Picking a Holster for new revolver

Status
Not open for further replies.

Thomasss

Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2020
Messages
1,591
Location
Wisconsin
I just bought a minty nickel S&W 586, 6 inch in .357 Mag. Now I'm thinking about
a nice holster for it. I'm not sure about leather or synthetic or whether I should even be concerned about conceal carry. My interest initially was target shooting, but now what else should should I consider? Any suggestions?
 
I see a trigger strap is an option. Did you get one? That was one of my concerns.

The Cattleman is a deep holster that actually wraps around the rear of the cylinder to some degree. I didn't feel the need for the strap, and honestly wouldn't worry about it with a longer barrel (like your 6"). Unless you think you're likely to be spending time hanging upside down. ;)
 
I just bought a minty nickel S&W 586, 6 inch in .357 Mag. Now I'm thinking about
a nice holster for it. I'm not sure about leather or synthetic or whether I should even be concerned about conceal carry. My interest initially was target shooting, but now what else should should I consider? Any suggestions?


Six inch? No, not for concealed carry.
 
How practical is a cross draw with a 6 inch barrel?

Easier to sit with. If you have a short torso it can make a draw easier than strong side with a longer barrel.

Cross draw works just as well with a 6" as a 4", if that's what you're asking.

Is crossdraw preferable to strong side with a longer barrel? That depends heavily on the user. I certainly don't think it's a bad option. I do have a crossdraw Cattleman for a 4-5/8" Blackhawk. It's a nice carry.
 
Revolver holster = LEATHER

Love my cross draw. Easy fast access from driver seat. Hip draw is almost impossible.

Thousands of styles and designs. Find what you like. Not an easy chore.
 
The girls(wife, daughter, and grand children) are usually asking me what colors go together, cause they don't want to clash with the fashion police. I once upon a time worked with graphic arts, advertising and printing presses and models.
 
Last edited:
Handgun hunting with a cross draw is especially easy. In a tree stand for deer,or back against a tree sitting on the ground. Your rig isn't bashing into "stuff" and you're gonna find it's a very natural position. Your rig stays holstered,with shooting hand just laying on it.

Also works in the rain better,which is a FANTASTIC time/reason to be handgun hunting. The rig isn't getting drenched.....well, at least until you "unleash" it,haha. Good luck with your search.



How practical is a cross draw with a 6 inch barrel?
 
Take a look at the Simply Rugged Sourdough Pancake holsters. They can be used IWB or OWB and what I wear when hiking with a GP100 (40-43 oz.)
 
How practical is a cross draw with a 6 inch barrel?

If the user wants to be able to sit, while wearing the holster, with a 6” revolver, cross-draw may be necessary. This will depend upon the user’s body shape, and whether wearing high-waistline trousers, or not. Sitting may be desirable for some hunting applications, and for driving a vehicle. Cross-draw may, however, depending upon the angle, and the user’s overall body size, make concealment difficult. At six feet tall, with a ~34” waist, concealing a 6” revolver, in a cross-draw rig, such as the Galco DAO, in its cross-draw mode, is hopeless, for me, unless I am using a very full-cut outer garment, larger than is typical for street clothing.

It is easier, for me, to conceal a big revolver with a straight-drop holster, but it requires wearing a rather long concealing garment, which is why I rarely carry revolvers with barrels longer than 4”. (I live in humid SE Texas, where is is often quite warm, or hot.)

Drawing the weapon, from a cross-draw rig, requires the shooter to be more careful about safe direction of the muzzle, while drawing, and while re-holstering. For example, a right-handed shooter will need to be careful not to “sweep” the muzzle across a hunting companion that is walking or standing to one’s left. While seated inside a vehicle, there is the immediate problem of a passenger that is seated to the right of a lefty driver, and a driver that is seated next to a right-handed shooter that is a front seat passenger. In Cowboy Action Shooting matches, there is a “dance” that a shooter must do, if using a cross-draw holster, to avoid breaking the 180-degree rule, with muzzle direction. The “Four Rules” of firearms safety might not call for a full 180-degree margin of safety, but CAS matches do have a 180-degree rule.

Of course, a cross-draw holster need not be made to carry at an angle that points the weapon so far to the side of the shooter, but most are.
 
6" is difficult to draw when seated in anything but a shoulder holster. Cross draws is sencond.
I carry 4.6" and cross draw works great. I have modified the holster slightlr, to change the angle downward. This helps greatly, in Cowboy Action, to prevent covering others, remaining within the 180° rule and "the "dance". I find it more comfortable when driving and easier to draw, also.
My one Blackhawks, with 7 1/2" barrel is carried in right hand leg holster or shoulder holster. Neither is comfortable when seated, driving is better with leg holster, but draw is impossible.
 
I
I just bought a minty nickel S&W 586, 6 inch in .357 Mag. Now I'm thinking about
a nice holster for it. I'm not sure about leather or synthetic or whether I should even be concerned about conceal carry. My interest initially was target shooting, but now what else should should I consider? Any suggestions?
If you think you might be carrying it in the rain, get a flap holster or a holster with the option to use a flap.
 
Handgun hunting with a cross draw is especially easy. In a tree stand for deer, or back against a tree sitting on the ground. Your rig isn't bashing into "stuff" and you're gonna find it's a very natural position. Your rig stays holstered, with shooting hand just laying on it.

Also works in the rain better, which is a FANTASTIC time/reason to be handgun hunting. The rig isn't getting drenched.....well, at least until you "unleash" it. Good luck with your search.
This is excellent advice...I'll add that for car use, it may not work well with most seat belts. For tractor use it's ok too. On horseback, for a right handed horseman, the butt/hammer will knock the hell out of your reins hand at trot and canter.
Lastly, 6" in bbl. length is a bit much for most concealed carry unless you're into shoulder rigs.

YMMv Rod
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top