Uberti clone of an 1885 Winchester high wall in .45-70. I used 65 grains of blackpowder and a 515 grain cast bullet. For steel silhouette matches, you fired 40 rounds either standing or laying down.

I put on a rubber/gel Limbsaver pad to avoid discomfort. I already had bursitis in my right shoulder from an old Army injury, so shooting a match really didn't help it.

IMG_20191222_183602001.jpg

The .45-90 used for 1000 yard matches got the same treatment...

Hv9c31r0TsS95CTnlSGXDA.jpeg
 
Every 300 magnum Ive owned/used under about 9lbs, 'specially Browning Abolts with the synthetic stock......Its not that they kick that badly, my .375 delivers significantly more energy, its that they usually kick REALLY sharply.
My solution to date as been to sell them, RIGHT after Ive installed a decent recoil pad. Im on that route again tho since ive agreed to buy another .300WM from a friend.
 
I have several Marlin and Winchester 30-30's including a 1958 model with a steel butt plate. The stock shape causes recoil to feel worse than it should, but I don't find any of them objectionable as they are.

Marlins 1895 in 45-70 was out of production for the better part of 100 years. When they re-introduced the gun in 1972 it had a curved butt plate similar to the one in this photo. Not steel, but hard plastic.

wm_902722.jpg

I bought the rifle used in 1976 and it came with some pretty hot 500 gr hand loads. I was young and dumb back then and I shot them. I kept that rifle for years and added a couple of others with the more modern stock. The newer versions were more reasonable, especially with milder factory loads, but I eventually concluded that the recoil was simply out of proportion to performance. My work around was to sell them all.

But that wasn't the worst recoil. That honor goes to a Remington 870 Supermag firing 3 1/2 turkey loads. Recoil exceeded 458 WM. Once again my work around was to sell the gun. I don't want a turkey bad enough to deal with 4X the recoil I'd get from 30-06.

Honorable mention was the 6 1/2 lb Colt Light Rifle in 300 WM. Recoil was sporty, but no where near the other 2. I've owned several 300 mags as well as 35 Whelen and I've shot 375 and 416 magnums. I can tolerate the recoil but I've come to the conclusion that I simply don't need any of those to do what I need to do. The hardest recoiling rifle firearm I currently own is a 7 1/2 lb, (including scope and mounts) 30-06. And I don't shoot it nearly as much as I do lighter recoiling rifles.
 
Of course weight and length has alot to do with it, my carbine comes in at just less than 6.5 lbs dry, I started down loading and that helped the kick, but lost the accuracy, but she is a old girl and needs the rest.
 
My TC Hawken with a curved metal butt plate is a killer with a 370 grain maxi ball over 100 grains of powder. I don't shoot a lot of those as a result. I have a slip on recoil pad, which helps. If I ever decide it is just too much, I have considered filling the butt stock with a bag of lead shot to add more weight and help tamp down recoil. I mostly shoot round ball with lower charges out of it, though.
 
I'm not sold on the prospect of selling a gun is a "work around" thats more like a "fail, I give up" situation. When you have a gun, and a need to keep it...and exercise its qualities...what's your work around to do this.
 
I don't shoot a lot of those as a result. I have a slip on recoil pad, which helps. If I ever decide it is just too much, I have considered filling the butt stock with a bag of lead shot to add more weight and help tamp down recoil. I mostly shoot round ball with lower charges out of it, though.
NOW...that's what I'm talking about...thanks brewer...
 
I use slip on recoil pads and/or wearable recoil pads like the PAST for the really heavy stuff.

That said just shooting a lot will do a lot to help a shooter. Shooting more gives you two benefits. First the more you shoot, assuming your not actually injuring yourself, the more your body grows use to recoil and will grow to where it will tolerate more of it both in both magnitude and quantity. Second shooting more you (hopefully) learn to control the recoil better, how much to grip without over-griping, proper stance and position, proper fitting of the gun, etc.
 
I don't mind a hard kick, the quick sharp ones can be the worst tho. It can be a pain to shoot or hunt with a gun where if your not perfectly behind the gun you get scoped.

The only kicker I have now is my 45-70, it's just over 8 pounds, with normal loads a marlin kicks worse. But when loaded with class 4 loads it has a heavy recoil, the vast recoil to. Still compared to a 416 or bigger it's not much.

For the 45-70 I put on a limb saver but with the real not stuff the rubber deforms so much you can feel the hard plastic underneath. It's getting a new on some day. But just loading light is the easy way to manage recoil.
 
I have an old mosin. I don’t have a work around because when I use it it’s hunting season (winter) and I’m wearing lots of layers.

But I also learned to shoot on a 12ga shooting deer slugs. I’ve never shot a rifle more painful than 3’ 12ga slugs.

Also, I love that leather cheek piece. Where from did you buy that?
 
Last edited:
I have an old mosin. I don’t have a work around because when I use it it’s hunting season (winter) and I’m wearing lots of layers.

Also, I love that leather cheek piece. Where from did you buy that?
I have mosin that I Sportsterized, lighter than original, slip on limb saver for sure...or that "strap on" :what:
Leather cheek piece...
20200412_210028.jpg
Ebay, sell left or righthanded, I bought this left used on ebay cheap, I'm right handed, doesnt bother me. I also cut a slot so I could pull out the foam cheek rest and get a little lower with the iron sites...
20200412_210546.jpg
I trimmed the foam
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top